Nassim Taleb on Living a Good Life in an Age of Volatility
23:40 Share

This is an iHeart Podcast.

At PGM, we actively manage risk today while targeting outperformance tomorrow. So no matter what investment risks concern you most, from geopolitics to inflation to liquidity, PGM brings disciplined risk management expertise that spans 30 market cycles. Our active approach finds opportunities in volatility, helping our clients to navigate risk and achieve their long-term goals. PGM, our investments shape tomorrow, today.

So, have you heard the story about the prescription plan with savings automatically built in? It's where a family of any size can feel confident the cost of their medication won't hold them back.

Go to cmk.co.stories to learn how CVS Caremark helps members save just by being members. That's cmk.co.stories. When your company has a professional position to fill, are you really seeing the best candidates? You may be missing an untapped resource. Ideal candidates not currently job searching.

♪♪

Hello, OddLots listeners. You are listening to another episode that was recorded live in New York City at our event on June 26th. This time it's with the one and only Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Distinguished Scientist and Advisor at Universa Investments. Yep, we talked to him about how to live a good life in a time of immense volatility. Take a listen.

Nassim, what's your definition of a good life? What should we be aiming for? A lot of people think that we're programmed to be happy and stuff like that. In fact, we're programmed to feel useful. That's a good life. I mean, you don't have to be a martyr to feel useful. As a matter of fact, martyrs go too far. And if you look at their deaths, typically in history, you realize they could have waited a decade and the problem was to solve itself.

by itself, right? So think of all the wars. Hey, the Vietnam War took care of itself. So whatever. So let's forget about martyrdom, except, of course, in narrow cases where you save someone. So the idea is to be useful to others. And then the idea is to share your mistakes as you grow in age, to share your mistakes with society so they can build on it.

That's my idea of a good life. For a lot of people, good life is hedonic in the sense that they have a chef flown in from Europe to eat some complicated food that our friend here would not approve of eating. Non-steaks, complicated things with long names. And so that's a hedonic approach to things.

Mine is you feel useful. So whether you have a family and you're providing for them or if a lot of people don't have a family yet or may not have a family because in the past most people didn't have a family. A lot of people were orphans. A lot of people had children who didn't survive. So the idea is to be useful to the community in general.

So we talked about this in the market context at the very beginning. But does, you know, I feel this pull to basically always look at my phone to monitor the latest headlines. Sometimes I don't think like I'm the best parent because I'm looking at my phone when I should be with my family, as you mentioned. How do we...

be useful in a time when we're just being bombarded with events beyond our control. Okay, yeah, but you're, we're better off than we were 40 years, 50 years ago before many were born, perhaps even you, right? Yeah. So you don't realize that we spend about a century in front of a TV set or reading papers where you're on the receiving end

but not providing anything in return. So it was a centralized information era that started with modernity. And you realize, you should see the families eating their dinner in front of the TV set. Basically, you're receiving information. Whereas organically, in the past, the way we dealt with information was by trading it. It's like Twitter. You give information, you receive information. So you go to the barber,

Someone gives you information and then you go to buy fish, you give the fishmonger information and then rumors start going. And now we're close to that period.

Because you're not just receiving stuff, you're also tweeting. Although your spouse, I'm sure, tells you not to tweet from home. That's correct. It is true. When we're trying to get Joe's attention, we send a DM because he doesn't respond to anything else. So I'm sure he's tweeting. So you're feeling you're not just receiving noise, but you're creating noise. So I'm contributing. I'm being useful by contributing to the noise. Thank you.

So-- Very validating. Wait, but do you personally enjoy being on Twitter? Because I read some of your tweets, and sometimes you seem a little angry. No, no. Just a little. If I were tweeting now in front of all of you, the tweet would look angry, but my face-- Wait, actually-- I'm often giggling when I'm tweeting, all right? I'm often giggling. So the idea is to separate--

your public persona from your private life. By the way, before we forget, before you leave tonight, someone DMed me and said, can you please ask Nassim to unblock me on Twitter? I get these all the time. That's probably the most frequent message. Remind me before you leave. It seemed like a nice guy. They all say, oh, sorry, I had a drink or I don't know. Wait, we should actually ask. Because of Bitcoin, because I chain blocked. When you have a smear campaign,

You chain block. So the friends, if someone bullies you or you block their friends as well. Yeah, that's right. It was possible at the time. Wait, how many people here have been personally blocked by Nassim Taleb?

Not that many. It's not nothing. Not that many. It's a small number. It's not none, though. No, no, no. A random room in New York. I stopped about a couple of years ago from using the chain blocker. Yeah. One, because it had a lot of type 2 error, the false positives. And the other reason is because when Elon took Twitter, he banned these...

Yeah. So they can't operate anymore. You got to do it manually. Like the third party apps that you can use. Yeah, yeah, exactly. They could use to block someone, their friends, the friends of their friends, the friends of friends of friends, and all of that. Speaking of alternatives, PGM's monthly podcast discussing trends and strategies in alternative investing.

There's no question that Mexico's preferential position in the new trade policy will drive incremental demand for industrial real estate and will sequentially drive rent growth as well. There's more to uncover. Hear the full conversation on PGM's podcast, Speaking of Alternatives. This is what the market used to sound like.

Pretty complex. But today, with iShares by BlackRock, investing is easier. With over 450 ETFs, iShares gives you easy access to countless market opportunities. iShares by BlackRock. The market is yours. Visit www.iShares.com to view your perspectives, which includes investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, and other information that you should read and consider carefully before investing. Risk includes principal loss. Prepared by BlackRock Investments LLC and member FINRA.

At GSK, we believe that to get ahead of disease, you need to understand its root cause. And that's why we combine our deep understanding of immune science with cutting-edge technology. It helps us to create targeted therapies that match the right treatment to the right patient, transforming the lives of millions. By uniting science, technology, and talent, we work tirelessly to get ahead of disease together. Visit gsk.com to discover more.

Are you surprised that in a year of just like unbelievable headlines seemingly day after day Multiple wars going on not to mention the trade war and all of that everything else doge, etc That the markets are not crazier than they are. Let me compose a tweet that maybe i'll post is for trump one Okay trump one was taken. Uh literally by his enemies by his uh

And metaphorically by his friends. Okay. Trump too is taken metaphorically by his enemies and literally by his friends. Explain. So whatever he's saying now, he's pretty much doing. Did you believe that he was going to start these tariffs? They make no sense. I mean, it makes sense to get elected in Pennsylvania, but I mean, it's not the kind of thing you do really. And it turned out he meant it. It was not just, you know...

a vague, it's really an ordinary metaphor. It was real. He wants tariffs. So maybe he wants to destroy the American economy. Maybe that's his wish. And you could probably put a dent. And yet, but it's not work. Where is stock markets at all time high? Sorry? The stock market is at all time high. First of all, you have to separate the health of American companies. No, I get that. From the income of the American who went to a stock market shop or what's his name?

saying in your area, not Whole Foods, you guys go to Whole Foods, but normal people go to Costco, whatever, and then you look at your bill, right? And the bill went up practically for everything, and their income did not, and tax breaks to come are not going to help

Those who don't shop at Whole Foods because the poor people don't pay taxes anyway. So they're not going to get a break from that. So the idea is there's a lunacy in these tariffs. I can understand that we need to protect

Pharma, yeah, we have some strategic interest in this. Okay, you protect the industry You want to make sure you don't depend on China for other things, but it's a lunacy to try to switch with 4% unemployment in America plus or minus from high margin

I mean, you guys are all hard margin, all right? To low margin, right? It's a high margin audience. Yeah, we have a high margin audience. To low margin, right? Occupations. Right. So now we're going to make socks. Can you imagine the high margin? So making films, we're going to make socks. And then also misperception is the whole process of a lot of things in basic trade accounting.

Like they say, they're ripping us off. I mean, I'm a dentist, right? And I go buy my bread. It's ripping me off, right? I should make my own bread. And then the baker should be a dentist. So the whole idea doesn't stand on its own. And plus, you know someone is not very intelligent or not very skilled, right?

And you can detect that at, it's like arbitrages. You guys are from financial audience. And we call that trading against themselves. They do a series of trades that end up being closing a loop in circular, but it was a loss. All right. They used to call that Texas trades, but I think that state of Texas is

has been unfairly defamed. Texas trades in general. One of them is Texas Hedge. So for example, they have tariffs on components that you would use to build a computer in your basement in New York. But if you bought an Apple product,

then there's no tariff, although everything is made overseas, manufactured. So this is an inconsistency. So there are plenty like that. And there's also, what's his name, the Secretary of Treasury is like...

Secretary of Commerce. He definitely, someone should hire him for comedy because he was saying, first of all, the inconsistency. He didn't realize. He said, oh, we're going to raise so much money from tariffs. And then when you ask him, you mean that the economy will not adapt to your tariffs by replacement? He didn't think about it.

And he wants us to produce, to pay tariffs on bananas so we're going to have substitutes. Or he spoke about wine. He said, oh, people will buy American wine, but what happens if the price of French wine goes up? Okay. There's something called substitution. I don't know if

People do that in Europe. They teach high school economics. I mean, for children, where they teach them substitution, right? So it's elementary me. I mean, I'm saying that Trump should have hired, if he could find, people who have some skills, right? I can't wait to develop my skills growing my own bananas. Banana autarky. Sorry, I can't talk tonight. Okay, I was going to ask, you always preach skin in the game. Yes.

unlike us journalists. So I got to ask, you're still an advisor to Universa. What's been going on there? What are your returns like? Give us all the numbers. Okay, no, so this is not the place to discuss numbers. You won't get, right? But you can get a general approach and philosophy that I have now to describe in a way.

in a compressed format of what we do and how we do it, we can safely say that, as usual, whatever we're doing worked. In the sense that the idea is that you've got to look at the return of that hedge, you've got to look at the return of the portfolio that was hedged, because when you have an insurance on your house,

You look at the package: house plus insurance. You don't look at insurance as a tradable thing. Today I'm not going to have insurance, tomorrow I will have. How is that paying off? You look at the package. Insurance allows you to buy a bigger house because you know your total risk is lower in case of stuff like that. So it's the same situation. And the stock market rallied.

Which means that not only did the hedge do okay, but it wasn't needed. So you're like making money on your insurance. So net-net, that story continued. And we've been doing it now for, time flies. We're in 2025. 25 minus, oh, it's a lot, right? So we've been doing it for 18 years.

18, 19 years directly with Universal and before of course an iteration before and it is the same story we didn't change strategy for a second and we will not change strategy so basically that's what we do is the same thing

It's just that it's getting bigger. That's it. Well, wait. There are a lot more volatility events nowadays. Do you not adapt to that at all or take that into account? Okay, so let me tell you. If you look net-net, first of all, I don't look at volatility as volatility in my technical work. And Universal doesn't look at volatility. You look at, for example, you can have a tail event or you can have regular volatility.

So a lot of people are overhauled by regular volatility. And typically, what they call regular volatility, I learned the linguistics of that business, is when the market goes down. In the old days, when they're losing money, they would say, oh, the markets are volatile. Volatile doesn't mean it's going up. Volatile is not an absolute mean deviation. Volatile is negative return. So a lot of perception of things, of volatility,

Your profession as a journalist is, of course, very important. That way you can reveal bad stuff when it's made and things like that. Wait, did Nassim just say something nice about journalism? Yeah, yeah. No, no, there are a lot of things. It's an important mission. But very often the scaling doesn't quite match. Like, for example, people in journalism, and this I wrote about in Fooled by Randomness,

You should have newspapers, or let's say lengths of newspapers. Now we don't have newspapers, but you understand what I mean. They should be on days like the stock market crash or on the last couple of weeks. Newspapers should be that big, and the rest of the time should be half a page. But they have the same length, right? So that's the scaling problem in journalism. In other words...

You have the news 14 and a half minutes plus, you know, of course, the Bloomberg ad in the middle. So, I mean, that news bulletin should be variable with the events. You see the idea? It's the same thing with market movement. So I don't think that we are experiencing the real volatility compared to what could have happened and what we have seen with explosive markets. Yes. So, as mentioned...

multiple wars going on. We had the COVID shock. We had the inflation shock. We have massive changes happening in the political landscape, including right here in New York City. Is there an underlying reason, in your view, why it feels as though big things are happening? No, my whole point is that

To go back to what we call fat tail. Fat tail means the smallest number of events explains the largest number of deviations. For example, if you take a thousand people and you have inequality, one person will have most of the money.

Likewise, few historical days have most of the information. So this is entirely normal, but the point is you can't predict ahead of time that you're going to have when you're going to have these days or you're going to have the structure of it is though very, very stable. Things tend to follow a power law. So...

I'm going to ask a very basic question that I'm sure you get asked all the time, but we are all nevertheless very interested in your answer. By definition, black swans, I guess, are unpredictable and impossible to forecast, but what black swans do you see on the horizon? Okay, so let me rephrase it. There's something called gray swans.

Pandemics were gray swans. Gray swans means events that have these characteristics of a very small number of events determine a large part of the total effect. Like a small number of events, a small number of wars have killed most of those people, stuff like that, pandemics. So there's gray swans. And you can say they have a structure.

You predict them ahead of time, you don't know. Okay, but what we do is you can figure out if an environment is fragile or not. And in fragile environments,

You can say, okay, this is prone to break if there's a shock. Like in 2007, we knew that banks were fragile. Why? They were net short volatility. That's sort of my fragility work in antifragile. To answer your question, I wrote antifragile, which on its own became a monster, right? But the whole idea is to figure out what can have cascading effects

from shocks. Okay? As I wrote in The Black Swan, it's foolish to say what colored truck is going to break a fragile bridge. Okay? But it is not foolish to say this bridge is fragile, it's going to break one day, don't cross it.

Or invite your enemies to, you know. Okay, okay. What areas of fragility do you see right now? Oh, okay. So the first one is… I'm learning. Okay. So the first one is we have a… I don't know if you're aware of it. Maybe people aren't aware yet. We don't have a deficit. Oh, I heard about this. And you know that you have to borrow money.

to pay for the interest rates, for the interest, the debt that you've had before. And at 4%, 4% interest rates, 4% to 5% interest rate, this is significant. It means you can have a snowballing effect. You have to borrow more and more. And you know that they're not fixing the budget problem, except verbally. Hey, we're going to fix the budget. It's all the same story.

The structure of the political system, unfortunately, is driving us there. So this is one source of fragility, one main source of fragility, that the political system is not adapted to that kind of thing. So what happened in the Western world? It's not just a case of the United States. It's a case of the Western world because you've got to look at it as I describe an antifragile, think of an S-curve. Like China can have rapid growth because they're pulling people out of

their beautifully landscaped countryside to put them in apartment blocks. That maybe it's not pleasant for the people, you know, to live in boxes, but that generates a huge amount of economic growth. Okay? So a lot of people going up the so-called development scale, you're on the convex part of the S-curve. Okay? The West is on the concave part of the S-curve. So which means that

You have two car garages, except New Yorkers live in small boxes like poor people in the Middle Ages. But outside New York City, most people have two car garages and stuff like that.

You you you we can't you can't grow right and you don't have poor people so you have to import them from El Salvador Fana mods a lot of people you don't have poor people so so you don't to create that kind of thing and and and even and now you don't want them anymore You know, they don't want everybody, you know, so so they have a problem is that gross in America is structurally

declining, while at the same time, the debt burden is structurally increasing. You see that aversion. And that applies to the rest of the developed world. Because you've developed. You're arriving to destination. Why are you still borrowing? The problem is most countries tend to borrow when they're already rich, when they don't need it anymore, just like people.

See, like people on Wall Street, these people are on Wall Street, they probably borrow a lot. Now they're already rich, all right? Whereas poor people don't borrow. So that's a big problem. That's number one problem. The second one is China is representing the larger and larger share of GDP of the world. And so you've got to think that geopolitics aren't going to be the same. And you don't want to live in the wrong century. Think you're living in this century, think you're in a different century.

All right, Nassim Taleb. Yeah, thank you so much. Thanks for inviting me. Thanks for eating cow meat. And thanks for the steak. So next time, let's make sure either have organ food or bring wine. We'll definitely have wine. Thank you so much.

This has been another episode of the All Thoughts Podcast. I'm Traci Allaway. You can follow me at Traci Allaway. And I'm Jill Wiesenthal. You can follow me at The Stalwart. Follow our producers, Carmen Rodriguez at Carmen Arman, Dashiell Bennett at Dashbot, and Kale Brooks at Kale Brooks. For more Odd Lots content, go to Bloomberg.com slash Odd Lots, where we have a daily newsletter and all of our episodes. And you can chat about these topics 24-7 in our Discord, discord.gg slash Odd Lots.

And if you enjoy Odd Lots, if you like it when we do these live recordings, then please leave us a positive review on your favorite podcast platform. Thanks for listening.

Every business has an ambition. PayPal Open is the platform designed to help you grow into yours with business loans so you can expand and access to hundreds of millions of PayPal customers worldwide. And your customers can pay all the ways they want with PayPal, Venmo, Pay Later, and all major cards so you can focus on scaling up.

When it's time to get growing, there's one platform for all business. PayPal Open. Grow today at paypalopen.com. Loans subject to approval in available locations.

In business, plans change fast and your brand has to keep up. That's why teams rely on 4imprint for promotional products that deliver. 4imprint offers thousands of options including apparel, drinkware, tech, and trade show gear. Many available with 24-hour turnaround, helping you move quickly and never compromise in quality. You'll enjoy free samples, expert support, and every order backed by their 360-degree guarantee. So it arrives right and on time. Explore more at 4imprint.com.

Thrivent can help you plan your finances for the people, causes, and community you love. What makes Thrivent different? Financial services and generosity programs are combined to help you build a financial roadmap for the future, while also creating opportunities to give back along the way. Visit Thrivent.com to learn more. Thrivent, where money means more. This is an iHeart Podcast.