cover of episode Plutarch's Parallel Lives

Plutarch's Parallel Lives

2025/1/16
logo of podcast In Our Time

In Our Time

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
A
Andrew Erskine
J
Judith Mossman
P
Paul Cartledge
节目主持人
Topics
节目主持人: 本节目讨论了古希腊传记作家普鲁塔克(约46-120年)及其作品《希腊罗马名人传》,这部作品对后世如何看待古典世界产生了深远的影响。普鲁塔克明确表示他写的是人物传记,而不是历史,他将希腊人和罗马人的生平配对撰写,对比和比较了这些名人的性格、优点和缺点。这种关注伟人内心世界的做法吸引了莎士比亚等后世作家,他们从普鲁塔克的作品中汲取灵感,创作了《凯撒大帝》、《科利奥兰纳斯》、《雅典的提蒙》和《安东尼与克利奥帕特拉》等作品。虽然很少有人效仿普鲁塔克的配对写作方法,但他的作品却影响了无数传记作家,尤其是在启蒙运动时期。 Judith Mossman: 普鲁塔克的旅行大多是为了执行外交任务,这使得他有机会接触到不同地区和文化,并与罗马的精英人士建立联系。他曾在亚历山大图书馆学习,并在罗马教授哲学,这反映了他对知识和文化的追求。普鲁塔克对罗马统治既有肯定也有保留,他既认识到罗马统治带来的稳定性,也对其文化水平有所保留。他巧妙地平衡了罗马世界和希腊文化之间的关系。 Andrew Erskine: 普鲁塔克的传记作品以人物配对为特色,他并非按照时间顺序进行配对,而是根据主题和人物的共同经历进行选择。他关注的是人物的道德品质和性格特征,而非单纯的历史事件。普鲁塔克写作传记的目的是为了教育读者,学习历史人物的优缺点,并从中吸取教训。他通过对人物性格的细致刻画和关键事件的生动描写,展现了人物的复杂性和多面性。 Paul Cartledge: 普鲁塔克选择希腊和罗马人物进行对比,是因为在当时,罗马人被视为荣誉希腊人。他的比较并非简单的同类比较,而是为了进行优劣评判,并从中获得道德启示。普鲁塔克关注的是人物性格和道德品质,而非历史事件本身。他特别关注命运的逆转和人物的内心世界,并通过生动的细节描写和故事讲述,展现了人物的复杂性和多面性。普鲁塔克对罗马统治的态度较为复杂,既肯定其带来的稳定和秩序,也对其文化水平有所保留。他试图在希腊和罗马文化之间架起桥梁,促进两种文化的交流与理解。普鲁塔克的写作手法独树一帜,其作品对后世产生了深远的影响,启蒙思想家如伏尔泰和卢梭都深受其影响。普鲁塔克的作品中包含许多广为人知的故事,影响了人们对古典世界的认知。他并非平等主义者,他偏好罗马的等级制度和精英统治。

Deep Dive

Chapters
This section explores Plutarch's life, highlighting his background in Chaeronea, his travels as an envoy, and his integration into the intellectual circles of the Greco-Roman world. It also touches upon his philosophical writings and his balanced perspective on Roman rule.
  • Plutarch's birthplace in Chaeronea, a town between Athens and Delphi
  • His career as an envoy, leading to extensive travels
  • His contributions as a philosopher and his vast philosophical works
  • His balanced perspective on Roman rule, recognizing both its benefits and drawbacks

Shownotes Transcript

Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss the Greek biographer Plutarch (c46 AD-c120 AD) and especially his work 'Parallel Lives' which has shaped the way successive generations see the Classical world. Plutarch was clear that he was writing lives, not histories, and he wrote these very focussed accounts in pairs to contrast and compare the characters of famous Greeks and Romans, side by side, along with their virtues and vices. This focus on the inner lives of great men was to fascinate Shakespeare, who drew on Plutarch considerably when writing his Julius Caesar, Coriolanus, Timon of Athens and Antony and Cleopatra. While few followed his approach of setting lives in pairs, Plutarch's work was to influence countless biographers especially from the Enlightenment onwards.

With

Judith Mossman Professor Emerita of Classics at Coventry University

Andrew Erskine Professor of Ancient History at the University of Edinburgh

And

Paul Cartledge AG Leventis Senior Research Fellow of Clare College, University of Cambridge

Producer: Simon Tillotson

Reading list:

Mark Beck (ed.), A Companion to Plutarch (Wiley-Blackwell, 2014)

Colin Burrow, Shakespeare and Classical Antiquity (Oxford University Press, 2013), especially chapter 6

Raphaëla Dubreuil, Theater and Politics in Plutarch’s Parallel Lives (Brill, 2023)

Tim Duff, Plutarch’s Lives: Exploring Virtue and Vice (Oxford University Press, 1999)

Noreen Humble (ed.), Plutarch’s Lives: Parallelism and Purpose (Classical Press of Wales, 2010)

Robert Lamberton, Plutarch (Yale University Press, 2002)

Hugh Liebert, Plutarch's Politics: Between City and Empire (Cambridge University Press, 2016)

Christopher Pelling, Plutarch and History (Classical Press of Wales, 2002)

Plutarch (trans. Robin Waterfield), Greek Lives (Oxford University Press, 2008)

Plutarch (trans. Robin Waterfield), Roman Lives (Oxford University Press, 2008)

Plutarch (trans. Robin Waterfield), Hellenistic Lives (Oxford University Press, 2016)

Plutarch (trans. Ian Scott-Kilvert), The Rise and Fall of Athens: Nine Greek Lives (Penguin, 2023)

Plutarch (trans. Ian Scott-Kilvert), The Age of Alexander: Nine Greek Lives (Penguin, 2011)

Plutarch (trans. Richard Talbert), On Sparta (Penguin, 2005)

Plutarch (trans. Christopher Pelling), The Rise of Rome (Penguin, 2013)

Plutarch (trans. Christopher Pelling), Rome in Crisis: Nine Lives (Penguin, 2010)

Plutarch (trans. Rex Warner), The Fall of the Roman Republic: Six Lives (Penguin, 2006)

Plutarch (trans. Thomas North, ed. Judith Mossman), The Lives of the Noble Grecians and Romans (Wordsworth, 1998)

Geert Roskam, Plutarch (Cambridge University Press, 2021)

D. A. Russell, Plutarch (2nd ed., Bristol Classical Press, 2001)

Philip A. Stadter, Plutarch and his Roman Readers (Oxford University Press, 2014)

Frances B. Titchener and Alexei V. Zadorojnyi (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Plutarch (Cambridge University Press, 2023)

In Our Time is a BBC Studios Audio Production