We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Wisdom in the Face of Censorship | Sharon McMahon and Ryan Holiday

Wisdom in the Face of Censorship | Sharon McMahon and Ryan Holiday

2025/5/11
logo of podcast The Daily Stoic

The Daily Stoic

AI Deep Dive Transcript
People
R
Ryan Holiday
S
Sharon McMahon
Topics
Ryan Holiday: 我在海军学院的演讲被取消,原因是我计划讨论该学院从图书馆中移除书籍的行为。我认为,人们应该能够接触各种思想,审查和移除书籍是错误的。海军学院移除约400本被认为'过于觉醒'或支持多样性、公平与包容政策的书籍,这与智慧的理念相悖。我不能对此保持沉默。作为一名公民,我有责任发表我的看法,即使这可能会招致批评。接触不同观点并不会削弱我们,相反,它能让我们更好地理解世界。詹姆斯·斯托克代尔的故事就是一个很好的例子,他阅读马克思主义理论是为了更好地理解共产主义对美国的威胁。我坚持发表我的演讲内容是因为我认为这是我的责任,也是为了确保信息不会被压制。在海军学院的经历让我意识到,我们每个人都有责任在力所能及的范围内捍卫言论自由。 Sharon McMahon: 海军学院移除的书籍主要与美国种族问题有关,这种行为表明,即使是最优秀、最爱国的学生也无法接触到某些想法,这非常令人担忧。对政府行为的批评不应该被压制,海军学院压制批评的行为是危险的。压制思想自由探究是反美的,这与美国宪法的精神背道而驰。学习历史应该包括学习错误和缺点,这样我们才能避免重复过去的错误。如果历史不会让你感到不舒服,那么你实际上并没有真正阅读历史。人们能够承受真相,掩盖真相反而会造成更大的伤害。学习历史应该让我们与历史上的好人产生共鸣,并从他们的经验中学习,而不是被历史的黑暗面所压垮。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to The Daily Stoic early and ad-free right now. Just join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. I don't know anyone whose inbox isn't a huge mess, who managing email isn't a day-to-day struggle. I'm looking at my email right now. How many unread emails do I have? I've got here 298 in my main email, and I've got

147,000 in my other email. That is insane. And that's where today's sponsor comes in. Notion Mail is the inbox that thinks like you, automated, personalized, and flexible to finally work the way you work. And with AI that learns what matters to you, it can organize your inbox, label messages, draft replies, and even schedule meetings. No manual sorting required.

Plus, if you're a Notion user already, which we are here at Daily Stoic, Notion Mail integrates into your account and uses your Notion docs for context as well. It's just a great service. You can get Notion Mail for free right now at notion.com slash TDS. And you should try the inbox that thinks like you. That's all lowercase letters. Notion.com slash TDS to get Notion Mail for free right now. And when you use our link, you're supporting the show. That's notion.com slash TDS.

Welcome to the weekend edition of the Daily Stoic Podcast. On Sundays, we take a deeper dive into these ancient topics with excerpts from the Stoic texts, audiobooks that we like here or recommend here at Daily Stoic, and other long-form wisdom that you can chew on on this relaxing weekend. We hope this helps shape your understanding of this philosophy, and most importantly, that you're able to apply it to your actual life.

Thank you for listening. Hey, it's Ryan. Welcome to another episode of the Daily Stoic Podcast. So I've lived out here a long time and been coming into this town of Bastrop for a long time. And I passed this thing on the way in. It's a church. And there's like a big old white church.

sort of farmhouse-y looking building. It kind of looked like a schoolhouse. And it turns out that's what it was. I'd never stopped. I saw it had a historical marker. And then I was reading Sharon McMahon's book, The Small and Mighty. And she talked about these things called Rosenwald schools. Basically, the founder of Sears gave away most of his money and he gave them away to people like Booker T. Washington and

And this is right after the American Civil War, as they were trying to educate this whole generation, this whole race of people who'd been kept unfairly in bondage. They were trying to teach them. And these things called Rosenwald schools popped up all over the country, but particularly in the South, funded by him. They were schoolhouses. And it turns out there's one like right near me. And I passed by this so many times and I didn't ever stop to look at it. I never went in it.

And I didn't really even know what it was. And that's my favorite thing about reading is when I'm reading a book and then I'm somewhere, I'm traveling. I love interacting with history that I've been learning about. So we finally stopped. I posted this on Instagram to the bane of my wife's existence. We stopped. She took a picture of it. And...

I was like, oh, I was just reading about this. Right. And actually, Sharon is one of my favorite people. You might have seen her on Instagram. She's Sharon Says So. She's basically like America's government teacher. She was for many years a high school government teacher. Now she runs this nonpartisan fact based Instagram account called Sharon Says So that's teaching what we desperately need right now in this country, which is basic civics.

And Sharon was on the podcast several months ago. I loved her book. As I said, when I interviewed her, she was one of the few guests that my in-laws, even though we've had some incredibly famous people in and out of the studio over the last couple of years, that my in-laws were like, we heard Sharon's coming. Can we meet her? And they went and actually saw her talk. She gave a speech at the Paramount Theater in Austin. Anyways.

All of this led up to the thing you've probably heard about now, which is when my talk got censored at the Naval Academy and in a brand new listener times op-ed about it. Anyways, Sharon reached out and asked me if I would come on her podcast. Actually, we did it as an Instagram live where we would talk about like the importance of access to information, which the Rosenwald schools were all about, the importance of free speech, the importance of the free exchange of ideas.

And how these basic facts are enshrined in our government. But also what I so loved about her book is how each of us plays a small but essential role in reinforcing these norms, in showing that we actually believe in these norms, in having to fight for these norms. So we had this great 30 minute quick conversation about this.

this very idea and how it pertains to Stoic philosophy and how it pertains to being an informed citizen these days. I asked her if I could run it here. So that's what we are running. You can check out Sharon's podcast. Here's where it gets interesting. You can follow her on Instagram at Sharon Says So. And you can check out her sub stack, The Preamble, and definitely check out her book, The Small and Mighty, which I have raved about. I rave about it in the conversation. I've told so many people about it and it's inspired me. And as I said, it just widened my horizons about where I live.

I will give that to you now. I hope you enjoy. Thanks for squeezing me into your busy schedule. No, it sounds like you were busier than me today. I am really excited to chat. And one of the things that I wanted to talk to you about is about your recent scheduled appearance at the U.S. Naval Academy. First of all, for...

Just to set the stage a little bit, if you guys are not familiar with Ryan Holiday, you really should follow him. He has written so many incredible books about Stoic philosophy, and he was going to be speaking to students at the Naval Academy about the concept of wisdom, right? Yeah.

OK, tell me more about what the speech that you were supposed to be giving was about. The last four years, I've been doing a series of lectures on the cardinal virtues. So I did courage, then I did discipline, then I did justice. And then on Monday, last Monday, it was supposed to be wisdom.

And I own a bookstore here in Texas. You were nice enough to come out when you were doing your talk at the Paramount. You might remember, but on the window of the bookstore is a line from Rage Against the Machine, the rock band. It says, they don't got to burn the books. They just remove them.

Favorite songs, favorite song lyrics. And we put that up when they started removing books from the library here at the high school in the little town that we live. So I've always believed that generally people should have access to ideas and that when we're in the business of censoring and removing stuff, we're almost certainly screwing up.

And so I was supposed to give this talk at the Naval Academy. And about a week before I talked, I read in the New York Times that they'd removed something like 400 books from the university library that were deemed to be too woke or supporting various DEI policies.

Now, 400 sounds like a lot. Also, it doesn't sound like a lot when you realize there's something like a half a million books in this library. So the idea that any one of these books is somehow, you know, a statement of policy preference is ridiculous. This is a library for warrior scholars and as well as the many brilliant professors and teachers that are there. So.

I felt like I couldn't give a talk on the subject of wisdom, the cardinal virtue that I was speaking about, and not address this very timeless and unfortunately very...

prevalent tendency to get rid of books that we disagree with, right? And so I was gonna talk about that briefly. I wasn't gonna call anyone out or humiliate anyone, but I was gonna say, "Hey, we shouldn't be doing this. Not only shouldn't we be doing this, it's the opposite of what we should do." And I was gonna tell the story of the great James Stockdale, a graduate of the Naval Academy who was later sent to Stanford to get a master's degree.

And you can read these letters he sent home while he's studying there about his excitement to take this class on Marxist theory. And not because he's a Marxist, but because he thinks that communism, which it was then, was the primary geopolitical threat to the United States. And he wants to be familiar with it. He's doing what Seneca, the Stoic philosopher, calls reading like a spy in the enemy's camp. And my point was...

If one of the revered heroes of the Naval Academy can sit down and read Lenin and Marx in the midst of the Cold War, you're telling me that today's midshipmen can't read Maya Angelou or Stacey Abrams memoir or this book about the history of the Ku Klux Klan?

in the Naval Academy Library. I mean, it was absurd on its face. So that's what I was going to talk about. And what happened, to make a long story short, is they called me about an hour before my talk was supposed to go up and said, hey, you've got to remove these slides. We don't want to wade into the middle of a political fight. And I said, look, I understand that. And if you want to talk about some ground rules by which you don't want to get anyone specifically called out, I'm all about it. But

But I can't come here and give a talk about courage and a talk about doing the right thing. I can't put a sign on the window of my bookstore that says removing books is the same as burning them. And then just do it just because you don't want anyone to have their feelings hurt. And so, as you can imagine, that led to the talk, the offer to give the talk being quickly rescinded. And I flew home. Here we are. Yeah.

Yeah, like, didn't it happen, like, just very shortly before? Like, you weren't there ready to go on stage in short order. I was ironing my shirt, to tell you a little behind the scenes. I was about to walk over to go give the talk. And what had happened is I'd sent the slide, like, maybe this is naive, so I'll own that. But I sent my slides over the night before, as one does. You give a lot of talks.

You don't send your slides over the night before for approval. You send your slides over so the tech person can load them up. And so that's what happened. I'd sent the slides over and, you know, they made their way up the chain of command. And some people were very alarmed. And they made up, ironically, a very political decision, right, to suppress criticism from a private citizen of a policy that

that, by the way, they were following. I think I understand that if you're an officer in the armed forces and the commander in chief or coming down the chain of command gives you an order, unless that order is in itself illegal, your job is to follow that. So I get their position. But my position as a private citizen, as a voter...

is that this is insane. And I'm not not going to say that just because I've been invited to speak somewhere. In fact, I feel like maybe you can tell me if you disagree, but I feel like my obligation is to, as a private citizen, is thus greater to say things that I don't think a uniformed military officer is in a position to say and probably isn't appropriate for them to say.

Yeah, I totally agree with what you're saying. And the idea that criticism of a governmental action is being suppressed, like you're not allowed to come here and criticize us.

That is the opposite of freedom. Yes. That is the opposite of freedom of you can't criticize the government. That is a slippery slope, my friends. A slippery slope is exactly what happened because I imagine that the superintendent of the Naval Academy, who I did not talk to, so I wouldn't imply otherwise, no one gets in the

position where they're running a university, especially an elite university like the Naval Academy, because they like removing books from a library, right? She did not want to do this. She would not have asked to do this. It was the order that she got. But in following that order and not pushing back against it publicly or privately, next, her and the administration there is in the

the even stickier position of having to suppress criticism of the decision because it's a bad look, like the optics of it are inherently bad. And so that that's that tricky situation where where I think sometimes people think, oh, hey, I'm going to go along with this. So in the future, I'll be in a better position to do the right thing.

What actually happens, and I say this from experience, having done the wrong thing, when you don't speak up, when you don't do what you know is right, when you go along with a policy that is problematic, what actually happens is you find yourself having to double and triple and quadruple down on that thing. And you get much further from where you want to be. And then kind of once you're in it, it's hard to get out of it.

I love what you had to say, too, about James Stockdale and this concept of reading like a spy in the enemy's camp. There seems to be this idea that if we are exposed to an idea that we disagree with, that that somehow diminishes us, that that somehow is so inherently harmful that we must have sort of big brother government to protect us from said, you know, air quotes, hostility.

And I'd love to hear you talk a little bit more for somebody who's not familiar with the James Stockdale story or about this concept of, you know, reading like a spy in an enemy's camp. I want to hear you talk a little bit more about who he was and why that concept is important.

And look, I think it's worth pointing out, because apparently it doesn't go without saying, Maya Angelou is not the enemy. You know, these books that were removed, you can disagree with some of the arguments. And I haven't read all 500 books. I'm defending their right to exist.

not their ideas in them. And I'm certainly defending people's right to read them and agree with them or disagree with them, right? But when Seneca is saying we read like a spy in the enemy's camp, he's not just paying lip service to this idea. I think it's worth pointing out. If anyone here has read Seneca's letters, which is one of the most remarkable philosophical texts you'll ever lay hands on, you'll notice

that he, the Stoic philosopher, quotes more than any other philosopher Epicurus, the head of the rival Epicurean school. And it's remarkable that he does this because we're so used to taking only some

- Reporting arguments for what we believe, right? I think everyone knows what a straw man is. The opposite of a straw man is what they call a steel man. That means engaging in good faith with your opponent's arguments. And by the way, stipulating and recognizing when they get it right.

Seneca has another great line. He says, "I'll quote a bad author if the line is good." Right? And I think you found this, you know, your book does a good job of this too. A lot of the figures that you talked about were not perfect. They were not all good. They believed some great things and some bad things.

And an adult is able to celebrate the good and acknowledge and discuss the bad. And so Stockdale, to go to what we're talking about, when he gets this graduate's degree in the humanities, he studies Marx. He studies world history. There's no doubt this is the early 60s. He's getting all sorts of information that's critical of America, that's critical of America's mistakes.

And you know what he's doing? He's engaging with it as an adult. He's not a sensitive little snowflake. He has his prior beliefs, but he's willing to question them and have intellectual intercourse with people who believe differently. And my belief is these midshipmen are...

are the elite of the elite. They're the most talented, brightest young men and women in this country. And I will say my time giving these talks at the Naval Academy has been one of the honors of my life. And I would say one of the things that gives me the most hope for our country, because it's an incredibly diverse group from all different walks of life.

who have decided to, instead of going to Harvard or Yale or Stanford, they're going to a university that comes with an obligation of service. And anyways, my point is, these people are going to be the commanders of submarines and battleships and fighter jets.

They go on to run enormous organizations. You know, Admiral Stavridis, who is a graduate from the Naval Academy, a great author, he becomes the supreme allied commander of NATO. So these are leaders of leaders. The idea that they're too fragile to be exposed to some books about diversity, equity, and inclusion is, if we believe that, let's shut this whole thing down right now.

We are hiring over at Daily Stoic. And whenever we are hiring, the first place I go is LinkedIn Jobs. LinkedIn Jobs, it's super easy. They even have this new AI tool that will write your job description for you. You can put in, you know, the main stuff and it'll make it better for you. Your business is defined by the people that you have in it. And if you don't have good people, you're not going to do a good job.

And so when you need a partner that works as hard as you do, that hiring partner is LinkedIn Jobs.

When you clock out, LinkedIn clocks in and LinkedIn makes it easy to post your job for free, share it with your network and get qualified candidates that you can manage all in one place. Posting your job is easy with LinkedIn's new feature and that can help you write job descriptions and then promote your job in front of the right people. Promoted jobs get more than three times the qualified applicants. And with LinkedIn, you can feel confident you're getting the best

That's why 72% of businesses using LinkedIn say that LinkedIn helps them find high quality candidates. Find out why more than two and a half million small businesses are using LinkedIn for hiring today. Find your next great hire on LinkedIn. Post your job for free at linkedin.com slash do it. That's linkedin.com slash do it. Post your job for free. Terms and conditions apply.

Well, and also, please note, the only books that were banned, because I've been through the list of the books, they really have to do with race in America, right? We're not banning porn from the Naval Academy. We're not banning books about Nazis from the Naval Academy. We're not taking other...

other allegedly bad ideas, even if an administration thinks it's a bad idea. We're not taking other potentially harmful concepts and removing those from the library. It's specific to this one topic that somehow some of America's best and brightest, most civically minded people, because as you mentioned, these are incredibly elite students who then have

have to serve their country in the Navy afterwards, after they are done with their education. They don't just get to take the degree and leave. They're not just incredibly bright. They're also perhaps some of the most patriotic. They care the most about the country.

And for us to say, here are some ideas that are just so bad that we can't allow you to be exposed to them while also allowing them to be exposed to other bad ideas, that is very telling. It's very telling. And I think it says like so much. And it almost, by the way, it seems like they just did a control F search of the library catalog and looked for the word black.

I'm not even joking. That is what they did. They asked ChatGBT, what are some woke books we should remove from the Naval Academy Library? And then I think it gives you a sense of who the type of person and the type of education they're dealing with that's leading this is that they don't even have the familiarity with American history or American literature to go, hey, this is the list.

let's get rid of Maya Angelou from that list because it's going to look badly. We might be able to get people to roll over and accept that.

you know, the removal of some of these obscure, more leftist, you know, academic history books. But Maya Angelou is a treasure of American letters. You know, Oprah Winfrey is her number one fan. The idea that people aren't going to be upset, anyone would know that. And I think the reason they didn't know that is they have also not read Maya Angelou.

Right. And so there's a blind leading the blind here. Let's do it. I think. And you're right. These are people who are going on to be leaders. Right. They're going to be the next generation of leaders in America. We're not trying to indoctrinate them with anti-Americanism, but if they're going to help America become what America is capable of becoming.

I don't think it's unreasonable that we would give them the unvarnished truth about who America has been in the past. That's how we don't repeat mistakes like the Ku Klux Klan and the Holocaust. And, you know, I quote, I wrote a New York Times op-ed about this, and one of the people that I talked about, and he was going to be in the talk as well, this

None of this controversy is new. There was a big backlash during the Cold War about what books were in American embassies during the Red Scare. And right after he's elected, there's a press conference where a reporter is asking Eisenhower if he's going to remove the Communist Manifesto and other books from the libraries at American embassies.

And he says, absolutely not. He's like, if we're going to run a free country, we have to educate ourselves. And he says, one of the lessons that I took from World War Two is that we should have more of us should have read Hitler and more of us should have read Stalin and more of us should have read Marx because we would have understood where they were going.

Right. And so, again, Maya Angelou and these authors that were removed from the library are not the enemy, which makes this even more inexcusable. But the point is, if you're going to make America what it's capable of being,

You have to understand it for its flaws and deficiencies so you can accentuate the good and prevent the bad. I love that. I think that's so true, that in order to fully understand something, you have to understand it from all dimensions. This is not a situation where indoctrination is never being allowed to question what you have been told.

And if you're not allowed to say, is it really true that X, Y, and Z is what happened? If we're not allowed to say that, then that is the path to indoctrination. Free inquiry is the opposite of the path to indoctrination. So when somebody is characterizing the free inquiry of ideas, meaning I might read a book I disagree with to better understand the enemy, again, air quotes, to be a spy in the enemy's camp.

The suppression of free inquiry is inherently anti-American. That is not what the framers of the Constitution, the founders of this nation intended for the population as a whole and certainly not for the leaders of leaders. The suppression of free inquiry is a very dangerous thing.

No, you're absolutely right. And look, anytime an organization does something that it knows it's wrong, you often see this revealed in the sort of corporate or political doublespeak that comes out. And so when the Naval Academy was asked, and I told them, hey, you're canceling a planned –

an announced lecture. The idea that no one's going to find out about this is silly. So when they were asked, you know, we heard you cancel this lecture, what happened? They said, look, the Naval Academy is an apolitical institution and we were concerned that this thing would be political. And then they said, but we were really just canceling it for scheduling reasons, right? But I agree that the Naval Academy should be apolitical.

And that's why it's so alarming that politics is intervening to remove books from the library. One of the tricky things about the times we live in is that often the accusation is a kind of confession. And when they're saying, hey, we're trying not to be political and then removing books because they're politically disagreeable, that's an accusation masquerading as a confession. But I think.

It says something about where we are that's saying, hey, I don't think we should be removing books, any books from a university library that's effectively an Ivy League university for the armed services. I don't think we should be doing that. And then you're told you're being political. Like this isn't political to me. This is basic social contract, constitutional freedom. This is academic freedom.

freedom and independence at its core. That's what I'm objecting to. And I hope people who are listening that maybe aren't fans of DEI as it's sort of as a political boogeyman, like they disagree with some of the ideas from, you know, Kendi and these other thinkers.

Great. You're free to do that also. But when we are removing books, if each administration is coming in and removing the books they don't like, that gets to a dark place very quickly. And it's not what we're supposed to be doing. And it's not how you raise money.

you know, a generation of leaders and independent thinkers, which ultimately you want. I think people think the military is about top-down control. Actually, I interviewed General Dan Cain, who's now the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff on the Daily Stoke podcast several years ago.

And he said, people get the military wrong. He's like, I've probably given two direct orders in my entire career. He and most of the great military leaders will say that the crown jewel of American military power is the independent thinking of our officers and our non-commissioned officers. We have really smart people in our armed forces that make really great independent decisions and for the most part, don't make decisions

ethically horrendous decisions, you know, like your Malay massacres and things like that. We have people who think for themselves and they question illegal orders and they push back when things are dangerous or, you know, strategically unsound. That's what you want. Russia doesn't have that. That's why they have blundered in Ukraine over and over and over again.

The military is not a meat grinder that we feed people into. It is made up of elites of elites who are smart, who are creative, who think for themselves. You know, you said something that I really want to touch on, which is that if history doesn't make you uncomfortable, then you're not actually reading history.

And I mean, isn't that the truth? This idea that we're supposed to be fed, you know, only like the chocolate cake version of history is kind of a recipe for disaster. You it leads us to and I've spoken with many members of the military about this, too. I recently had the occasion to talk to Jim Mattis, who was secretary of defense under one of my heroes, Donald Trump in his first administration. And

And, you know, one of the things that they talk frequently about is that people actually can handle the truth. Yes.

They want to know the truth. And there's far more damage that happens when we lie to people with some sort of sanitized version of what we wish were real. And you talk about this, too, that when we're so overcome with what we hope to be true or what we wish to be real, that we're not seeing things differently.

as they really are. - No, I think that's totally right. The ability to deal with reality on reality's terms, I think is the mark of an adult. But I would also say like, look, when you study history, there's darkness to it and contradiction and embarrassment and shame, American history being no exception. But when I read American history and I read it extensively, I read from all different sources,

And when I see the darkness and the sadness, I don't go, oh, I'm a white person. I have blood guilt on me and I hate my country and I hate myself. No, I relate to the small and mighty characters that you profile in your books. Like when I tell my kids how history goes and I explain what

what the good people did and the bad people did, and how even there was bad people on the good side and good people on the bad side. What I'm doing is trying to get them to identify with the good people, the people who didn't always win, but were trying, you know? And like, when I read about American slavery, I don't identify with Thomas Jefferson. I identify with Frederick Douglass and I go, he's my guy, right? And I think when we talk about uncomfortable truths,

I think especially somewhere like the Naval Academy, they're not like my country, right or wrong. They're identifying with the good virtues in the person. And then they're able to see the vices or the flaws and go, hey, I don't want to make that same mistake. So I'm going to do things differently. That's why we study history. Okay.

And you can learn just as much by studying somebody's foibles and flaws and mistakes as you can from studying only the times they were embodying virtue. If you don't understand what went wrong when they didn't embody a virtue like wisdom or like courage, then you're robbing yourself of important lessons. Right.

That's totally right. And look, this is some of my criticism of the sort of more the very far left interpretation of history, even the sort of Howard Zinn version of history, where when you only catalog the horrors and the contradictions and the hypocrisies, you end up with this kind of nihilism, right? Like, look, Vietnam was a war started for no real reason and continued for 30 years for no real reason. It is a black mark on American history. But

But in that blackness, there is someone like James Stockdale who was heroic and virtuous and worth studying and learning from. So you don't just look at history and go, this is gross, this sucks, nothing matters.

What you do is you look for the good and you look for the bright spots. You look for the green sprouts. You look for the people who are trying to swim against the current. And you elevate those stories to provide a model for future generations to swim against the negative currents of their own time as well.

of time, but I want to hear from you. Why did you feel so strongly about continuing forward with your speech as was? Why did you feel like I need to record what I was going to say and I need to bring this to light and write it out of the New York Times? Why are you here today? Like, why is this such an important issue for you?

Well, thank you for asking that. Thanks for having me. I think it's two things. So people have been so nice. Well, not everyone, but most people have been so nice in their reaction to it. And they they've said some some, I think, very generous things about me and this little standard that I took.

I have not always done this in my life, right? Like in my 20s, I worked for some controversial people. I was put in ethically fraught situation. I didn't always make the right choice, but I feel like I learned from that. And I feel like my study of history, we sort of pick our heroes. Doing this talk about Stockdale, this guy, if he had done the expedient thing, if he had gone along with what was being asked of him,

any point in his time as a POW, he would have gone home. He would have been spared torture. And he said, no, I'm going to stand on principle here. And it felt morally bankrupt and contradictory for me to hold him up as an example and then immediately contradict that example, right? So I felt that, but it's been a process for me. Like, I understand I'm in a position to take a stand in a way that a civil servant or a

career military officers, perhaps not. So I thought about that too. But at the core of stoicism is this idea that we control some things and we don't control other things. We've got to focus on what we control. And

And as it was happening, I go, look, I don't control that they're forcing me to make this choice, but I do control what choice I make. And then I don't control whether they allow me to speak or not, but I do control whether the message disappears or not. And so I said, look, I have to take my lumps here. You know, I have to go. I have to slink home. I have to leave. I can't do the thing I wanted to do, but I can go home and I can record.

record this talk. I can write it. I can use what I'm good at, which is writing. I can write up what I was going to say and submit it to the New York Times. I can do that. And I can make sure that I don't go quietly about it. And I think

We're in, I think, a very precarious moment in American history here. Most of us are not presidents. Most of us are not senators. Most of us do not hold serious political power. But we do have influence over our choices and our little sphere. And you think about the president of Columbia versus the president of Harvard. One rolls over and...

you know, agrees to the policies and the other takes a fight. We each have the ability to say, hey, here's the line and you're not going to get me to cross it. And I think if everyone were to do that or if we were all as a society to get better at doing that, whether we're talking about resigning on principle, pushing back, you know, being a whistleblower, et cetera, I think

A lot of the extreme forces on all ends of our political spectrum would get pushed back into normal bounds very quickly. The problem is everyone is going along with it because they don't want to be criticized. They don't want to pay anything for it. They don't want attention. You know, they don't want to they just don't want to be in the middle of it. And

I think the obligation to us all is to be in the middle of it in the areas that it's possible for us to be in the middle of it. Yeah, what would 100-year-old Ryan, in retrospect, looking back at his life, where would he wish he might have made different choices? And not speaking up for what is right is often a regret that people have.

-Every time in my life, I have made a decision for reasons, you know? Like, I had my reasons at the time. Those reasons have not aged well. -Ryan, we could keep talking, but I'm gonna let you go for today. -I will. -I'm so glad we were able to make time to do this. Thank you for your courage and your wisdom. -No, my pleasure. And thank you for everything that you do. I'm a huge fan, and we sell so many of your books at our bookstore because it's exactly the thing people need to be reading right now. It's not that they were small and mighty.

It's that you can be that, right? That's what we have to take from history, that we all have the ability to make a little bit of a difference and that the world is better when people do that. So thank you for writing it. Thank you. Thanks, Ryan. Thanks so much for listening. If you could rate this podcast and leave a review on iTunes, that would mean so much to us and it would really help the show. We appreciate it. I'll see you next episode.

If you like The Daily Stoic and thanks for listening, you can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts. Prime members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. And before you go, would you tell us about yourself by filling out a short survey on wondery.com slash survey.

You know those creepy stories that give you goosebumps? The ones that make you really question what's real? Well, what if I told you that some of the strangest, darkest, and most mysterious stories are not found in haunted houses or abandoned forests, but instead in hospital rooms and doctor's offices? Hi, I'm Mr. Ballin, the host of Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries. And each week on my podcast, you can expect to hear stories about bizarre illnesses no one can explain, miraculous recoveries that shouldn't have happened,

and cases so baffling they stumped even the best doctors. So if you crave totally true and thoroughly twisted horror stories and mysteries, Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries should be your new go-to weekly show. Listen to Mr. Ballin's Medical Mysteries on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.