The episode begins by introducing Haley Rathgeber, a young woman found dead near a soccer field in Newburgh, Indiana. The discovery triggers a murder investigation and the desperate search for answers by Haley's family and friends. Police identify the body and inform Haley's mother, Heather Collins, shattering their world.
When a young woman is found dead near a soccer field in Indiana, detectives try to piece together a puzzle that leads them to an unexpected suspect. Andrea Canning reports. Originally aired on NBC on September 28, 2018.