Verdict day in Karen Read's second trial. A courtroom twist in South Carolina. And tariff scammers.
29:00 Share

This episode is brought to you by Progressive, where drivers who save by switching save nearly $750 on average. Quote now at progressive.com to see if you could save.

Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. National average 12-month savings of $744 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2022 and May 2023. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states and situations.

Grand Canyon University, a private Christian university in beautiful Phoenix, Arizona, believes that we're endowed by our Creator with certain unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. GCU believes in equal opportunity, and the American dream starts with purpose. Whether your pursuit involves a bachelor's, master's, or doctoral degree, GCU provides a path to help you fulfill your dreams, offering 340 academic programs as of September 2024. Find your purpose at Grand Canyon University. Private. Christian. Affordable.

Good morning. It's the start of another workday for the Dateline team here at 30 Rockefeller Center. Prosecutors saying she is a master manipulator. She is a evil woman. Our producers are catching up on breaking crime news around the country, swapping tips and story ideas. Ash, could we have a verdict tomorrow? That seems unlikely. I know they're not deliberating on the weekend. We will see what happens tomorrow.

Welcome to Dateline True Crime Weekly. I'm Andrea Canning. It's June 19th, and here's what's on our docket. A massive courtroom twist at the retrial of a South Carolina businessman accused of staging his wife's murder to look like suicide. Everyone was stunned. It took a moment for people even to realize they could stand up. In Dateline Roundup, the latest in the trial of children's author Corey Richens, it's

And in Connecticut, a plea deal for someone connected to the case of murdered mom of five, Jennifer Dulos. Authorities allege that he helped Fotis create an alibi for the time of Jennifer's disappearance. Plus, NBC News chief investigative consumer correspondent Vicky Nguyen on a whole new scam to watch out for involving tariffs.

But before all that, we're heading back to Dedham, Massachusetts. Since 2022, Karen Reed has been fighting for her freedom, facing a potential sentence of life in prison on charges including second-degree murder. We were there in court as she finally learned her fate.

31 days of testimony and 49 witnesses. 38 witnesses for the prosecution, 11 for the defense. Yesterday afternoon, after more than three years, we finally got something we didn't get in the first trial, a verdict. Mr. Foreman, on docket number 2282CR117001, murder in the second degree, what say you? Is the defendant at the bar guilty or not guilty? Not guilty.

We'll tell you everything you need to know about the dramatic conclusion to this case. But first, before the verdict came down, I talked to Dateline producer Sue Simpson about how the lawyers on both sides made their final pitch to the jury and what was happening outside the courtroom as the jury went off to deliberate. Sue, let's start with closing arguments. Alan Jackson was first up for the defense. Let's take a quick listen. There was no collision.

There was no collision. There was no collision. This was almost identical to how Alan Jackson began his opening statement. What was the argument that he laid out for the jury in his closing? Well, Andrea, as you know, I mean, this is his final sales pitch, right? And he started off smartly by thanking them for their attention and their patience and also for their courage. Courage is what this moment, this moment demands.

Not just to listen, but to stare directly at injustice and say, not here, not now, not on our watch. That's what you're being asked to do. Stare down injustice. You folks are the last line of defense. The last line of defense between an innocent woman and a system that has tried to break her, that falsely accused her, that tried mightily, mightily,

to bury the truth. So Jackson said the case was corrupted from the start. You know, he pointed at the lead investigator, Michael Proctor, and he said his misconduct infected every single part of the case. Alan Jackson also wanted to talk about reasonable doubt and how it is, in his words,

the bedrock on which the entire system of justice is built. So from the start, he's really laying out this idea that Karen Reid was entitled to the presumption of innocence, of course, and that the heavy burden of proof, beyond a reasonable doubt, was on the state, not the defense. You think about one or more of the charges, you think, you know what, maybe that's true. It might be true. Then you vote not guilty. If you think it's possibly true or probably true,

Your vote must be not guilty. If someone among you thinks it's likely true or even very likely to be true, your vote is not guilty. It's because none of those standards, maybe, might be, possibly, probably, likely, very likely, none of those meets the extraordinary burden of beyond a reasonable doubt and to a moral certainty. A moral certainty means a level of confidence so strong, so incredibly unshakable that

that you could go home, you would go home, look your loved ones in the eye and say, I am certain. The prosecutor...

Sue was up next, and he began by talking about John O'Keefe. He spoke about how he spent his life helping people and what a good man he was. And you'll remember he was selflessly raising his niece and nephew. That's right. As we know, the niece and nephew were orphaned, and John stepped in as single uncle and became their, what they called their funcle, their fun uncle. Prosecutor Hank Brennan said,

wanted to drive home the message that this was a good man who died. And on the morning of January 29th, 2022, John O'Keefe, who had helped so many, was the one who needed help himself. And that one person who could help him that morning was this defendant right here, Karen Glee. And she made a decision.

In her Lexus with the shattered taillight, debris failed all over the front yard, and John O'Keefe lying helpless like a child on the front yard. She made a choice. She drove away. She was drunk. She hit him. Then she left him to die.

What else did Hank Brennan focus on, Sue? Well, you know, like the defense, Hank Brennan went back over a lot of the evidence during his closing argument. He talked about how blood samples indicated Karen was two to three times over the legal limit.

He also talked about the battery temperature of the cell phone, Andrea, and this was a whole new piece of the state's case as compared to the first trial. He really honed in on the data surrounding the temperature of the phone battery to try to show that John O'Keefe was outside versus inside the house all night, as the defense had suggested. He also spoke about physical evidence at the scene, those taillight pieces. There's no doubt there's a collision because her taillight's all over the yard.

It's all over the yard. And when he falls back and he hits the back of his head, his basal fracture, he's then lying there helpless. When Miss Reed leaves, she leaves behind tons of her taillight all over the yard.

Brennan, Sue, also had audio and videos that he played during the closing argument? That's right. He played those angry voicemails that Karen left John that night. And Hank Brennan played clips from Karen Reid's own media interviews, including the one she did with Dateline. And some of the statements she made really were sort of, it seemed to be her admitting that maybe she had, for instance, a bit too much to drink. All right. So, Sue, what was the atmosphere like around the courthouse as deliberations

gone underway, you know, this has really gotten worldwide attention. It is big. And boy, I can tell you, Andrea, outside the courthouse these past couple of days, the crowd has been growing and growing and growing. And it's all a heaving sea of people in pink, you know, supporters of Karen Reid. We love you! Yes!

As jury deliberations stretched into a fourth day, Karen's supporters were still there in the streets, waiting. Then word came. The jury had a verdict. The prosecutor and defense teams filed back into the courtroom, and Karen stood before the judge. Mr. Foreman, on docket number 2282CR117001, murder in the second degree, what say you? Is the defendant of the bar guilty or not guilty?

Not guilty. So say you, Mr. Foreman. So say you. No, no. Do you agree? Yes. 002, what say you? Is the defendant at the bar not guilty or guilty? Not guilty. 003, what say you? Is the defendant at the bar leaving the scene after accident resulting in death? Is the defendant not guilty or guilty? Not guilty. So say you, Mr. Foreman. So say you all.

Not guilty on the most serious charges of second-degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence, and leaving the scene of an accident resulting in death. A roar came from outside the courthouse. John O'Keefe's mother broke down in tears. Karen was found guilty of operating a vehicle under the influence and immediately sentenced to one year of probation. Moments later, she spoke on the courthouse steps. I could not be standing here.

With that, the case that has transfixed the nation for more than three years was at an end. The mystery of what happened to John O'Keefe in a snowstorm back in January 2022 still lingers.

It's a case we've been covering here at Dateline since the beginning. And tonight, on Thursday's edition of Dateline, you can watch our in-depth report, Center of the Storm.

We'll bring you the whole story, including one of Karen Reid's first television interviews. I didn't know what the hell, what the hell happened. And I'll talk to a man at the center of the case, disgraced former trooper Michael Proctor. What do you want to say to anyone who believes that you framed Karen Reid? It did not happen. As well as his wife, Elizabeth. But he did say, there are some really embarrassing text messages that I have to read. And I said, okay, well...

Own it. We'll dive into the case files, the theories, the evidence. And you'll also hear from John O'Keefe's family about their journey and what they wish people knew. She has put my family through hell to save herself. That's airing at a special time of 9, 8 central this Thursday on NBC.

Coming up, seven years after a jury deadlocked in the trial of a South Carolina businessman accused of killing his wife, his retrial is stopped in its tracks. We'll take you inside the courtroom. This episode is brought to you by WhatsApp.

On WhatsApp, no one can see or hear your personal messages. So the calls with your mom, chats about the latest work drama, late night voice messages, and all those photos and videos of your dog, every personal message stays private because no one, not even WhatsApp, can see or hear your personal messages. WhatsApp. Message privately. With everyone.

If you work as a manufacturing facilities engineer, installing a new piece of equipment can be as complex as the machinery itself. From prep work to alignment and testing, it's your team's job to put it all together. That's why it's good to have Grainger on your side. With industrial-grade products and next-day delivery, Grainger helps ensure you have everything you need close at hand through every step of the installation. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgrainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.

Welcome to Birch Lane, where you can find a fresh take on classic furniture and decor. Every piece is hand-picked and crafted to last for years to come. At Birch Lane, you can explore everything from outdoor sets to living room furniture and everything in between, and get fast, free shipping. It's classic style for joyful living. Shop now at birchlane.com.

For our next story, we're headed to a South Carolina courthouse where a prominent jeweler was set to go before trial this week for allegedly murdering his wife. Before we continue, we should warn you there is some discussion of self-harm in this case. On the evening of May 20th, 2015, Michael Colucci called 911 from outside a warehouse he was renting for his business.

He said he found his wife, Sarah Lynn, hanging from a fence with a garden hose wrapped around her neck and begged them to hurry. Paramedics got to the scene within minutes, but it was already too late. Sarah Lynn was dead. Michael told investigators that she had been depressed and suspected it was a suicide.

But a year later, he was arrested and charged with her murder. He pleaded not guilty and stood trial in 2018, but the jury was unable to reach a verdict. This week, Colucci was in the courtroom getting ready to stand trial again when a last-minute twist changed everything.

Dateline producer Carol Gable is here to tell us more. Carol, welcome back to the show. Good to be here. So Carol, before we get to that big twist, let's go over some of the basics of this case. Who was this couple? Well, there were two people who were thrilled to get that

elusive second chance at love. They were each a single parent to a daughter. They met on a blind date. They, from all accounts, pretty much fell instantly in love and got

The two of them ran this jewelry business together? Yes. I don't think Sarah really was there full time, but she certainly was in some ads you can still see on the Internet for the jewelry store. She was tall, blonde, beautiful, very personable. And so she did work at the store from time to time. What were Michael and Sarah doing at the warehouse that night?

Well, it was kind of the last stop on a big day of errands. They started out at a lawyer's office, and then they ended up at the very famous cemetery here in Charleston called Magnolia Cemetery, where Sarah's first husband, who died of a suicide, was buried.

At the grave, Sarah got really upset. His death were very stressful, even after all these years. And then they began to drive home. And Sarah had this quirk that if she needed to go to the bathroom, she did not want to go in a public restroom. So she had Michael pull over, according to Michael, so she could go relieve herself behind this warehouse.

along very busy Highway 17. So she gets out of the car, according to Michael, to go do this and

And while she's gone, he says he plays some music. You know, he may have fallen asleep. We don't know. Next thing, he looks up and Sarah is hanging from a garden hose that had been draped over a chain-link fence. Wow, so awful. What eventually made local investigators suspicious of Michael's story? Well, at first, they thought it might be a suicide attempt.

But Sarah's father, Ronnie, and her mother, Barbara, were absolutely insistent that Michael had something to do with it. So they basically just bombarded the local sheriff. And eventually the sheriff called the state law enforcement division to come in and do their own investigation. And they send a person named David O'Connor,

What motive did prosecutors say Michael murdered?

might have had for killing his wife. In the first trial, it seemed that the prosecutors were painting a picture of this couple being very volatile. So in their scenario, they were having a fight and somehow it led to her death. Carol, back in 2018, the jury couldn't agree on a verdict at the first trial. Now here we are, 2025, retrial, and the defense presents a motion filed last week

Tell us about that. Well, it centers on a conversation that David Owen had with Barbara Moore, Sarah's mother, in which Barbara said that in the days before her death, she had found Sarah drinking and crying uncontrollably. Her face was swollen. And she was saying that if it were not for the girls,

coming home, she would commit suicide. And that piece of information did not make its way to the defense, which in legal ease is a Brady violation. You are required to return over to the defense any piece of information that might be in favor of the defendant.

And so what the defense said in this case is had that information been turned over earlier, that even the state's witnesses could have come to a different conclusion and would have testified differently, which would have meant a potential different outcome. So what did the judge decide with this motion? When he came out and read his decision, it was clear.

This court is quashing this indictment without prejudice. So the judge dismissed the charges against Michael Colucci? He dismissed it as if it had never happened. What was the reaction like in the courtroom? I think everyone was stunned. I think it took a moment for people even to realize they could stand up and the

the judge went further to say, you know, telling Mr. Colucci, you know, you don't have to wear that ankle bracelet anymore, the monitoring device. You're free to go. You're not even on bond anymore. That's incredible. And he started crying, Colucci? Oh, yeah. He cried for the rest of the time in the courtroom. And it was very poignant, too, because his daughter was

who thought she was going to come for opening arguments, was headed up the stairs to the courtroom, and Michael Colucci was running down the aisle, and they sort of, you know,

met in the middle in, you know, one of those embraces. It's really unbelievable. So, Carol, this trial is not happening, but this isn't over. The prosecution still has a card to play. They do have a card to play. They could go to a grand jury with what they have, and a different grand jury could decide to indict him again. We don't know what they're going to decide.

Carol, fascinating case. Thank you so much for bringing this to us. You're welcome. Up next, it's time for Dateline Roundup. We've got the latest in the Corey Richens case. She's the children's author accused of poisoning her husband. And the final defendant facing charges in the case of Connecticut mom Jennifer Dulos learns his fate. Plus, scammers are taking advantage of consumers' confusion around tariffs. How to spot the red flags.

NetCredit is here to say yes to a personal loan or line of credit when other lenders say no. Apply in minutes and get a decision as soon as the same day. If approved, applications are typically funded the next business day or sooner. Loans offered by NetCredit or lending partner banks and serviced by NetCredit. Applications subject to review and approval. Learn more at netcredit.com slash partner. NetCredit. Credit to the people. When you say yes.

Don't want to get pregnant right now? It's smart to have a primary birth control method and a backup plan like Plan B One Step. Plan B is safe, effective emergency contraception you take within 72 hours after unprotected sex or birth control failure. The sooner you take it, the better it works.

Whether you've taken it once, twice, or multiple times in the past, taking Plan B after unprotected sex won't impact your ability to get pregnant in the future. Visit planb1step.com slash get to find a store. If you went on a road trip and you didn't stop for a Big Mac or drop a crispy fry between the car seats or use your McDonald's bag as a placemat, then that wasn't a road trip. It was just a really long drive. Ba-da-ba-ba-ba at participating McDonald's.

Welcome back. For this week's Roundup, we're joined by Dateline digital producer Veronica Mazzica. Veronica, thanks for coming back. Thanks for having me. Okay, so up first, Veronica, we've got an update in a case that will likely be familiar to Dateline fans. Jennifer Dulos, the Connecticut mom of five, she went missing in May of 2019 after dropping her kids off at school. Her body has never been found, but she's been declared dead. Remind us just a little bit about the case.

Yes. So her estranged husband, Fotis Doulos, was charged with her murder. He maintained his innocence and later died after attempting suicide. Investigators had surveillance video of him dumping garbage bags they said contained items connected to Jennifer's murder.

And his girlfriend at the time, Michelle Traconis, was found guilty at trial last year of charges of conspiracy to commit murder, conspiracy, tampering with evidence, and hindering prosecution. Okay, so what is new in the case now? So Fotis's friend, a lawyer named Kent Mawinney, had also been charged with conspiracy to commit murder. Authorities alleged that he helped Fotis create an alibi for the time of Jennifer's disappearance.

What's new is that the state has reduced Mawini's charge to interfering with an officer. They say police asked him if he had spoken to Fotis on the day of the murder, and Mawini denied it. But forensic evidence later showed that Mawini had spoken to Fotis when he was allegedly disposing of evidence. After the reduction, Mawini took an Alford plea, and a judge sentenced him to 11 months, which he had already served, so he walked free.

He spoke afterwards, Kent Mawinney, with his attorneys. Let's take a listen. Obviously, it's tragic. But, you know, I have as much responsibility for that tragedy as you do. When he was asked if he knew where Jennifer Dulos was, he said, quote, no, if I did, I would tell them. Hmm. Wow. Yeah, it's such a shame that they've never been able to find her body. Very sad. Hmm.

Up next, we are headed to Summit County, Utah. We've got an update on the case of Corey Richens. You might remember she is the mom who wrote a children's book about grief after her husband died in March three years ago. But then she was arrested for his murder and charged with nine felonies, including aggravated murder and multiple counts of forgery and fraud. Veronica, remind us of some more of the details of this case.

Yeah, so prosecutors say that Richens allegedly poisoned her husband, Eric, by putting a lethal dose of fentanyl in his drink in 2022. According to prosecutors, Corey was in financial hot water over some real estate deals and had taken out life insurance policies on Eric, and she pleaded not guilty. In the past, Veronica, we played some exclusive recordings that Richens sent us from jail. We played them on the podcast.

Here's a quick clip of one of them. So what is the latest in the case? The trial was supposed to start this spring, but the judge allowed a delay so that the Utah Supreme Court could consider whether the trial should be moved to a different county.

Last week, they declined to hear the case. So at a hearing on Friday, Richens finally got a new trial date. It's now scheduled to begin on February 23rd and is expected to last five weeks. And Richens will be back in court on August 1st for a hearing on trial preparations. Okay, we'll keep you posted.

Another high-profile trial, Lori Vallow Daybell. Quick update with her. There has been a verdict in the latest trial in Arizona. She was accused of conspiring to kill her niece's former husband, Brandon Boudreau. So what did the jury decide? All right, the clerk will read and record the verdict. We, the jury, do find the defendant, Lori Daybell, guilty.

And this is her second conviction for murder conspiracy in less than two months. In April, a jury found her guilty of conspiring to kill her husband, Charles Vallow, in 2019. She will be sentenced for both of her convictions at the same time, even though they were separate trials? Yes. So Lori will be sentenced for this conviction as well as the April conviction on July 25th, and both carry the possibility of a life sentence.

All right, Veronica, thank you so much for all this great information. Thank you.

We have all seen tariffs making headlines in recent months, and it can be confusing at times to know if the things we're buying are affected. And that's the perfect opportunity for scammers, according to my next guest, NBC News Chief Investigative Consumer Correspondent Vicki Nguyen. She's back to tell us what to watch out for and how to avoid becoming the victim of these new tariff scams. Hey, Vicki. Hey, Andrea. Yeah, so, okay, this is one I would not have thought of. I was very surprised to find out.

Scammers are nothing if not on trend, Andrea, right? So tariffs in the headlines, major buzzword. And so what these scammers have done is after you place an order for something that you want online, suddenly they'll follow up and say, hey, we've got your item, but there's

a delay because of additional tariffs that need to be paid. So if you want to get your item and have it be released and sent to you, we're going to need you to send some more money. You may fall for that because you want this item. And so that's why the Better Business Bureau has put out an alert to say,

beware of the retailers with whom you're shopping online. And if anyone tries to ask you for money after the fact, that's a major red flag. So you, Vicki, reached out to the Better Business Bureau. What did they tell you as far as what we all can do? They want to go back to shopping with reputable retailers and really watching out for something called a sponsored ad.

ad. You're going to see a lot of these popping up, especially on social media. And it'll say, oh, check out this new company, this product. It looks really great. Some of those are definitely legitimate new small businesses, but others are absolutely purchased and run by scammers. And so

Anytime you're going to spend money with a retailer you haven't heard of, I just want you to take the name of that business and put it into an internet search along with the word scam or along with the word review and just see what are other buyers saying. Have any complaints come up?

Also, look carefully at the website itself. Are there misspellings? If anything looks suspicious on that site or the price is too good to be true, that's typically a red flag. And Vicki, so you found out that there's another kind of tariff scam. The scammers are promising tariff relief. What's that?

What's that? This is wild, and it's the opposite. Instead of saying, hey, you need to pay us for tariffs that are due, the scammers are saying, hey, the government owes you money for tariffs. We're giving you some relief to offset the extra cost of these tariffs.

No, run. Hear me loud and clear when I say the government is not paying you one single cent for tariff. So just if anyone is contacting you, and usually this comes in the form of some message that you did not ask for in your email as a text on your phone, and they say, click here to get your tariff relief.

And really what that link is taking you to is a phishing website. They're going to try to get your name, your payment information, bank account information, even your address to send you a check in the mail. The big picture here, if anyone is offering you any sort of tariff relief, run away.

And, Vicki, if you are one of the unfortunate ones who's fallen victim to one of these tariff scams, what can you do? Make sure, if you already made a purchase, that you call your credit card company or your bank right away. Report it as fraud. If it's very serious and you've lost a lot of money, you can report it to your local police department.

as well as the FTC, the Federal Trade Commission, and the FBI. And that just helps them to keep track of trends and online crimes that are happening so they can put warnings out to the rest of us. Once in a while, they are able to help people recover their money, but, you know, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, as they say. Vicki, this is such good information. As always, thank you for joining us. Thank you.

That's it for this episode of Dateline True Crime Weekly. Don't forget to take a listen to our coverage of the Sean Combs trial. Every day after court, I'll be chatting with NBC News correspondent Chloe Malas about what she's seen, the witnesses, the evidence, and what it all means.

And Josh has a new season of his award-winning podcast series, Dateline Missing in America. Episodes one and two are out now wherever you get your podcasts. So listen closely. You could be the key to solving a mystery.

To get ad-free listening for all of our podcasts, subscribe to Dateline Premium. And a reminder that Dateline is on tonight, Thursday. You can watch my in-depth coverage of the Karen Reid trial. Ladies and gentlemen, there is no doubt what happened that night. This case should be over right now. Why is she even here? That's Center of the Storm tonight at 9, 8 central on NBC.

Dateline True Crime Weekly is produced by Frannie Kelly and Katie Ferguson. Our associate producers are Carson Cummins and Caroline Casey. Our senior producer is Liz Brown-Koroloff. Veronica Mazzica is our digital producer. Rick Kwan is our sound designer. Original music by Jesse McGinty. Bryson Barnes is head of audio production. Paul Ryan is executive producer. And Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline. Anything else, anyone? All right. Thanks very much. See you soon.

Welcome to Birch Lane, where you can find a fresh take on classic furniture and decor. Every piece is hand-picked and crafted to last for years to come. At Birch Lane, you can explore everything from outdoor sets to living room furniture and everything in between, and get fast, free shipping. It's classic style for joyful living. Shop now at birchlane.com.