The Truth Behind Donald Trump’s Tariff Talk
Slate Money
Deep Dive
What is Paul Krugman's view on Donald Trump's approach to tariffs?
Paul Krugman believes Donald Trump has a simplistic and misguided view of trade, where he thinks selling more to another country means 'winning' and vice versa. Trump has consistently advocated for tariffs, ignoring warnings from economists and Wall Street. Krugman expects Trump to follow through on his tariff threats, which could lead to significant economic disruption, especially given the integrated nature of North American manufacturing.
Why does Paul Krugman think Trump's tariff policies could be particularly disruptive?
Krugman argues that the North American manufacturing sector is highly integrated, with components of products like cars crossing borders multiple times before final assembly. Imposing tariffs on Canada and Mexico would disrupt this supply chain, leading to catastrophic economic consequences. Additionally, other countries may retaliate with export taxes on essential goods like oil and uranium, further escalating trade tensions.
What were the effects of Trump's tariffs during his first administration?
During Trump's first term, he imposed a 20% tariff on China, which was a fraction of U.S. imports. While the impact on inflation was minimal, Krugman warns that the tariffs Trump is now proposing—25% on Canada and Mexico—are roughly ten times larger in scale. This could lead to a full-blown trade war with significant economic consequences.
How does Paul Krugman view Biden's economic legacy?
Krugman believes Biden's economic legacy will be viewed positively in the long term, comparing him to Harry Truman. Despite high inflation during his presidency, Krugman argues that this was a global phenomenon driven by COVID-19 supply chain disruptions. Biden's policies, including the Inflation Reduction Act and CHIPS Act, focused on climate change and industrial policy, which Krugman sees as significant achievements.
What is Paul Krugman's perspective on the relationship between politics and economics?
Krugman believes politicians should listen to economists, especially when they warn of negative outcomes. However, he acknowledges that economic policies must also consider political realities. For example, Biden maintained Trump's tariffs on China for political reasons, despite economic advice to repeal them. Krugman emphasizes the importance of balancing economic expertise with political pragmatism.
What does Paul Krugman think about the future of U.S. fiscal policy under Trump?
Krugman is uncertain about the direction of U.S. fiscal policy under Trump, especially given conflicting statements from Trump's team about slashing the deficit. He notes that significant fiscal changes would require cuts to Medicare, Social Security, and Medicaid, which would be highly unpopular. Krugman suggests that the U.S. needs to increase revenue, but he doubts this will happen under Trump.
What is Paul Krugman's take on the use of cryptocurrency?
Krugman argues that cryptocurrency has no legitimate use cases but is widely used for illegal activities like money laundering and ransom payments. He highlights the inefficiency of moving large sums of physical cash, as seen in the case of Assad transferring $250 million in cash to Russia, which weighed two tons. Cryptocurrency, by contrast, allows for the movement of funds without physical weight.
What does Paul Krugman think about the Biden administration's industrial policy?
Krugman believes Biden's industrial policy, including the CHIPS Act and Inflation Reduction Act, could have a lasting positive impact. He sees these policies as creating durable economic changes that even a Republican administration might find difficult to undo. For example, subsidies for green energy projects have gained support from Republican lawmakers whose districts benefit from them.
- Trump's belief that trade surpluses indicate victory and deficits indicate loss
- Potential for 25% tariffs on Canada and Mexico
- Close integration of North American manufacturing sector makes tariffs disruptive
- Trump's lack of awareness of policy tools beyond tariffs
Shownotes Transcript