#149 Open Weights != Open Source with Google Engineer and Stanford Researcher Yifan Mai
freeCodeCamp Podcast
Deep Dive
Why did Yifan Mai leave Google to work at Stanford?
Yifan Mai left Google to work at Stanford because he wanted to focus on research and build infrastructure that supports scientific researchers, rather than being on the faculty track or publishing research himself. He enjoys being close to research and enabling other researchers through open-source software.
What is the HELM project, and what does it aim to do?
The HELM project, led by Yifan Mai, is a research initiative that benchmarks the performance of large language models (LLMs) across various tasks and use cases. It provides a standardized and transparent framework for evaluating models, allowing users to compare their performance on different benchmarks and use cases.
What is the difference between open weights and closed weights in LLMs?
Open weights refer to models where the parameters (weights) are available for anyone to download and run locally, such as Meta's LLaMA. Closed weights, on the other hand, are models like OpenAI's GPT or Google's Gemini, which are only accessible through the company's API or services, and the parameters are not publicly available.
What are some challenges in evaluating LLMs, particularly in high-stakes domains like medicine or law?
Evaluating LLMs in high-stakes domains like medicine or law is challenging because it requires domain-specific benchmarks and expert evaluation. For example, medical advice given by an LLM needs to be assessed by a real doctor, and legal advice requires verification against existing case law. These evaluations are complex and often require human judgment, which is difficult to automate.
What is the 'win rate' concept in the HELM project, and how is it calculated?
The 'win rate' in the HELM project is a metric that measures the probability of one model performing better than another across a variety of benchmarks. It aggregates results from multiple benchmarks to give an overall sense of how models compare to each other in different tasks.
What are some potential harms of LLMs, according to Yifan Mai?
Yifan Mai highlights several potential harms of LLMs, including the generation of harmful outputs like instructions for building bombs or political disinformation. There are also concerns about bias, fairness, and labor displacement, as well as the ethical implications of using AI in high-stakes applications like unemployment benefits processing.
How does Yifan Mai see the future of AI in terms of accessibility and distribution?
Yifan Mai is optimistic about the future of AI accessibility, particularly with the improvement of smaller, more efficient models that can run on consumer-grade hardware like MacBooks. He believes this will make AI more evenly distributed, though he remains concerned about who gets to decide how the technology is used and the power dynamics involved.
What advice does Yifan Mai give to aspiring AI engineers or programmers?
Yifan Mai advises aspiring AI engineers to focus on building strong software engineering fundamentals, including programming, software engineering practices, and foundational knowledge in AI, such as probability and statistics. He believes these fundamentals will be crucial regardless of the specific AI technologies that emerge in the future.
- LLMs are not expected to entirely replace programmers.
- Software engineering fundamentals remain crucial, even in AI.
- Strong foundations in probability and statistics are essential for AI professionals.
Shownotes Transcript