Sara Bareilles prefers theatre because it feels less competitive and more collaborative. She describes the music industry as highly competitive, which doesn't align with her personality. In contrast, theatre fosters a sense of gratitude and joy among participants, with everyone being happy to be part of a production, regardless of how long it lasts.
Sara Bareilles' early experiences with co-writers were discouraging, as she felt her presence didn't matter in the songwriting process. She describes songwriting as a sacred and intimate act, akin to her relationship with God. This led her to reject co-writing sessions and insist on writing solo, which ultimately helped her develop her unique voice and style.
Sara Bareilles wrote 'She Used to Be Mine' as a way to capture the complexity of the main character, Jenna, in Waitress. The song reflects Jenna's messy, kind, and lonely nature, portraying her as a mix of emotions 'baked in a beautiful pie.' Bareilles aimed to authentically express the character's inner struggles and transformation.
Sara Bareilles believes that while art itself is not vulnerable, artists are. She criticizes the rapid rise to fame many young artists experience today, which can be overwhelming and unsustainable. Bareilles emphasizes the importance of creating art for the right reasons, such as self-expression and connection, rather than for commercial success or fame.
Collaboration is central to Sara Bareilles' creative process in theatre. She values the right kind of collaboration, where the collective effort results in something greater than the sum of its parts. Working on projects like Waitress allowed her to engage in meaningful conversations about motivation and storytelling, which she finds deeply rewarding.
Sara Bareilles embraces aging naturally and sees it as a privilege. She feels a responsibility to show up authentically, even if it means challenging societal expectations about appearance. Bareilles aims to be a role model for younger artists by being true to herself and not hiding the natural process of aging.
Sara Bareilles broke out as a pop-music star in the late two-thousands. But she’s gone on to have a very different kind of career, writing music for Broadway and eventually performing as an actor on stage and on television. At the New Yorker Festival, in 2024, she played her early hit “Gravity,” and spoke with staff writer Rachel Syme) about the pressures of fame, aging, and why she prefers working in theatre. “There’s so much competition in the music industry. I’m not a competitive person; I don’t understand it. It’s not that theatre isn’t competitive, but there’s this feeling—everybody’s so happy to be there. Like, ‘We got a show, guys, and we don’t know how long it’s going to last!’ ”