Hermes Homerica: They're Making an Odyssey Movie & We Have Thoughts
Let's Talk About Myths, Baby! Greek & Roman Mythology Retold
Deep Dive
Why is the casting of Matt Damon as Odysseus in Christopher Nolan's Odyssey adaptation so controversial?
The casting of Matt Damon as Odysseus is controversial because many critics and fans believe he is not suitable for the role. They argue that Damon is too reliable and lacks the complexity and Mediterranean appearance required for Odysseus. Additionally, the casting is seen as a step back in terms of diversity and representation, resembling the whitewashed casting of past Hollywood adaptations of ancient Greek stories.
Why is the Odyssey considered a suitable subject for a Christopher Nolan film?
The Odyssey is considered a suitable subject for a Christopher Nolan film because of its narrative structure, which includes elements of time manipulation and unreliable narration. These elements align well with Nolan's style, as seen in films like Inception and Interstellar, which also play with time and narrative complexity.
Why is the casting of women of color as divine seductresses in the Odyssey adaptation seen as problematic?
The casting of women of color as divine seductresses, such as Calypso and Circe, is seen as problematic because it reinforces stereotypes and limits the roles of women of color to seductive and otherworldly characters. Critics argue that this casting choice lacks nuance and fails to represent the complexity of these characters and the diverse Mediterranean setting of the Odyssey.
Why is the prospect of a diverse cast for the Odyssey adaptation important to the hosts?
A diverse cast for the Odyssey adaptation is important to the hosts because it would more accurately reflect the Mediterranean setting and the diverse populations of the ancient world. They argue that casting actors who more closely resemble the characters' backgrounds would enhance the authenticity and cultural representation of the film.
Why does the host suggest that Matt Damon could be a better fit for Jason in the Argonautica instead of Odysseus?
The host suggests that Matt Damon could be a better fit for Jason in the Argonautica because the character of Jason, like Odysseus, is a leader but with a different set of traits. Jason's role in the Argonautica might align better with Damon's reliable and straightforward acting style, making it a potentially more suitable and interesting casting choice.
Shownotes Transcript