The Mystery of Silent Letters: Why English Spelling Doesn't Match Its Sound
14:31 Share

ever stopped and wondered, like, why is there an H in the word our? You know, the K in Knuckles. Why is that there? Yeah. Well, we are going deep today into the world of silent letters in English. Those letters that we don't pronounce but are still there in our spelling. Right. And what we're finding is that these silent letters are

They're not actually useless. Yeah. It's like they're little time capsules holding all these clues to a word's history and how it's traveled through different languages. It's true. We often think of them as just like these weird quirks of English spelling, but they really do have some stories to tell. Oh, they absolutely do. And we've got some really cool sources today that dive into this. We've got a YouTube video, a really fun one actually.

That has this whole silent letter day party going on. Okay We've got a blog post from a teacher who is very passionate about silent letters and they make a really good argument about why they actually make sense interesting and then we've got this essay that goes way back into the history of English spelling and talks about things like the great vowel shift and

Oh, wow. So we are really going to get into it. Oh, we are. We're going to uncover like all the hidden logic behind why English spelling can be so, so puzzling. And by the end of this, you'll probably be a better speller. Oh, I hope so. I need all the help I can get. Okay, so this YouTube video celebrating silent letter day.

It is hilarious. Like imagine just walking around and saying half a how instead of half an hour. Right. Or like kiff instead of knife. Yeah. You know what? It does make you realize just how many silent letters we really use. Oh, yeah. And how strange it would actually sound. Oh, yeah. If we were to pronounce all of them. It would be a whole different world. Salomon for dinner. Anyone. I think I'll pass. Yeah, I think I'm good too. I'll take the champagne though. Yeah.

But OK, all jokes aside, you know, this blog post we have. Yeah. It makes a really good point. Like we shouldn't just be teaching letters all by themselves. Yeah. Letters don't really make sounds. It's more about the combinations. That's right. The author, they say it's the graphemes that we should be focusing on. What graphemes? It's just a fancy way of saying letters.

The combinations of letters. Okay. So like, you know, T-H together. Yeah. Makes the sound. Exactly. It's not about individual letters all by themselves. It's how they work together to make a sound. So it's kind of like you can't just listen to one note. Yeah. And understand the whole song, right? Exactly. And they actually use the word dog as an example. And they say, look that G at the end. Right. That's always going to be a hard G sound. Right. When it's at the end of a word like that.

So it's about recognizing the patterns. Exactly. Not just the individual letters. And then it kind of starts to click. Yeah. Okay. So this blog post also talks about how silent letters, they're not just randomly there. Right. They serve a purpose. Yeah. So let's break down some of these categories. What about these markers? Okay. Well, the markers are really interesting because they point to other words where that same letter I-S pronounced. Okay. So like if you think of crumb...

Okay. The B is silent. Yeah. But then you have the word crumble and the B is pronounced. Okay. So it's almost like a little trail within the language. Yeah. A little breadcrumb trail. I like that. Okay. And then there's the whole idea of etymology. So that's all about the history and origins of the word. Yes. Like how did the word get here? Yeah. Where did it come from? And those silent letters...

can tell us. So if you take the word debt, for instance, that silent B. Yeah. That's not random. It actually connects to the Latin root debitum. Huh. See, now that's interesting. OK, so the blog post talks about a bunch of other things like digraphs. Yeah. Unpronounceable clusters. Right.

And even like ancient Greek, how does that all fit in here? Well, let's start with digraphs. Okay. It's basically just two letters that work together to make a single sound. Okay. So like think of the word read. Okay. But E is a digraph. So it's not that either one of them is silent. Exactly. They both work together. Okay. I got it. What about those unpronounceable clusters? Well, those are, well, they're just...

unpronounceable for us at least. Okay. In modern English anyway. So like the MB at the end of words like dumb or lamb is

Oh, right. Yeah. We don't pronounce that B. No, we don't. That's just kind of left over from an older pronunciation. So it's like a linguistic fossil. I like that. It is. And then you have words like anchor. Okay. Character. Yeah. And you hear that chat sound, but it's more like a K sound, isn't it? It is. That often tells us that the word has Greek origins. Wow.

Okay, so it's like these silent letters. They're like breadcrumbs. They are. Leading us back to the origins of the word. They are. And this is just scratching the surface. I know. It's amazing how much depth there is to these what seem like just silences.

silent, meaningless letters. I know. I know. Okay. So we've seen how they can be markers. They can reflect the etymology. Yeah. They can even point to a word's Greek roots. Right. But what about these big shifts in English pronunciation? Yes. How did that lead to some of the weird spelling that we have today? Well, we've got to talk about that great vowel shift. Okay. I mean, can you imagine a time when the word name sounded more like father? Yeah.

Really? Yeah. That is wild. That's a great vowel shift in action. Oh, wow. So vowel sounds basically went through this crazy transformation over a few hundred years. They did. But the spelling didn't always keep up. No. So that's why we have so many words where the spelling of the pronunciation just seem totally out of whack. Totally. It's like we're speaking like a

A haunted version of English or something. That's a good way to put it. Like the ghosts of past pronunciations are still like hanging around in our spellings. I like that. Okay. And then we've also got the printing press to thank. Ah, yes. For some of this spelling chaos. The printing press. Yeah. I mean, think about it. The printing press comes along. Right. And at that time, English spelling was already changing so much. From the great vowel shift. And then you had all the French influence. Right. Exactly. So the typesetters...

They're thinking, "We've got to standardize this." Even if the spelling doesn't match exactly how people are saying it. So even if it didn't sound right, if you saw it printed enough times, it started to look right. Exactly. So visual recognition won over pronunciation. It did. And when you have the printing press, now all of a sudden you can make so many copies. Oh yeah, mass production. Exactly. And it just kind of gets solidified. That's pretty powerful.

Technology really can shape language, huh? Absolutely. Okay, we can't forget about those scribes, though. The scribes, yeah. That Aeon essay talks about scribal tampering. What is that all about? Well, you know, some scribes,

They were a little bit obsessed with Latin. Okay. And so they would add letters back into English words based on the Latin. Oh, even if we weren't saying those letters anymore? Even if they weren't pronounced, yeah. Okay. The P in receipt is a good example of that. Like they snuck it back in there. Yeah. Maybe they had a little too much wine that day. I don't know. Just decided to be a little extra?

Wow. Okay. So we've got markers, etymology, digraphs, unpronounceable clusters, the great vowel shift, the printing press, meddling scribes. Meddling scribes. Yeah. And all of this is because of silent letters. And we're just getting started. There are so many more examples and categories we can look at. I know. It's amazing how every silent letter seems to have its own little story to tell. They really do. But I have to ask why.

Why even have silent letters? Yeah, why not just spell things exactly how they sound? Right. Wouldn't it be so much easier? Well, you know, linguists and educators, they've been debating this for centuries. Really? Yeah, I mean, there are some good reasons to have a more phonetic system. Like what? Well, it could make learning to read and write much easier. Oh, especially for people learning English as a second language. Exactly. Think about all the time we spend trying to memorize all those crazy spellings. I know, right? It's a lot.

But there's a trade off you see. Because English it borrows words from so many other languages. Yeah. And those words often keep their original spelling.

So if we tried to make English perfectly phonetic, we'd lose all those connections. Oh, so we'd be sacrificing like the history and the etymology of the words? In a way, yes. And then there's the whole issue of all the different accents and dialects. Right. I mean, whose pronunciation would we choose? It's true. As the standard. Yeah, it would be impossible. To standardize all the different ways that people say things. I see your point. Plus, language is always changing anyway, right? Yeah.

Right. So even if we did come up with this perfect phonetic system, it would probably be outdated pretty quickly. Exactly. So maybe those silent letters, they're kind of a necessary evil. Maybe. Or maybe, just maybe, they add a little charm to the language. Yeah, maybe they do. They're definitely unique. They are. You know, this whole conversation, it's really changed how I look at silent letters.

I used to see them as mistakes. But now I kind of appreciate them. Like they're clues to the history of the language. They are. And they really do make you think, don't they? They do. About how we got to where we are today. For sure. So listeners, the next time you see a word and you're like, wait a minute.

Why is that letter there? Yeah. Don't just ignore it. Think about it. Take a second to be curious. Yeah. Think about what story that silent letter might be trying to tell. You might be surprised at what you discover. It's like they're little puzzles, you know, and the silent letters, they're like, they're like clues. Oh, yeah. To help us solve those puzzles. I like that. So we've talked about like the markers, the etymology. Yeah. We

We even talked about those scribes who were tampering with words. Those meddling scribes. But there's this whole other category that I find really interesting, and it has to do with how pronunciation has changed over time. Oh, so like how the great vowel shift messed up a bunch of spellings. Yeah.

Exactly. But it's not just that. Think about the word night, for example. Okay. That silent K. Yeah. It's not just randomly there. It's because way back when, people actually did pronounce that K. Oh, wow. So it's like a fossil. It is. Of a sound that's not spoken anymore. Actually. And that silent K in night, it's not the only one. You've got words like...

Like night, light. Okay, yes. That silent A. Right. That spelling, that represents a sound that used to be pronounced in Old English.

But we don't say it anymore. So those letters are like, they're like little ghosts. They are. Haunting our spelling. Yeah. It's really amazing to think about it. Like how these silent letters connect us. Yeah. To this like whole history of language, like sounds that aren't even spoken anymore. I know. And those connections can actually be really meaningful. Remember those words, um...

With that silent W at the beginning that we were talking about before. Oh, yeah, like rap. Yeah. Wreck. Wrestle. Those silent Ws, they reflect a sound. Okay. From way, way back. Okay. It was a Germanic consonant cluster. And it had this meaning, this sense of twisting or distortion. Okay.

So like even though we don't pronounce the W anymore, it's still kind of there in the meaning of the word. Exactly. It's like that twisting. It's built into the word itself. Wow. That's really cool. So even though the pronunciation has faded, the spelling is kind of holding on to that echo from the past. It is. It really is. And it's affecting like...

how we understand those words, even if we don't realize it. Right. Like on a subconscious level. Yeah. They're still shaping how we think about the word and what it means.

That's pretty amazing. It makes you wonder. Yeah. Are these letters really silent? That's a great question. Like, I know they're not pronounced. Yeah. But they're obviously not meaningless either. Right. It's not like they're just there doing nothing. Or doing something. They are. They're like these little whispers giving us these hints about where the word came from.

Okay. How it's related to other words. It's really fascinating. Yeah. So instead of like dismissing them or ignoring them. Yeah. We should really approach them with a sense of curiosity. Absolutely. Like why is this letter here? Yeah. What's the story? What's the story? You know. That's the fun part. I love that. It's like every word is a mystery. It is. It really is. And for you, the listener. Yeah. I mean, this means that even the most ordinary words, the words we use every single day. Yeah. They can...

have these like hidden depths. Right. You know, so the next time you come across a word with a silent letter. Yeah. Don't just don't just skim over it. Right. Pause for a second. OK. Think about it. Yeah.

Why is that letter there? Yeah. What's it trying to tell us? Exactly. It's the story. I know. It's making me think of all these other words like psychology with that silent P. Yeah. Now I'm like, I got to go look that up. I know. Right. See where that came from. It's a rabbit hole. It is. It really is. And our sources gave us some great starting points like read, crumb, debt,

Oh, and Wednesday. Yeah, Wednesday. That one's always a fun one. That's a good one. The list just goes on and on. It does, doesn't it? So many words to explore. As we're wrapping up our deep dive today into the world of silent letters, what's the one big thing you hope our listeners take away from this?

I think the most important thing to remember is that those silent letters, they're not just mistakes or random quirks. They're like these echoes of the past. They tell us about how words are connected, how language has changed over time. It's pretty amazing when you think about it. Yeah, it really is. It's like language. It's more than just rules. You know, totally. It's like this whole tapestry of history and culture and creativity. And these silent letters, they're like those threads that connected all together.

I like that. So to all our listeners out there, as you keep exploring the world of words, pay attention to those silent letters. Yeah. Don't be afraid of them. Don't be afraid of them. Have fun with them. You never know. They might just lead you to some amazing discoveries. Exactly. And who knows? You might even learn a thing or two about yourself along the way. That's a great point. Well, thanks for joining us on this deep dive. It's been a pleasure. And until next time, happy exploring.