Who Does Science? Under Trump, That Could Change
12:12 Share

This message comes from Soladyne. Yesterday's approach to storage can't meet the demands of today's AI ambitions. Bigger, faster, and more energy efficient, Soladyne solid-state storage solutions are optimized for AI. Learn more at storageforai.com. You're listening to Shortwave from NPR.

Hey, short wavers. Emily Kwong here. So the next four years are likely to be difficult for foreign-born scientists who want to work in the United States. That's because the incoming Trump administration wants to make it harder for these scientists to get a work visa or a green card. John Hamilton is with me. As a science correspondent who regularly talks to a lot of these scientists, you've been reporting on what this could mean for research in the U.S., right? I have. And it sounds like it could be trouble because...

Even though President-elect Donald Trump's focus has been on deporting millions of undocumented residents, that ever could spill over into the visas that allow a lot of foreign-born scientists to work here legally. Why is there such a concern that that will happen? The concern is based on what happened during Trump's first term. That was from 2017 to 2021. Early on, the president made a point of tolerating

I do remember this. The

Conflict over H-1B visas. And those are used by people who are doing, let's say, computer or software engineering at places like Amazon or Google. A lot of tech hubs use these visas. Yeah, that's right. I mean, even Elon Musk says he worked under an H-1B visa before becoming a citizen. But, you know, it's not just the tech sector. A lot of researchers at the National Institutes of Health are working under an H-1B visa.

But Trump saw the visas as a way to replace U.S. workers with cheaper foreign labor. Back in 2017, just a couple of months into his first term, he gave this speech at Snap-on Tools in Kenosha, Wisconsin. He was standing in front of this American flag made of red, white and blue wrenches. This will stop. American workers have long called for reforms to end these visa abuses. And today their calls are being answered for the first time.

That includes taking the first steps to set in motion a long overdue reform of H-1B visas. It's worth noting here that Snap-on Tools itself has employees working under an H-1B, though the president may not have known that at the time.

And he followed through on this promise, though, in his first term. He absolutely did. He used an executive order to make H-1B visas much harder to get. The denial rate for those visas doubled or tripled depending on whose statistics you use. Some specialties were no longer eligible. And then in 2020, he temporarily closed the borders to people trying to enter with an H-1B visa.

The architect of a lot of this effort was Stephen Miller, who was a policy advisor to Trump at the time. Now Miller is back as Trump's Homeland Security advisor and the deputy chief of staff. And all of this is making a lot of research institutions wonder whether they're in for another battle over visas.

Today on the show, how a change in immigration policy could cause a scientific brain drain. And why other countries could stand to benefit. You are listening to Shortwave, the science podcast from NPR.

This message comes from Capital One. Say hello to stress-free subscription management. Easily track, block, or cancel recurring charges right from the Capital One mobile app. Simple as that. Learn more at CapitalOne.com slash subscriptions. Terms and conditions apply.

This message comes from Schwab. With Schwab Investing Themes, it's easy to invest in ideas you believe in, like online music and videos, artificial intelligence, electric vehicles, and more. Schwab's research uncovers emerging trends, then their technology curates relevant stocks into over 40 themes to choose from. Schwab Investing Themes is not intended to be investment advice or a recommendation of any stock or investment strategy. Visit schwab.com slash thematic investing.

This message comes from Greenlight. Parents rank financial literacy as the number one most difficult life skill to teach. With Greenlight, the debit card and money app for families, kids learn to earn, save, and spend wisely. Get started today at greenlight.com slash NPR.

OK, John Hamilton, let's talk about H-1B visas. How many people currently are working under them? It's somewhere around 600,000. So Congress set an overall cap of 85,000 new H-1B visas each year, and they allow a person to work for up to six years. But of those 85,000 visas that are granted each year, 20,000 are reserved for workers who have at least a master's degree from a university in the U.S.,

Also, to be considered for any H-1B visa, you need to be sponsored by an employer who declares that no U.S. worker is being displaced. Oh, I didn't realize that. So in order to offer it as an employer, you have to demonstrate there wasn't a competitive U.S. candidate that could fill that role. Exactly.

The employers also must pay at least the prevailing wage to anyone working under an H-1B. And I should add that this is what's called a non-immigrant visa. That means it's designed to be a guest worker program for highly educated people, not a path to citizenship. Got it. OK, so how important are these H-1B visas then to science in the U.S.? They're pretty important. You know, when you walk through a typical research lab in the U.S., you tend to encounter scientists from all over the world.

Europe, the UK, Asia, Australia, the Middle East, South America, you know, everywhere, right? A lot of them came to the U.S. as students because we have some of the best schools in the world. That means they probably came here under a student visa. But in order to stay and work, they need to either get a green card, which is not a visa. It gives a person permanent residence. And so it's hard to get. Or they need to get a visa, often an H-1B. What happens?

What happens when H-1B visas get then more difficult to obtain? One thing that happens is that some of the very best scientists simply choose to work somewhere else. I mean, I spoke about that with a brain scientist named Raimundo Baez-Mendoza. For me, he kind of personifies the world of high-level science. He was born in Mexico, got his master's at the Max Planck Institute in Germany, then his Ph.D. at Cambridge University in the U.K.,

That's an impressive roster. When I first met Raimundo back in 2019, he was working at Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School under an H-1B visa. And this was at a scientific meeting in Chicago. And Raimundo was there because he was presenting a poster on behalf of another scientist named Hamid Reza Ramazanpour.

I'm a colleague of Hamid Barresa. He's a great scientist and he's based in Germany. He wanted to come here to present his work and he wasn't able because his visa was denied.

That was because Hamid Reza had an Iranian passport. This was during what was called Trump's Muslim ban, which closed the border to people with passports from certain countries, including Iran. Do we know where Hamid Reza is now? I believe he is now at York University in Toronto, Canada. So not in the U.S. And what about Raymundo? Did he stay at Harvard?

Nope. The European Union offered him a grant to start a lab in Germany. So he's in Göttingen studying the brain circuits involved in social interactions. I actually called him up after Trump got reelected to see what he thought. And he says he didn't choose Europe just because of the visa policies he encountered during Trump's first term. But he did talk about living in Cambridge, Massachusetts, which is this kind of bubble where

He says when he went outside that bubble, you know, he saw things like road signs that were pretty hostile to immigrants. So all that kind of factored into his decision. And now Raimundo is really pretty worried that if the incoming administration goes after H-1B visas again, it could really hurt the U.S. scientific enterprise. Other countries are more open towards immigration and towards immigrants will stand to gain, you know,

And that was a little bit the case with Brexit. A lot of countries in Europe benefited from Brexit in the sense of

capturing really amazing scientists that were working in Britain. Right. Brexit. I mean, among the many things it did, it made it a lot harder for scientists in the European Union to work in the UK. It did. And we're talking about some really top-ranked international scientists here. You know, they've lived in different countries. Many of them speak several languages. They have got options. Yeah.

Institutions compete to get them. So if you put up barriers in one country, these top people are likely to go somewhere else. Oh, they're in demand. They are indeed. I have been talking with another brain scientist about that very thing. Her name is Lely Mortazavi. She was born in Iran, was living in Canada, and then wanted to go to graduate school at Stanford.

But she almost didn't get to go there because she still had an Iranian passport. She got a Canadian passport just in time to attend Stanford. When I spoke with her in 2019, she was just beginning her studies there. But even then, Lely was pretty concerned about visa and immigration policies that seemed designed to keep out people like her. Everyone I meet here,

It's very welcoming. But for sure, it's kind of sad to be in a country that has these policies in effect. I really hope that they change soon. It sounds similar. Like Stanford is a bubble of welcoming, but beyond that, the policies are not.

That is exactly correct. And it's worth noting that, you know, her hope came true temporarily. The policies did change under President Biden. H-1B visas got easier to get and so on. But now with the incoming Trump administration, they're likely to change back and they could get even more restrictive. I spoke with Lely again after Trump's reelection, and she says she expects to get her Ph.D. in just a few months.

Then she'll have to decide whether to look for a job in the U.S. or somewhere else. I really like Stanford. Stanford people here are great. The resources are amazing. But as I said, like, I would have to...

see what kinds of changes happen under Trump. So do you have any sense of what Lely is going to do? It's unclear, but I do know she's looking at jobs in Canada and the UK. And that's pretty typical for people who have that sort of academic pedigree. You know, the very scientists who could be most valuable to research institutions in the U.S.,

are the same scientists who have the greatest ability to go somewhere else. Have you heard from people that this kind of policy would allow for opportunities in the sciences for American citizens? What I hear is that American schools do not produce nearly enough top-level scientists to fill all the jobs that are out there. This is not a desire to hire foreign workers. This is labs and research institutions that

Yeah.

Not one wanted to talk on the record, which tells me that they are really concerned about being targeted for criticizing this policy before it arrives. John Hamilton, science correspondent for NPR. Thank you so much for bringing us this reporting. Always a pleasure. Short Wavers, thank you for listening. Make sure you never miss a new episode by following us on whichever podcast platform you're listening to right now.

This episode was produced by Rachel Carlson, and it was edited by our showrunner, Rebecca Ramirez. Tyler Jones, check the facts. Beth Donovan is our senior director, and Colin Campbell is our senior vice president of podcasting strategy. I'm Emily Kwong. And I'm John Hamilton. See you tomorrow for more Shortwave from NPR.

This message comes from NPR sponsor Merrill. Whatever your financial goals are, you want a straightforward path there. But the real world doesn't usually work that way. Merrill understands that.

That's why, with a dedicated Merrill advisor, you get a personalized plan and a clear path forward. Go to ml.com slash bullish to learn more. Merrill, a Bank of America company. What would you like the power to do? Investing involves risk. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc., registered broker-dealer, registered investment advisor, member SIPC.

Support for NPR and the following message come from Edward Jones. What is rich? Maybe it's less about reaching a magic number and more about discovering the magic in life. Edward Jones Financial Advisors are people you can count on for financial strategies that help support a life you love. Edward Jones, member SIPC.

Support for this podcast and the following message come from Autograph Collection Hotels, with over 300 independent hotels around the world, each exactly like nothing else. Autograph Collection is part of the Marriott Bonvoy portfolio of hotel brands. Find the unforgettable at AutographCollection.com.