The full post is long, but you can 80/20 the value with the 700 word summary! Over half the post is eight optional case studies. Thanks to Jemima Jones, Claude 4 Opus and Gemini 2.5 Pro for help copy-editing and drafting

TL;DR: I recommend giving advice by asking questions to walk someone through key steps in my argument — often I’m missing key info, which comes up quickly as an unexpected answer, while if I’m right I’m more persuasive, and can still express my case. This is useful in a wide range of settings, as a manager, managee, friend, and mentor, and is better for both parties, if you have the time and energy and are able to seriously engage with whether you are wrong.

Summary

Socratic Persuasion: When trying to persuade someone, especially if giving advice, I much prefer the Socratic method over directly presenting my case. I take my argument/thought [...]

---

Outline:

(00:57) Summary

(06:56) Why does this matter?

(10:26) Caveats & Warnings

(13:26) Case Studies

(13:51) Managing/prioritisation: Convincing a team member that a project is a better use of their time

(18:27) Debugging/giving negative feedback: Retrospectives on Time Management

(21:14) Interpersonal/conflict resolution: Friend Having a Dispute

(23:06) Domain knowledge/negative feedback: Critiquing Research Project Ideas

(25:43) Ambition/career advice: Encouraging Someone to Drop Out of a PhD (to Accept a Job Offer)

(29:18) Debating: Convincing Someone We Can't Just Turn Misaligned AI Off

(32:22) Reflection/self-improvement: Receiving Negative Feedback

(35:23) Coaching/career advice: Giving Career Advice to Someone I've Just Met

(38:29) Conclusion

The original text contained 7 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
May 26th, 2025

Source:
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/zesWv9YipxY8pQFKu/socratic-persuasion-giving-opinionated-yet-truth-seeking

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

“Socratic Persuasion: Giving Opinionated Yet Truth-Seeking Advice” by Neel Nanda 39:40 Share

LessWrong (30+ Karma)

Shownotes Transcript

“Socratic Persuasion: Giving Opinionated Yet Truth-Seeking Advice” by Neel Nanda