We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode How ‘positive masculinity’ can improve men's and women’s at work and home

How ‘positive masculinity’ can improve men's and women’s at work and home

2025/3/6
logo of podcast World Economic Forum

World Economic Forum

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
G
Gary Barker
L
Linda Lucina
Topics
Linda Lucina: 我认为参与性别平等不仅利他,也利己。它能改善个人生活、居住环境和工作场所。 Gary Barker: 积极的男性气质体现在以下几个方面:首先,在遇到骚扰或暴力时挺身而出,成为性别平等的坚定盟友;其次,积极承担家务和育儿责任,成为家庭中不可或缺的一份子;再次,重视自我关爱,避免因忽视自身需求而影响他人;最后,积极参与到性别平等的议程中来,为实现性别平等贡献力量。推动性别平等需要男性积极参与,这不仅是‘为了女性’,更应认识到这对自己、国家和社会的益处。我们应该从‘为了女性’的出发点,转变为‘为了我们共同的利益’的视角。积极参与性别平等,不仅能改善女性的生活,也能提升男性自身的生活质量、改善工作环境,并为社会的可持续发展做出贡献。Equimundo致力于通过研究、政策参与和项目实践,推动男性参与性别平等,并促进更健康的男性气质观念。我们开展全球调查研究,了解男性现状,并与政策制定者、媒体等分享研究结果。同时,我们也进行项目实践,评估不同方法(例如职场培训、父亲参与、青年工作和亲子工作)的效果,并与政府合作推广有效方法。此外,我们还开展有意义的、基于证据的大规模倡导工作。缺乏对男性参与育儿和家务的追踪数据,阻碍了性别平等,特别是护理平等的进步。因此,我们启动了《世界父亲现状报告》,旨在了解阻碍因素和有效方法,并寻找让男性参与到现有变革中的途径。促进男性参与育儿和家务需要多方面策略,包括平等的带薪假、强制性休假、育儿培训,以及将护理平等纳入衡量指标。例如,在卢旺达,我们与政府合作开展了一个为期16周的父母培训项目,该项目在减少家庭暴力、增加男性参与育儿和促进职场政策变化方面取得了积极成果。鼓励男性参与育儿,应强调其个人利益,例如改善家庭关系和个人幸福感。企业应通过调查、试点和倾听员工反馈,灵活调整政策,以支持员工的育儿和家庭责任。男性应积极参与育儿,并创造一个让男性参与育儿成为常态的环境。提高护理人员的薪资待遇,并增加对护理服务的投资,是实现性别平等的关键。我投身于这项事业的契机源于我女儿出生后,我深刻体会到男性在育儿中的重要性以及社会对男性参与育儿的准备不足。倡导工作中,结合同理心和证据,并鼓励男性分享自身经验,是有效传递信息的关键。我希望国家领导人将护理政策放在政策议程的首位,因为关注国民的福祉,不仅仅是应对战争,更重要的是关注彼此之间的关爱。阅读小说有助于培养同理心,这对于男性学习和提升育儿技能至关重要。

Deep Dive

Chapters
This chapter explores the concept of positive masculinity, examining its various aspects and its potential role in improving gender equality at work and home. It emphasizes the benefits of positive masculinity for both men and women, highlighting the need for men to actively participate in gender equality initiatives.
  • Positive masculinity involves men acting as good humans, being allies for gender equality, and sharing care work.
  • Men's involvement improves workplaces, homes, and the planet.
  • Shifting from men doing a favor to being part of the solution is key.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

Welcome to Meet the Leader, the podcast where top leaders share how they're tackling the world's toughest challenges. In today's episode, we'll talk to Gary Barker, the CEO of Equimundo, the Center for Masculinities and Social Justice. He'll talk to us about positive masculinity, what it is, and how it can help us bridge the gender gap. Subscribe to Meet the Leader on Apple, Spotify, and wherever you get your favorite podcasts. And don't forget to rate and review us.

I'm Linda Lucina from the World Economic Forum, and this is Meet the Leader. It is not that you're doing us a favor by stepping into gender equality. Your life gets better. The planet you live in gets better. Your workplace gets better. Masculinity, it seems, is having a moment. In fact, one of the world's most famous CEOs recently bemoaned the lack of masculine energy at his company. It was a comment that understandably got people talking, mostly about what on earth he meant.

When it comes to masculinity and its potential for a society, Gary Barker can help.

His singular organization co-created the International Men and Gender Equality Survey. That is the world's largest data set on men, masculinity, and gender equality. And it also publishes the only global report on men's involvement in things like parenting, care work. Their work and research digs into this idea that is powering the zeitgeist now. What does it mean to be a man? What does it mean to be masculine?

Is it masculine to be aggressive? In a time of political confusion and economic precarity, being a tough guy or even a bully might seem a natural way to get what you want, what you need. That said, Equal Mundo's work has found that both men and women prefer to be in places without that kind of energy. Or is a masculine energy something else? Could it be something powered by connections to others? What's equitable or caring? I talked to Gary about what it means to embrace positive masculinity and how that will

We'll talk about that, but first, he'll tell us more about positive masculinity.

It's all around us all the time, which is men doing what good humans should do. Stand up when they see harassment or violence, be allies for gender equality broadly.

They're our best selves in terms of doing our portion of the care work at home and supporting the care agenda. I would say all those three. Self-care, I would add to that as well, that we as men are not particularly good at. And often others pay the price when we do it. So yeah, self-care, doing the care work, being allies at work and beyond, being part of the gender equality agenda. That's all. Yeah.

You said that women's rights and the gender gap and all that can't happen unless we make sure that we sort of engage with men. Tell us a little bit about that and what exactly that means. Yeah. So what does it mean to engage men in the gender gap? There's a lot of men leaning in. Not a bad thing, not a bad place to start, but kind of I'm in gender equality for women. I'm OK with that as a starting point.

We need that happening in workplaces, House of Parliament, Congress, voting for the stuff that men should do. We need men stepping out, sometimes not being in places of leadership because we need to make equal number of seats for women at the tables. But going beyond that is to say, what men to feel a stake in this, to say, my country,

My workplace, the bottom line, the well-being of, again, my workplace, the planet, my household is made better when men are part of this and men feeling that there's stake in this for me as well. That's it really is to go from there's a lot of guys ready to the yes, I should do this. It's the right thing. I should say I do it. But to go a step further and say you've got a stake in this world.

It is not that you're doing us a favor by stepping into gender equality. Your life gets better. The planet you live in gets better. Your workplace gets better. I want men to feel that and to feel the benefit when it happens.

And I want them to feel troubled when it doesn't. So it's moving from I'm doing a favor to I'm part of this. Tell us a little bit about Equimundo and what it does. Yeah. Our predecessor organization we started in Latin America, Equimundo has been around now for 12 years with this

lofty, but we hope achievable goal that men and boys need to be part of gender equality and healthier ideas about manhood. We do research and some global surveys on what's up with men. We engage policymakers, media, others with the results of that. We do programmatic work where we evaluate whether different approaches, whether they're workplace-based trainings or engagement of fathers or work with young people or work with parents actually lead to better outcomes. And if they do, we work with governments to scale them up. Third,

Third, we do advocacy in meaningful, evidence-based, large-scale ways. We're about 20 people scattered across 10 countries. We do part of our work in the U.S., and we partner in about 20 countries. I talked a little bit about the research. Equimundo publishes the State of the World's Fathers Reports, and that happens to be the world's only global report.

on men's involvement in parenting and care work. And so that's sort of an interesting thing. We talk about women being half the population, but so are men, especially their role in care work and fatherhood and all this. Why isn't this being tracked elsewhere? Yeah, good question. So why haven't we been measuring whether men are actually doing the care work? There have been time use surveys over many years comparing men and women. So there is data collected. It's just not collected really in sort of agile time to say, are we making a difference? Other

Of the agendas of gender equality, the care equality space, we know it's so crucial. The care inequality probably drives about two-thirds of income inequality between men and women. And yet it's taken us a long time to say we obviously need to support more care services for households. Even when we have those extra services in some countries, they've still not achieved care equality.

So we started the State of the World's Fathers Report to say what's getting in the way and what seems to be working. What changes do we see and where might we find ways to engage men to build on change that's already happening? It's that. It's not quite a dashboard, but it's a light dashboard, let's say, to give a wake-up call every couple of years with new data to say, here's where we are. Here's what we think is in the way. Here's what we think needs to happen.

Otherwise, that gap in the gender equality equation kind of just sits there. And we imagine that someday men might just step up and do more instead of saying, well, actually, we need some strategies so that men are part of care equality, which is part of the global gender equality push. What are some of those strategies? I mean, one is, you know, kind of the low hanging fruit is you have leave policies that are equal for men and women, all kinds of caregivers.

You make that leave non-transferable. So his leave is his leave. If he doesn't use it, he loses it. That's the Iceland and Norway lesson. Even when you offer it, there's some countries like Japan and Korea that have amazing leaves and a couple of percent of men take it.

So we've also got to do the norm change that says men should take it. We've worked with a couple of workplaces that made it obligatory for men. You are off three months. Good luck. Your job is here. We'll help you with the backfill when you're away. Please don't look at the work for a while. Go and be this parent. Learn how to do it. Feel competent. Come back. We'll find you.

Parent training, getting men used to this in countries where it's not quite as used, that men should be at prenatal visits and present during birth. And from there, you know, really engaged in the process itself. Starting younger, making, you know, kind of helping both our sons and daughters see that if we're going to have children, this should be normal, that it's both men's and women's work.

I think among other things, those we found really do make a difference. The other is countries and workplaces taking it seriously and saying, "We're actually putting metrics to it. We put metrics to the things that we tend to care about. Why isn't there a metric that says by 2035 in country X, we will have achieved full equality in care work?" Obviously, each household will have its dynamic.

But on aggregate, we should put that as a metric. Sometimes we know it just helps to have the metric that countries feel like we're holding ourselves accountable for. I think the same holds for workplaces. If you're offering leave, whether it's government-supported and mandated, which we believe should be there, often employers offer more. Some countries where it's not very much, employers offer more. Measure it and say, we want to see men take more of their leave. Men have a lot less access to leave, right?

And not just in the first months of a child's life or adoption, but also over the course of a child's life.

more men in the care professions. We talk a lot about women in the STEM professions. We've not had a conversation about care jobs, nurses to elder care workers, to childcare workers. We need to pay those more so that we, for women's sake, who are the 80% of those, but we also need men to aspire for those to be meaningful professions. All of that

You talk about a range of things you guys put in place, from the AdViz Keyword to the trainings and things like that. Is there maybe a before and after that you can point to and say, "Hey, we were able to do this, and then when there was this result." So people can understand the behavior change and the shift that happens when people maybe have the toolkits, have the right questions to ask, or the right mindset. What's a before and after that might be really interesting?

I mean, from different settings in the world, right? Quite vast. But we do a parent training module together with the government of Rwanda. It's a 16 session once a week. Not unlike, you know, birth preparation classes that some folks may go through in some parts of the world. It's a bit deeper and a bit longer. Couple negotiation, how to raise your child, basic skills that you need to know about this new life that's about to come. You're recruited during prenatal visits in public clinics. Right.

couples go through it, half the sessions for men only, let men deal with their fear. What's this going to mean? What should I do? We measured impact with a randomized control trial that we've kept in contact with the control group and the intervention group six years later. 40% reduction in couple violence, that is his violence against her, increased participation by him in hands-on care work, increased support by him for the partner's participation in paid work,

Reduced violence by both partners against children. Greater participation by men in planning and thinking about the next child if they want to have one. So,

So in kind of a more development setting, if you want to think of it like that. Other places where we've done training in workplaces, we see attitude change. And the biggest thing is kind of coming out of those workshops, vast majority do some policy change. I mean, one, we're there looking at you. We are with you. We're guiding you toward what can you put in place in the workplace. So I think it's that policy niche change that they will do with about

some workplace policy. And then the next stage is to turn that into, did you implement it? And did you measure it? But in three quarters of the groups that we work with, there is a pretty quick run to do a policy change, increase leave for dads, some kind of internal campaign, increased attention to getting men to take the leave. And I kind of side benefit is those that are consumer facing often want to also do something in their brand that

that basically indicates or shows to the outside world that we care about men's caregiving. So I think we can count that as an impact as well. What are workplaces doing to grant incentives for people to take those leaves? What have you seen? Yeah, what kind of stuff works? I mean, one I think is to show is easy in the gender equality space and including in care equality for men to feel like you are telling me to do something, right? We're coming outside and it's kind of, you know, eat your carrots, brush your teeth, right?

do the hands-on care work. You know, a huge piece is just letting men tell the stories of how we benefit from this. We get to be better humans. We are better in the workplace when we feel that we've got an outside life and we're valued for that. And so I think that is really a key piece of it, that men feel we're invested in this and get to say out loud, it's cool to be an involved caregiver. My relationship is better at home.

My sex life is better as I've got, you know, able to keep all this stuff in balance and my partner sees that I'm doing my share as well. We figured out a balance that feels more like it works for us as a couple. So I think that really does work as an incentive. It's okay to lean into men's self-interest in being caring, connected caregivers, fathers, stepfathers.

stepfathers, support to our elderly parents. There's a virtuous cycle. There's a feedback loop that says, I want more of this at the workplace. I'm going to ask for it. I feel happier and more connected to you as a workplace if you give it to me. You talked about like policies. Are there certain questions that they should be asking themselves about like, hey, how can I design this or what would be equitable? What that even means? Like what should they be as a gut check, be asking themselves as they sort of design something that might be put into place?

Yeah. I mean, it's kind of survey, repeat, survey, focus group, repeat, listen. It's the small scale stuff, right? A corporation that says, no more meetings after four, because most of us need to go pick somebody up in that window. We can join perhaps a little bit later, but we'd prefer an earlier cycle. Try to get the workday to coincide with kind of what seems to be the school drop-off and pickup cycle. Post-COVID, more of us are doing that.

There's still school buses, et cetera, et cetera, in some parts of the world, of course. It can be some things as simple as that.

Thinking about staff that have to travel for work, what kind of flexibility do you offer? Everything from if you've got a staff who is breastfeeding, what kind of possibilities can you do to offer support for that to continue to happen? Can you provide an airfare that allows baby to go with or partner to go with? They sound kind of at first glance like, oh, we can't afford this. And then you look and say, well...

breathe here. If we really value staff and the way that we're looking at it, there's some of that stuff we've got to be flexible to do if it's a trip that does require somebody to be present. It's a lot of that micro stuff, the language that senior management uses about care, that it doesn't feel like, oh yeah, so-and-so is having a child or so-and-so is adopting and we've got to think about that. But to say, I don't get to bring the workers that I really want here unless I value that the vast majority of them have care duties.

I don't think there's a formula. It seems to be a lot of asking, iterating, repeating, testing,

All the above. You mentioned a little bit about couple negotiation, you know, and the importance for men to embrace the fear that they might feel in certain situations. Can you talk a little bit more about what are those ways that if somebody wants to be a better partner, what would be the advice or the frameworks that they should be considering? I mean, it's kind of it's both ends, right? There are things that we need men to understand.

We need to feel more comfortable doing lots of men are doing this, right? I mean, it is increasingly normal. Men are doing more of the hands-on care work. I think we've got to lean into spaces that make that normal for men. So whether it's changing tables, you know, just even some of the design around us as a world, if you have male, female bathrooms, you know, do you have a space where there's a changing table in the male restroom? Some of those, it's as simple as some of those sorts of things.

Do you see other men doing it? Are there enough of you that it doesn't feel like, well, that's a weird thing that I'm doing? So both seeing ourselves leave the office because we've got care duties and not feeling like we're being delinquent at the workplace. You know how we tell stories of caregiving on television with the Gina Davis Institute. We did a study. And to see the normality of men doing care work.

So I think there's things that I have to do as the one who wants to step into it, to claim it, to not walk away, to not find it easier that someone else will step in and do it, to learn and become competent at it, which is why first weeks after the birth of a child or adoption become really important that men get our own competencies in that. So men have to step into that, but also those around men need to say, this is normal, do it.

unearned praise. The other thing we often do is like a man carrying a baby. We go, well, like as if, you know, he's done something that no human male has done before to say that's normal, like go for it. And then the spaces where we interact have to see us as we should be there. Is there something that you kind of see as like a holy grail? We really like to get there, but you think that might be one of the toughest nuts to crack? I mean, one is just that we pay care workers more, right? I think the valuation of care is

is probably if I think of in economic terms, that will we as countries, individuals, households, now many households are already spending a third of their income in care.

So we've got to think about the subsidies that need to be there. So I do think, you know, as we talk to care systems directors in parts of the world, we've got to have the willingness, and that requires the corporate sector as well, to say, we need a tax base that acknowledges the subsidies that child and elder care require. So that seems to me one of the biggest ones. Voters want it. Workers want it. Our

Are we in corporate sectors and in policy sectors willing to pay for what care services require? I feel less resistance about men doing our part and more are we willing to invest in the return that care services offer? And they do offer returns.

ILO, International Labor Organization, has a tracker of what they show up in terms of results. Almost every care policy expanding child care, access to child care with subsidies or paying for it directly, governments or the workplaces, or paid leave, it's about a three to one return on investment, just about any care investment.

So, I think the biggest question I believe is economic. If we fix that, if we finally paid care workers enough and people didn't have to worry about their elderly parent or their child or something, or gosh, someone gets a cold and how do they handle it? They have to leave work. How would the world change? Well, there's a wonderful thing called workplace equality. So, more women in the workplace, salaries that approach equality with men.

We've got plenty of data that men live longer, we're healthier and happier when we care for others. There's a cycle where we tend to pay attention to our own health and well-being if we are responsible for caring for somebody else. That's a good win. Child development, also all kinds of outcomes. We're looking a lot at boys' problems in schools.

Men doing our share in the hands-on care of children, our children thrive. And I think there's some pretty compelling data, particularly from some parts of Europe, that where men do more of the care work and we achieve gender equality, we can look at the Global Champions Iceland survey.

Other Scandinavian countries, there tend to be lots of positive knock-ons in terms of reduced violence, better public safety, like creating, it's kind of a vague one, but promoting caring ideas about manhood has all kinds of ripples that seems to create public good in addition to those goods for women, children, and men themselves.

You're an academic, but there's a lot of different ways that your life and your path could have gone. What made you feel like, hey, you had a tipping point where like, A, there needs to be group and advocacy work and research done on this. And I'm the one who's going to help drive it. I think I've got a calling here. What was that tipping point?

holding a little baby Nina in my arms when my daughter was born 26 plus years ago. Went to Chicago to work on my PhD in child development. My partner's Brazilian. Brazil has five months paid maternity leave, 100% wage replacement. She was our main breadwinner, working as a therapist in a community public health clinic. And she said, you know, they only give me 12 weeks of partial pay because you treat

You treat childbirth as a disease in this country. Like there's no, I don't have guaranteed leave. And we went, Oh, so she said, you know, you brought me to this backwards country. Who's going to do the care work here? As she was the main breadwinner, we needed that income. As I was doing my PhD, we said, I'm going to do part of the care work here and feeling like, Oh,

oh my God, what preparation is there for me to know how to do this? Most of it is stuff that we as men can actually learn and it's not that difficult. It's acquiring a new skill set. It's kind of being willing that small human's needs take precedent over anything else you're doing. That is an amazing reset for men. And they're not ready for me as the man to be there, right? All the either, I must be incompetent, so let me help you. That was that stuff.

to more help given to me as a man than the woman who was carrying a baby next to me? And then how do you juggle that work life stuff? And so figuring out, you know, women have been doing for this for decades. How do we get men into both the joy and the challenges of that hands on care work?

Wasn't one of those rational, well, you know, A leads to B leads to C. It was, you know, the freight train of a young couple, the beginning of their careers, trying to figure out how to make it happen economically and personally and saying, I've got to do something about this. And also quite aware that in a child development program that looks at what helps children thrive, you know, there's kind of not much mention of fatherhood.

and saying, well, if we're to have a stake here, we've got to understand why it matters, what we can do, and how we change the systems around us so that men do it. And I have an amazing relationship with my daughter ever since.

And it, you know, it's, that's kind of immeasurable to have that. Is there a habit or an approach to your advocacy work or to your communication of these issues that would not have occurred to you at the beginning, but was a really, really important shift to getting the message across something that you're like, gosh, that's unlocked something.

You know, we go to do PhD programs and we hang out as researchers and we come to massive events with our data, right? Of showing, hey, let me show you the data of why this makes sense and what the gaps are and what can work.

But I think it's stepping into the kind of combination of empathy plus evidence, like getting men to tell the stories of why it matters to them. So the narrative shift in the storytelling, I think, becomes really important. Men need to feel a personal stake in this and getting men to laugh about it or talk about it.

Why didn't I get to do that? That thing I missed because I prioritized work over that. I think it's that let men step into the personal about it, which is often not easy. We're kind of socialized and particularly in the kind of workplaces that we often are. We kind of think we don't have time for that. But I think encouraging men to step into this is the other part of my humanity that you don't see here every day. I'm more interested in being engaged here at work if I also embrace that side of my humanity.

If there was one thing that happened in 2025 to bridge gender gaps and maybe even move forward to a positive masculinity and all this, what would be one thing that you would like to see?

More heads of state saying, you know, my first thing I'm going to do in office is review our care policies and everything we're doing, I'm going to multiply it times 1.5 or two. So to put at the beginning of a policy agenda would be fabulous to see more heads of state say the first thing we do is it's not caring for us as a nation that's going to be in war against another. It's how do we care for each other as humans? So, yeah, put care policies first.

You've said that if men read more novels, that would have an impact on empathy. Can you tell us a little bit about that? Yeah, we talk a lot about, you know, kind of men exercising their care muscles, right? There's a lot of things that we're amazing at playing sports and games, which is a lot of care for others as well when we're, you know, with our teammates and the rest. But, you know, we just need men to deliberately step into what does it take to do the kinds of skills that we need to care for another human? We will all have

have in about 30% of our lives, we've got a primary caregiving responsibility. Either a child, a partner who perhaps has a health issue or a disability, or an adult elderly parent. That's just part of the human condition. And I think helping boys exercise, how do I think about the care that person needs? And how do I get better at it? How do I treat it as a skill?

and be able to have those basic things of what it takes to be a responsive, nurturing caregiver. I do think, you know, that the kind of what novels and other kinds of storytelling does is you project yourself through the other. What is it that they're about? What do they need? And how can I step into that?

That was Gary Barker. Thanks so much to him. And thanks so much to you for listening. To read our recent Global Gender Gap report, go to the show notes of this episode. We'll make sure to have a link. And to listen to more podcasts, including my colleague's podcast, Radio Davos, go to wef.ch slash podcasts. This episode of Meet the Leader was produced and presented by me with Jerry Johansson and Taz Kelleher as editor, with Edward Bailey as studio engineer in New York,

and Gareth Nolan driving studio production. That's it for now. I'm Linda Lucina from the World Economic Forum. Have a great day.