We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Did the Suaalii send off ruin the game? | Paul Gallen gets honest as the Blues go down

Did the Suaalii send off ruin the game? | Paul Gallen gets honest as the Blues go down

2024/6/5
logo of podcast The Continuous Call Team

The Continuous Call Team

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
#sports#psychological impact of football People
P
Paul Gallen
S
Scotty
Topics
@Scotty 认为裁判的判罚不公平,使得比赛失去了观赏性,并对比赛结果产生了负面影响。他认为这并非一次故意的犯规行为,而是意外的碰撞,裁判应该运用常识进行判罚。 @Paul Gallen 认为Suaalii被罚下场导致新南威尔士队以少打多,最终输掉了比赛。尽管球员们非常努力,但人数上的劣势使得他们难以维持比赛的能量和节奏,最终输掉了比赛。 @Gary 作为一名观众,虽然对判罚结果感到失望,但他认为裁判做出了正确的决定,因为任何对头部有力的撞击都应该受到处罚,以保护球员的安全。他同时指出,如果新的观众看到这样的犯规行为,可能会对橄榄球运动产生负面印象。 @评论员 们则从多个角度分析了Suaalii被罚下场对比赛的影响,既肯定了裁判判罚的正确性,也指出了这一判罚对比赛结果和观赏性的负面影响。他们认为,Suaalii的犯规行为直接导致了比赛结果的改变,同时也让观众错失了观看明星球员Reece Walsh比赛的机会。 评论员们认为Suaalii的犯规行为对比赛产生了巨大的影响,直接导致了比赛结果的改变。他们既肯定了裁判判罚的正确性,也指出了这一判罚对比赛结果和观赏性的负面影响。

Deep Dive

Suaalii被罚下场:公平与观赏性之间的博弈

Suaalii在比赛上半场的犯规被罚下场,引发了关于裁判判罚、比赛公平性和观赏性的大讨论。这场争议的核心在于:一次意外的碰撞是否应该导致如此严厉的处罚,以及这是否彻底改变了比赛的走向。

Scotty认为裁判的判罚极不公平。他指出,这并非一次蓄意的犯规,而是一次意外的碰撞,裁判缺乏常识性的判断,直接扼杀了比赛的精彩程度,尤其对这场比赛的品牌宣传造成了负面影响。他甚至认为,效仿AFL取消红牌制度或许更合理。

与Scotty的观点形成对比,Paul Gallen则从比赛结果的角度分析了这一事件。他认为,Suaalii被罚下场后,新南威尔士队以少打多长达72分钟,这使得他们即使拼尽全力,也难以维持比赛的能量和节奏,最终导致了失利。尽管球员们表现英勇,但人数上的劣势最终压垮了他们。

观众Gary的观点则更具平衡性。作为一名Penrith的支持者,他虽然对判罚结果感到失望,但承认裁判展现了勇气,做出了正确的决定。他强调,任何对头部有力的撞击都必须受到严厉处罚,这是为了保护球员的安全。同时,他也担忧,这样的犯规行为可能会给新观众留下橄榄球运动充斥暴力和粗野的负面印象。

这场讨论中,评论员们从多个角度深入剖析了Suaalii被罚下场的影响。我们既肯定了裁判在维护比赛规则和球员安全方面的正确性,也承认这一判罚对比赛结果和观赏性造成了不可否认的负面影响。Suaalii的犯规直接改变了比赛的走向,更让观众错失了目睹明星球员Reece Walsh精彩表现的机会。

最终,这场争议的核心在于公平与观赏性之间的权衡。裁判的判罚无疑是维护了规则的公平性,但同时也牺牲了一部分比赛的观赏性,引发了关于规则适用性和判罚尺度等一系列更深层次的讨论。 这起事件提醒我们,在体育竞技中,规则的执行需要在公平性和观赏性之间寻求最佳平衡点。

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

0-4-6-0, 8-7-3, 8-7-3, if you'd like to join in. Scotty says, Mark, I can't agree with you. Those running the game have got to be upset with the ref. Makes an unfair mockery of the whole thing. The biggest brand advert they have for the game, and the ref takes the oxygen out. Wasn't an intentional piece of foul play. Rather a tackle gone wrong against a falling player. Very poor by the ref at this level. Ref needs to interpret with common sense. Maybe the AFL has it right, no send-offs. Well...

The NRL's trying to eliminate contact with the head. I don't know why the NRL would be upset with the referee. We all agree he had the kahunas to make the decision. It was the right decision, and for that, Ashley Klein should be applauded. And I'm sure the Match Review Committee, when they look closely at the tackle, they'll take a dim view of it as well, and I think you'll find Joey Suolii will be spending some time out of the game. Now, Queensland has won three of the past four series and will be aiming for three straight series wins tomorrow.

for the first time since 2015-17. They do have that 1-0 lead. Since the introduction of a three-game series in 1982, the team that's won game one has gone on to win the series on 31 occasions from 42 series, and 18 of Queensland's 24 series wins have come when winning...

game number one so those stats coming through courtesy of Andrew who's done plenty of homework leading into this game tonight let's bring in the former New South Wales captain Paul Gowland who's been a part of the nine coverage he's with us here in the commentary box on the continuous call team gal tough night for the Blues yeah it was tough night um I'm pretty deflated I've come in looking to give it a big man obviously come on lift a bit girl it hasn't been a great night it's hard look at

How can you win these days? When you're down to 12 men for 10 minutes, it's hard enough, let alone being down for 72 minutes. It's just too hard. They were very brave. They tried their backsides off. They come out of the second half very, very pumped up and look for a lot of it, they're probably on top, but at the end of the day, when you're down to 12 men, it's just too hard to maintain that energy. There's probably about a

six or seven minute period where the ball was in play constantly and that just like while that was hurting the queens and there's also when you're down to 12 man just makes it too hard for the blues and the back end of the game the queens has got a couple of tries to really kick ahead and yeah look that's life we've got to move on and have to get the job done game two yeah fair enough let's go back to the open line 131873 the number gary's at cranebrook wants to have his say about the suoliti incident g'day gary

Yeah, g'day, fellas. Look, I'm disappointed like all the other people, but the ref, like, I'm a Penrith supporter. The Penrith supporters hate that ref. I'll tell you what, that bloke had some kahunas doing what he did. Like, it had to go, he had to go. As I was just saying to the bloke, like, what you guys haven't said about is that you've got new people watching the game,

And if they see that, they'll say, these blokes are just all thugs. Like, at least they see... Now, Soali's not a bad kid, you know? Like, but...

I know you can talk all about that, but once you hit the head, and with that intensity, he's got to go. As Ray said, the more you look at it, the worse it gets. Exactly, Gary. And that's the thing, Gary. We've seen replay after replay after replay of the contact. We're all on the same page that it had to be a send-off. Did it...

I don't want to say ruin the game, but did it have a huge effect on the game? Well, yes, it did. It ruined the game. It did. Look, it ruined the game. Look, I'm as blue as they come, as you know, and I come here, the first thing Bramham said was that a send-off wanted me to say no, and look, it was. I can't. Contact direct with the head these days is a send-off. It was very, very forceful. He was, I grant it, he was slipping. Suhal, he did drop his body level, but any contact with the head these days is generally... It was forceful. I'm not denying that. I'm

You know how I ruined the game? It did ruin the game. Two ways, two ways.

One, the bloke got sent off, and two, we didn't get to see Reece Walsh, who's the superstar of the game. And that's why it did ruin the game. I agree, but it was the right decision. He had to do it. And, Gal, if Reece Walsh is on the field and we're down to 12 and the Blues, I don't think we're talking about it being 38-10. Probably not, but you know what? We wouldn't have been down to 12 if he stayed on. Look, I think it ruined the game, but it was a send-off. I'm not trying to discredit that at all or take it away. I thought he made the right decision. Yep. All right. Thank you, Gary, for your call. We'll take another break. Be back with more.

We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!

Export Podcast Subscriptions