cover of episode Rich Dad Poor Dad

Rich Dad Poor Dad

2023/4/6
logo of podcast If Books Could Kill

If Books Could Kill

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
M
Michael
帮助医生和高收入专业人士管理财务的金融教育者和播客主持人。
P
Peter
Topics
Peter和Michael对《富爸爸穷爸爸》一书进行了深入的批判性分析,指出书中许多观点缺乏事实依据,甚至存在误导性。他们认为作者罗伯特·清崎利用虚构的故事和夸张的描述来宣传其个人理财理念,并对穷人和普通劳动者持有轻蔑的态度。书中关于罗宾汉、熔炼牙膏管、以及彩票中奖者破产等故事均被指出是虚构或夸大的。他们还批评了书中关于税收、投资和房地产等方面的建议,认为这些建议存在误导性,甚至可能触犯法律。此外,他们还揭露了作者罗伯特·清崎通过举办收费研讨会来牟利的行为,认为这是一种欺诈行为。总而言之,Peter和Michael认为《富爸爸穷爸爸》一书并非一本值得信赖的个人理财指南,其内容存在大量虚构和误导性信息,不应被读者盲目接受。 Michael主要负责对书中内容进行事实核查和逻辑分析,并指出书中许多数据和观点存在错误。例如,他指出书中关于70%彩票中奖者破产的统计数据是错误的,并对作者关于金本位制和税收的观点进行了批判。他还详细分析了作者关于“富爸爸”和“穷爸爸”的描述,指出这些描述带有明显的偏见,并且“富爸爸”的形象过于理想化。Michael还对书中关于低工资和童工的描述进行了批判,认为作者对普通劳动者缺乏尊重。总而言之,Michael认为书中缺乏严谨的逻辑和事实依据,其观点存在严重的误导性。

Deep Dive

Chapters

Shownotes Transcript

In 1997, Robert Kiyosaki revealed the secret to lifelong success: Deliver grifty seminars and hire child slaves.Support us on Patreon)**: **https://www.patreon.com/IfBooksPod)**Where to find us: **

  • Twitter)
  • Peter's other podcast, 5-4)
  • Mike's other podcast, Maintenance Phase)

Sources:

  • Pound Foolish: Exposing the Dark Side of the Personal Finance Industry)
  • ‘Rich Dad Poor Dad' Robert Kiyosaki Exposed)
  • Stupid Investment of the Week)
  • Robert Kiyosaki’s Rich Dad Education on Real Estate Investing Review)
  • The Ticket to Easy Street? The Financial Consequences of Winning the Lottery)
  • Why the Myth of the Miserable Lottery Winner Just Won’t Die)
  • Work Centrality and Post-Award Work Behavior of Lottery Winners)
  • "The best way to get even with A-grade students was to make them employees of mine")
  • Ohio real estate investor’s warning statement on Robert Kiyosaki and Bill Gatten’s complex PACtrust for real estate investing)
  • Academic Discipline and Personal Finance Instruction in High School)

Thanks to Mindseye) for our theme song!