We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Why Argentina’s “Anti-Communist” Leader Is Working with China

Why Argentina’s “Anti-Communist” Leader Is Working with China

2025/4/3
logo of podcast China Unscripted

China Unscripted

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
S
Sascha Hannig Nuñez
主持人
专注于电动车和能源领域的播客主持人和内容创作者。
Topics
主持人: 阿根廷新总统米莱竞选时以反共立场示人,对中国共产党持批评态度。然而,上任后却与中国保持友好关系,这引发了我的好奇。 Sascha Hannig Nuñez: 阿根廷经济严重依赖对华出口,特别是大豆,这使得阿根廷难以迅速与中国断绝关系。政府内部对如何处理与中国的关系存在分歧,一部分人将其视为安全问题,另一部分人则认为这是必要的‘恶’。长期来看,希望能够与中国脱钩,但短期内难以实现。米莱政府将对华关系问题更多地视为叙事问题而非实际政策问题,因为他的首要任务是解决阿根廷的经济发展问题。中国是米莱上任后第一个祝贺的国家之一,这表明中国在阿根廷的地位。 在内乌肯省的中国空间研究站问题上,阿根廷政府内部存在争议,但缺乏终止合同的行动。该空间站的合同条款对阿根廷极其不利,租金过低,中国可以不受限制地使用自己的频率,阿根廷政府的监管能力非常有限,无法了解中国人民解放军在该空间站的活动。空间站工作人员通过外交渠道进入阿根廷,不受阿根廷政府控制,这使得该空间站实际上成为中国在阿根廷的飞地,阿根廷政府几乎没有控制权或监督权。 Sascha Hannig Nuñez: 阿根廷与中国签订的空间站合同中,虽然表面上说是用于科学研究,但实际上是由中国人民解放军运营的。这一事实是在空间站开始运营后才被披露的。合同允许中国长期运营该空间站,且阿根廷的监管非常有限。租金过低,且中国可以使用自己的频率,无需接受阿根廷的监管。阿根廷政府对中国空间站的监管能力有限,无法了解中国人民解放军在该空间站的活动。中国空间站工作人员通过外交渠道进入阿根廷,不受阿根廷政府控制,这使得该空间站实际上成为中国在阿根廷的飞地。

Deep Dive

Chapters
Despite running on an anti-communist platform, President Javier Milei's actions towards China reveal a complex relationship shaped by economic realities and political priorities. Argentina's heavy reliance on China for soybean exports makes severing ties difficult, leading to internal government debate on how to manage China's influence.
  • Milei's anti-communist campaign rhetoric
  • Argentina's economic dependence on China for soybean exports
  • Internal debate within Milei's government on China policy
  • Prioritization of economic development over immediate decoupling from China

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

I'm curious about Argentina. You know, their new president, Javier Mille, ran on an anti-communist platform. I think he was very critical of the CCP in his campaign. How is he getting on with China now? Well, actually, a few days after he got elected, he actually...

became very friendly with China. I mean, Argentina has a big problem, as many other Latin American countries have, that most of its exports, especially in soybeans, I believe, go to China. So the grip that China has currently in Argentina is pretty strong.

So, he cannot just cut ties directly with China overnight. I know that within his government, this is something I have been talking about with some public officials in Argentina, there is mixed views on how to engage with China and how to respond to China.

see this as a security problem and some others see the China issue as a necessary evil, something that they need to

Look in the long term how to decouple with China how to take action to diminish China's influence within the country, but not something that they can do overnight So these two views are kind of struggling in like within the melee government. Um

But yeah, I mean, you talk about doing it overnight, but it's been he's been in office about 15 months or so, right? It seems like a long time to be able to start cutting ties with communist China, if that's what he was serious about, right? I mean, there's not much that has been done so far. And to be honest, I think China was one of the first countries to congratulate Milley after he arrived in office. And he has

a few other problems that you might have heard of internally and of course politically. So since Millet's priorities seem to be in

get Argentina back on track in terms of economic development, then it doesn't seem that he can just cut ties with China. And I think that the executive decision there was to kind of live this as a more discursive or narrative issue than an actually policy-related issue. And it's the same with the space station that...

Well, there has been a lot of controversy surrounding the Neuquén space and research station, the Estación Espacio Alejano in Spanish. Although within the administration, and this is something I've talked to with a few public officials, there is an understanding that this is a problem. There is some controversy.

caution to actually do or engage in policies that will terminate that contract.

All right, so the space station, one of the things that's interesting about Argentina, just geographically, it's completely on the opposite side of the earth from China. Yeah. Right? So it's only really Argentina and Chile are geographically in the right place on the globe to have a kind of space station that can track satellites that are not trackable from Chinese stations, right, in China.

So it's like from China's perspective, they have to have a space station somewhere in like the southern part of South America. But when they built the space station in Argentina, I think it was 10 years ago or so, maybe 2014, they had said it was going to be for only civilian purposes. How's that turned out?

So the original contract, which was negotiated during the Kirchner administration and then was finalized by Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, didn't say civilian use per se. It said scientific research. The thing is, the branch...

of the Chinese counterpart that built the station is managed by the PLA. So this is something that

It is written in the document, but it is written in the document as scientific research. But actually these researchers or scientists that are working at the station come from the People's Liberation Army. So this is something that was actually put on the table after the space station started operations. And the contract is crazy if you see it.

It allowed China to operate this station without any due diligence from Argentina for decades. I think they granted them a surface in the Neocan Desert. Like, Pampa is basically a desert. There's nothing around. There is one town more than 20 kilometers away. And it allows them to operate this station for decades.

I think it's a ridiculous amount. It's a lease, but it's a ridiculous amount. It's not justifiable at all. They cannot change this contract because it is within the law in the sense that they are paying, but they're paying peanuts. They're not paying much. Another problem is that the contract allows them to use their own frequency that is enclosed and they don't have to respond.

or accept any kind of monitoring from the Argentinian state. So there have been some attempts at entering the base and actually seeing what's being done there. But apart from these guided visits in which they can say that, oh, the antennas are the antennas that are supposed to be there, the people who are supposed to be there, there's not many control mechanisms that

the Argentinian government can have to kind of know what the PLA is doing there. And actually many of the people who work at the base, or if not all of them, enter through diplomatic channels. So they're not even controlled by the Argentinian government in their entrance to the country, right? So it's basically like a piece of mainland Chinese soil

on which they can operate with impunity and it's operated by the chinese military and the argentinian government uh has basically no control or oversight at all basically yes and it's the size of uh microstating europe like luxembourg

Thank you for watching this highlight from our hour-long podcast. The full interview is available exclusively on our website, ChinaUncensored.tv. And when you subscribe to our website, you'll also get premium China Uncensored episodes, live streams, a community chat with me, Shelley, Matt, and hundreds of subscribers. And most importantly, you'll be supporting content you love. Check it out. The link is below.