The Brown family believed they were dealing with a vampire because consumption (tuberculosis) had claimed the lives of Mary Brown (the mother), Mary Olive (the eldest daughter), and Mercy Brown (the youngest daughter). Edwin, the only son, was also gravely ill. The family and locals, desperate for answers, turned to folklore, suspecting a vampire was draining Edwin's life force. This belief was fueled by Edwin waking up with blood on his mouth and neck, which they interpreted as signs of a vampire feeding on him.
In March 1892, George Brown, desperate to save his son Edwin, exhumed the bodies of his wife Mary and daughter Mary Olive. Finding them decomposed, they turned to Mercy's body, which had been stored in a stone keep. Mercy's body showed no decomposition, and her position had shifted. A local doctor cut open her chest, finding liquid blood in her heart, which the locals took as proof she was the vampire. They burned her heart and liver, mixed the ashes with water, and fed the concoction to Edwin as a cure.
No, the remedy did not work. Edwin Brown died less than two months later on May 2, 1892, despite consuming the ashes of his sister's organs. The gruesome act, rooted in folklore, failed to save him from consumption.
Mercy's body showed signs of movement and lack of decomposition because she was stored in a stone keep during the winter. The cold temperatures slowed decomposition significantly. Additionally, natural processes like muscle tightening, gas buildup, and blood liquefaction can cause a body to shift or appear preserved. These phenomena were misunderstood at the time, leading to the belief that she was a vampire.
Newspaper articles about Mercy Brown's exhumation and the vampire scare circulated widely, even reaching Scotland. Bram Stoker, who was researching vampire folklore for his novel Dracula, included these accounts in his files. Mercy's story likely contributed to the modern vampire mythos, particularly the idea of vampires as undead creatures feeding on the living.
In 1900, the average life expectancy in the U.S. was 47-48 years, largely due to diseases like tuberculosis and limited medical knowledge. By 1920, it rose to 61 years, and today it is around 78-79 years. Advances in medicine, vaccines, and healthcare have significantly increased life expectancy and quality of life over the past century.
Mercy Brown's story highlights how societies react to pandemics with fear and desperation, often turning to folklore or unproven remedies when science fails to provide immediate answers. During COVID-19, similar behaviors emerged, such as the promotion of unverified treatments. The story serves as a reminder that fear and misinformation can lead to irrational actions during health crises.
Welcome to New England Legends From the Vault – FtV Episode 97 – Jeff Belanger and Ray Auger head over the area surrounding Archer’s Pond and Polly’s Crossing in Ossipee, New Hampshire, in search of ghosts, curses, plagues, and the story behind an alleged mass murder. So many legends swirl around this place that it’s tough to know where to begin, but after searching news archives and town records, we find there’s something to all of the stories. This episode first aired March 28, 2019
Listen ad-free plus get early access and bonus episodes at: https://www.patreon.com/NewEnglandLegends)