Episode 281: The Silken Thomas Rebellion
16:14 Share

Hey, let's talk about your expense report. I didn't submit an expense report. You will. Custom saddles and dog training services are not within policy. What are you talking about? SAP.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you

Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.

Hey, hey, hey, friend. Welcome, welcome to the Renaissance English History Podcast, a part of the Agora Podcast Network and the original Tudor History Podcast telling stories of Tudor England since 2009. I am Heather. I am delighted that you are here with me. Today, we are going to talk about the Silken Thomas Rebellion. So in the summer of 1534, there was a young Irish noble named Thomas Fitzgerald

who stood before an assembly in St. Mary's Abbey in Dublin and threw down the sword of state, renouncing his loyalty to Henry VIII. He was 21 years old. Thomas, who was nicknamed Silken Thomas for the elaborate silken fringes his followers wore on their helmets, declared open rebellion against the English crown.

It was a reckless move, but in that moment he believed he was striking a blow for Ireland, for his family's legacy, and perhaps even for his own survival. It did not end well. By 1537, Thomas and his five uncles would be executed at Tyburn, the Fitzgerald dynasty would be crushed, and English rule in Ireland would take a new and harsher turn.

But how did it all unravel so quickly? What led this young Irish lord to gamble everything against Henry VIII and why did he lose? Today we are going to dive into the dramatic story of the Silk and Thomas Rebellion, an uprising born out of misinformation, ambition, and the shifting power dynamics between England and Ireland.

Before we begin, though, just a little heads up. I've got something very special coming up over spring break in a couple of weeks. It's not quite time for details yet, but if you enjoy diving deep into Tudor history with me, you are going to want to keep an eye out for an announcement soon. You can sign up to my newsletter list if you're not already on there. I send out weekly newsletters with Tudor information, Tudor news, Tudor events,

at englandcast.com slash newsletter, englandcast.com slash newsletter, and you can find out about this exciting spring break adventure. But for now, let's get back to Ireland in the 1530s, where a single decision changed the fate of an entire family.

To understand why Thomas Fitzgerald's rebellion was such a seismic moment in Irish history, we need to take a step back and look at the power his family held and the growing tensions that made his revolt almost inevitable.

By the early 16th century, Ireland was technically under English rule, but the reality was far messier. The English-controlled Pail, which was a region around Dublin, operated under direct royal authority, but beyond it, Gaelic lords and powerful Anglo-Irish families like the Fitzgeralds ruled with near-complete autonomy.

For decades, the English crown had relied on a policy of appointing the most powerful Irish nobles as Lord Deputy of Ireland, a sort of royal governor, to maintain control without having to exert too much direct effort. More often than not, that position fell to the Fitzgeralds, one of the most dominant families in Ireland.

Thomas's father, Gerald Fitzgerald, the 9th Earl of Kildare, had been Lord Deputy on and off for much of Henry VII and Henry VIII's reign. He was a powerful, cunning man who was deeply entrenched in Irish politics, but his influence made him enemies, particularly among Henry VIII's advisors in England who were increasingly suspicious of the Fitzgeralds' loyalty.

Thomas Wolsey, and later Thomas Cromwell, saw Kildare as unreliable, too close to the Irish clans, too independent, possibly even treasonous. Things came to a head in 1534. By this point, Henry VIII was in the middle of his break with Rome, making England's control over Ireland even more crucial.

The last thing Henry wanted was a powerful Irish nobleman who might align himself with Catholic Europe against him. On top of that, Kildare had enemies within Ireland itself, rival families like the butlers, led by Pierce Butler, Earl of Ormond, who were eager to see the Fitzgeralds fall. That year, Gerald Fitzgerald was summoned to England, supposedly to answer charges of mismanagement.

Whether Henry VIII truly intended to execute him is unclear, but what is certain is that once Kildare was in London, he was stripped of his authority and thrown into the Tower. Back in Ireland, Thomas, still in his early 20s, was left in charge as acting Lord Deputy. And then everything fell out of control.

So it's the summer of 1534. Thomas Fitzgerald is in a very precarious position. His father, Gerald Fitzgerald, has been summoned to England under suspicious circumstances. Thomas is barely 21 years old and he's left to govern Ireland in his place. It was a daunting responsibility, but at first Thomas seemed willing to play by the rules. He had been trained for leadership, raised in the world of Anglo-Irish politics, and had been a great leader.

And he knew that his family's power rested on balancing loyalty to the English crown with the realities of ruling a volatile land. But then came the rumors, the whispers that his father had been executed in the Tower of London. It's unclear exactly how Thomas first heard this supposed news. But in a period where misinformation could spread as fast as a messenger's horse, it didn't take long for panic to set in.

If the rumors were true, it meant that the Fitzgeralds were finished. Gerald Fitzgerald had been the glue holding their influence together, and if Henry had disposed of him, Thomas would likely be next. The logical move would have been to wait for confirmation, to gather intelligence before acting. But Thomas was young and impulsive, and he made a fatal miscalculation.

On June 11, 1534, he rode into Dublin at the head of 140 horsemen dressed in full battle attire and he entered St. Mary's Abbey, the stronghold of the English administration.

Before a stunned audience of officials and noblemen, he dramatically renounced his allegiance to Henry. He declared himself the true ruler of Ireland, proclaiming his defiance of English oppression. Whether he truly believed his father was dead or simply using it as a justification for rebellion is uncertain, but once he had spoken, there was no turning back.

The rebellion quickly gathered momentum. Many Irish lords, especially those with grievances against English rule, saw an opportunity to shake off foreign control and rally to Thomas's side. His forces swelled as Gaelic clans joined him, seeing the Fitzgeralds as their best chance to resist Tudor encroachment. His followers saw him not just as a noble in revolt, but as a figurehead for Irish independence.

And though the rebellion had been sparked by a misunderstanding, it was also fueled by deeper resentments against Henry VIII's increasing demands, against English administrators who treated Irish lords as second-class rulers, and against the creeping influence of the Protestant Reformation. But if Thomas expected a quick victory, he had underestimated just how seriously Henry and his advisors would take his challenge.

This rebellion was happening at the same time Henry was breaking with the Pope and asserting his authority as the head of the Church of England. From the English perspective, this was a dangerous act of rebellion. This was more than just some kind of family feud. This had to be crushed and soon. The full weight of the Tudor military power would come bearing down on Ireland.

Now, at first, it seemed like Silk and Thomas might actually pull the whole thing off. After declaring his rebellion in June, he launched an assault on Dublin Castle, the administrative heart of English power in Ireland. Though he failed to take the castle itself, his forces ravaged the surrounding city, asserting control over much of the pale, the area around Dublin that was still firmly under English rule.

English officials, taken by surprise, were forced to barricade themselves inside the castle, desperately waiting for reinforcements from across the Irish Sea. This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.

On average, you'll have to wait 31 days to see an OBGYN. And if you're dealing with an infection or outbreak, you know you need care fast. That's where WISP comes in. Connect with a U.S. licensed provider online and pick up safe, effective care.

effective treatment at your local pharmacy that same day. Plus, get birth control and more delivered in all 50 states. Take control with comprehensive sexual and reproductive care off of your phone. WISP. That's HelloWISP.com. The waiting room can wait.

Bombas makes the most comfortable socks, underwear, and t-shirts. Warning, Bombas are so absurdly comfortable you may throw out all your other clothes. Sorry, do we legally have to say that? No, this is just how I talk and I really love my Bombas. They do feel that good and they do good too. One item purchased equals one item donated. To feel good and do good, go to bombas.com slash ACAST and use code ACAST for 20% off your first purchase. That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash ACAST and use code ACAST at checkout.

Thomas had the numbers. His forces swelled as Irish lords joined him, many seeing this as their best chance to push back against English control.

But his rebellion wasn't just a clean military campaign. It became a bloody and chaotic conflict, marked by massacres and, of course, always shifting alliances. Thomas's men slaughtered Loyalist settlers and attacked English garrisons, while Henry's forces, once they arrived, retaliated with equal brutality. Among the most shocking moments came in July 1534, when Thomas's forces captured John Allen, the Archbishop of Dublin.

Alan had been trying to flee to England, but his ship was forced ashore by bad weather. When he was captured, he pleaded for his life, claiming he was only an administrator and not a military threat. It might have saved him, if not for a horrible miscommunication. Thomas allegedly ordered his men not to kill the archbishop, but by the time the message got through, Alan had already been hacked to death.

The murder of a high-ranking churchman horrified many and turned the public opinion against Thomas, even among some of his supporters. The real turning point, though, came in early 1535 with the arrival of Sir William Skeffington, Henry VIII's new Lord Deputy of Ireland. Skeffington had been sent to do one thing, crush the rebellion, no matter the cost, and he wasted no time.

Using heavy artillery, something rarely seen in Irish conflicts at the time, Skeffington began to systematically batter Fitzgerald's strongholds. The most significant target was Maynooth Castle, the Fitzgerald's seat of power and a very formidable fortress. In March 1535, after a short but devastating siege, Maynooth fell to English cannon fire.

The castle's defenders, who had believed they would be offered mercy if they surrendered, were executed en masse in what became known as the Maynooth Pardon. The shocking betrayal sent a chilling message. No quarter would be given to rebels.

With Maynooth lost and his forces dwindling, Thomas' rebellion began to unravel. One by one, his allies abandoned him, seeing the writing on the wall. By August of 1535, a little over a year after the whole thing started, Thomas was on the run. His power was broken. Some sources suggest that he might have been betrayed by his own men. Others say that he surrendered voluntarily.

Either way, he was somehow handed over to the English authorities, believing that Henry VIII might still show him mercy. After all, he was still young, a nobleman, and had once been a loyal servant of the crown. Perhaps there was a chance to negotiate. He was wrong. After his surrender in August 1535, he was taken to England in chains and imprisoned in the tower. For nearly two years he lingered there, his fate uncertain.

Perhaps at some point he believed that Henry might still spare him. After all, noblemen, even rebellious ones, were sometimes ransomed or allowed to live under house arrest. But Henry had no intention of showing mercy.

Silken Thomas had defied the crown at a moment when Henry was consolidating power as supreme head of the Church of England. This was also right around the time of the Pilgrimage of Grace, of killing Anne Boleyn. Henry was not in a very merciful mood. He needed to send a message that defying the Tudor state, especially in Ireland, would not be tolerated. On February 3rd, 1537, Thomas Fitzgerald, he was only 24 years old, was led to Tyburn, the infamous execution site in London.

He was hanged, drawn, and quartered, the brutal punishment reserved for traitors. Normally, noblemen would receive just death by beheading. But no, he received the full horrors of a traitor's death.

But his death was just one part of the crown's systemic dismantling of the Fitzgerald family. Henry VIII was determined to wipe out the Fitzgerald lineage entirely. Five of Thomas's uncles, Sir Richard, Sir John, Sir James, Sir Oliver, and Sir Walter Fitzgerald, were also arrested and executed alongside him.

This was super unusual. Even when noble families fell from grace, some members were often spared. But in this case, Henry ensured there would be no Fitzgerald resurgence. The once mighty dynasty that had ruled Ireland for generations was now leaderless and shattered. With Thomas dead and his uncles executed, the Fitzgerald lands were confiscated and their allies were either executed, exiled, or forced into submission.

The family's vast network of power, built over centuries, was dismantled almost overnight. The rebellion had not only failed, it had given Henry the perfect excuse to tighten his grip on Ireland in a way no English king had done before. For centuries, England had ruled Ireland through powerful Anglo-Irish noble families, essentially outsourcing governance to local lords who acted as intermediaries.

But Thomas's rebellion shattered that model. Henry VIII no longer trusted the great Irish families to keep order. Instead, he began moving to direct rule, a process that would eventually lead to the full Tudor conquest of Ireland. I actually did an episode about maybe eight or nine years ago on the Tudors in Ireland, and I will link to that as well here in the show notes, and you can listen to that episode.

In 1541, just a few years after Thomas's rebellion, Henry declared himself the King of Ireland, replacing the old feudal-style Lordship of Ireland. This marked the beginning of a much harsher, more centralized form of English rule, one that would see increased military campaigns, plantation settlements, and the gradual erosion of Irish autonomy.

Though Silk and Thomas' rebellion ended in disaster, it was far from the last act of resistance against English rule. If anything, it set the stage for later Irish uprising, including the Desmond rebellions of 1569-83 and then the Nine Years' War from 1593-1603. The Fitzgerald Rebellion became an early warning sign of the growing tensions between England and Ireland, tensions that would continue for centuries.

Now, ironically, despite Henry's ruthless efforts, the Fitzgerald family did not vanish entirely. The last surviving son of Gerald Fitzgerald, the 10th Earl of Kildare, escaped execution as a child and eventually returned to Ireland, though his family would never regain the same level of power. Today, Silke and Thomas is remembered both as a reckless young noble and an early symbol of Irish resistance to English domination.

His rebellion may have been doomed from the start, but it did mark a turning point in the long and often bloody history between England and Ireland. And with that, we close the chapter on Silken Thomas and the Fitzgerald Rebellion. But if there's one thing Tudor history teaches us, it's that no rebellion, no matter how doomed, ever truly fades away. So check out that episode I did on the English in Ireland for more details on how things turned out for Tudor.

for the English in Ireland. It's like very aptly named. Anyway, my friend, we will leave it there for now. Thank you so much for listening. Thank you so much for being here. Thanks for taking the time out of your day to hang out with me and talk about Irish rebellions. I will be back again next week. Have an amazing week and I will speak with you soon. Bye-bye.

Thank you.

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states. Mazda crafts cars for those who choose to do more. And the Mazda CX-50 Hybrid will take you farther.

What you choose to do with all those extra miles is up to you. Mazda. Move and be moved.