We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Is it Wise for Tuchel to Criticise Players he Won't See for a Few Months?

Is it Wise for Tuchel to Criticise Players he Won't See for a Few Months?

2025/3/24
logo of podcast It's All Kicking Off!

It's All Kicking Off!
AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
C
Chris Sutton
D
Dwight Gayle
I
Ian Ladyman
Topics
Ian Ladyman: 我认为批评Dan Burn的英格兰首秀是不公平的，因为他正处于职业生涯的巅峰时刻。然而，他的表现也暴露出一些问题，这让我质疑他是否具备国际级中后卫的水准。此外，我认为图赫尔批评南门的做法有些轻率，因为他没有经历过南门所面临的困境。英格兰队目前的对手实力较弱，这使得对球队实力的评估存在偏差。我认为南门承受了很多不公平的批评，而英格兰队几年前糟糕的国家联赛表现，至今仍对其造成影响。我还担心英格兰队在2026年世界杯之前没有足够的准备时间。如果图赫尔执教的英格兰队在首场比赛中输给强队，他将面临巨大的压力和批评。有时，作为一名主教练，尤其是英格兰队主教练，隐晦处理某些话题比直接了当更明智。我认为苏格兰国家队降级到国家联赛低级别联赛，反而可能更有利于他们世界杯预选赛的晋级。如果Craig Bellamy能够带领威尔士队晋级世界杯，这将是一个了不起的成就。我认为Robbie Savage为Macclesfield FC所做的工作值得赞扬，尽管他为人备受争议。我认为Mark Hughes对Carlisle的投入值得称赞。我认为Bradford City的成功，突显了低级别联赛球队强大的球迷基础和投入的重要性。 Chris Sutton: 我认为主教练应该根据球员的不同性格特点，采取不同的批评方式。我认为Dwight Gayle批评Steve Bruce的训练方式是一种不公平的批评，因为许多成功的教练并不总是亲自参与所有训练。我认为球员在轻松的环境下，有时会说出一些事后后悔的话。我并不认为现在还有必要继续批评Steve Bruce在纽卡斯尔联队的执教表现。我认为球员对教练的批评应该私下进行，不应该公开发表。我认为Craig Bellamy作为球员时就拥有出色的足球头脑。 Dwight Gayle: 我认为Steve Bruce在执教期间，更注重比赛结果而非球员的长期发展。 Steve Bruce: (无核心论点，仅有对Dwight Gayle批评的回应)

Deep Dive

Chapters
Chris Sutton shares his recent trip to New York, discussing his activities, experiences, and some humorous anecdotes from his journey.
  • Chris Sutton visited New York for a Q&A session with the Celtic Foundation.
  • The trip raised over $400,000 for the foundation.
  • Chris experienced some travel mishaps, including a unique return route via Iceland.

Shownotes Transcript

Welcome back to 'It's All Kicking Off!' 

Chris returns from New York, Ian explains the rules to his new game 'rock, paper, scissors stone gun' and Dwight Gayle and Steve Bruce exchange a war of words - there really is a lot to unpack in this episode. 

There's also chat about Thomas Tuchel's criticism of his star players, with Ian questioning how clever it is to do this publicly, when he doesn't work with them everyday. Could it play on their mind ahead of the next international camp?

Ian defends the comments he made about Dan Burn's England debut, after Newcastle fans jumped on him on Twitter. What do you reckon, was it an underwhelming start or should we give him a break?

Presenters: Ian Ladyman and Chris Sutton

Producer: Henry Williams

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices)