The podcast discusses the lack of diversity in the Goodreads Choice Awards, highlighting how the awards are dominated by white authors despite efforts to include more diverse nominees. The hosts express concern about the reading public's implicit biases and the role of algorithms in reinforcing these biases.
The hosts are concerned because the Goodreads Choice Awards, which are publicly voted on, consistently favor white authors, even though the editorial staff tries to seed diverse nominees. This reflects broader issues in readerly attention and acquisition, where books by authors of color are often overlooked despite their quality.
Storehouse Voices is a new imprint by Crown focused on Black writers and authors. It represents a counter-narrative to recent layoffs of Black staff in publishing and aims to amplify diverse voices in the industry.
The hosts found 'Fourth Wing' to be not for them. They felt it was not well-written, lacked innovation, and took too long to develop its plot, especially the romantic elements. They acknowledge that while they are open to the genre, this particular book did not resonate with them.
The hosts had mixed feelings about 'All Fours.' They appreciated its exploration of a woman's midlife crisis and sexual desire but felt the protagonist lacked self-awareness and the story didn't break new ground. They also found the sexual content to be more of a gimmick than a meaningful exploration of the character's existential needs.
The hosts discuss the rise in popularity of witch-themed books, questioning whether the genre has reached 'peak witch.' They note that while witches have always been a staple of fantasy, there has been a noticeable increase in witch-centric stories, often tied to themes of women's empowerment.
The hosts are skeptical of the claim that men are not reading enough fiction, pointing out that men are over-indexed in nonfiction reading. They argue that the focus on men not reading fiction overlooks the broader issue of empathy and connection, which can be developed through various means, not just books.
The hosts are critical of the branding and initial slate of books for Jenna Bush Hager's new imprint, 'Thousand Voices x RHPG.' They note that all six initial titles are by white authors, which they find problematic given the current emphasis on diversity in publishing.
We kick off the new year in book news by talking about Book Riot's own list of the most anticipated books of 2025, a look at the whiteout that was the 2024 Goodreads Choices Awards before talking about All Fours (Jeff read it). And then some very brief reactions to Fourth Wing (we both read it).
Subscribe to the podcast via RSS), Apple Podcasts), and Spotify).
For more industry news, sign up for our Today in Books) daily newsletter!
Check out the Book Riot Podcast Book Page on Thriftbooks)!
This content contains affiliate links. When you buy through these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
The Book Riot Podcast on Instagram)
The Book Riot Podcast Patreon)
Check out new collections on Patreon)
Book Riot’s Most Anticipated Books of 2025)
The Unbearable Whiteness of the Goodreads Choice Awards)
Christopher Nolan’s next film is an adaptation of The Odyssey )
Constance Grady digs into whether there’s actually a crisis of men not reading)
Jenna Bush Hager launches imprint with PRH)
Katy Waldman Goes Deep on the Romantasy Plagiarism Case)
Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros)
Life in Three Dimensions by Shigehiro Oishi)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)