Tonight, author Stacy Horn returns to take us deep inside one of the most chilling institutions in American history—Blackwell’s Island. Once hailed as a visionary experiment in humane care, it quickly devolved into a hellscape of madness, misery, and corruption.

In her haunting book Damnation Island: Poor, Sick, Mad and Criminal in 19th Century New York, Horn exposes the nightmarish reality behind the asylum walls—where the sick were abandoned, the poor punished, and the so-called insane subjected to unspeakable horrors. With voices lifted from long-buried archives, she brings to life the forgotten souls who endured it, and the few who dared to speak out, including the fearless Nellie Bly and a tormented reverend caught between compassion and chaos.

This is not just a history—it’s a descent into the shadows of a society that chose to look away.

Unlock a world of mystery!

Join our exclusive community and instantly access over 1,000 ad-free episodes, mind-blowing bonus segments, and much more. Dive deeper into the unknown with content that challenges what you think you know.

For nearly a decade, Mysterious Radio has taken listeners on a journey through the strange, the unexplained, and the downright chilling. And now, we're taking things to the next level—with even more immersive content available only to our most dedicated listeners.

With millions of listeners around the globe, the next era of Mysterious Radio is unfolding. The majority of episodes and exclusives will be reserved for our inner circle of members.

Step beyond the veil and claim your place in the next chapter of the unknown. OPEN THE DOOR

Get the ultimate experience and easy access to everything from the Patreon app!

Download Patreon for IOS

Download Patreon for Android

Follow Our Other Shows
Follow UFO Witnesses
Follow Crime Watch Weekly
Follow Paranormal Fears
Follow Seven: Disturbing Chronicle Stories

Join our Patreon for ad-free listening and more bonus content.
Follow us on Instagram @mysteriousradio
Follow us on TikTok mysteriousradioTikTok
Follow us on Twitter @mysteriousradio
Follow us on Pinterest pinterest.com/mysteriousradio
Like us on Facebook Facebook.com/mysteriousradio]

Blackwell Island: New York's 19th Century Madhouse 53:07 Share

Mysterious Radio: Paranormal, UFO & Lore Interviews

Shownotes Transcript

Blackwell Island: New York's 19th Century Madhouse