We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode What's the Best Way for Ethereum to Grow? Justin Drake and Martin Köppelmann Debate - Ep. 740

What's the Best Way for Ethereum to Grow? Justin Drake and Martin Köppelmann Debate - Ep. 740

2024/11/26
logo of podcast Unchained

Unchained

AI Deep Dive AI Chapters Transcript
People
J
Justin Drake
M
Martin Köppelmann
Topics
Justin Drake:以太坊L1专注于构建价值互联网的坚实基础,追求安全性与稳健性,与比特币竞争;L2则专注于快速增长和用户获取,与Solana等竞争。两者都需要加速发展。通过预确认机制和Rollup,以太坊可以提供比Solana更好的用户体验,并实现可持续的吞吐量扩展。L1路线图过于雄心勃勃,建议批量升级以加快进度,并在未来几年内进入维护模式。许多Rollup目前是孤立的,但乐观地认为,中期将形成集群,通过共享基础设施来增强网络效应,最终实现以太坊范围内的共享基础设施。Beam Chain旨在通过对共识层进行全新设计,解决长期问题,并利用ZK技术改进共识层。Solana的竞争主要针对以太坊的L2,而不是L1;以太坊应该同时关注短期与长期目标。原生Rollup比执行分片更强大,可以拥有不同的商业模式,但具有相同的安全性。最终,大部分Gas消耗将来自Blob,这将带来大量的销毁,从而实现通缩。 Martin Köppelmann:以太坊面临的最大问题是互操作性降低,各个Rollup实际上是独立的链,缺乏强大的网络效应,导致代币价格和利率在不同Rollup之间存在差异。以太坊应该直接为自身创建经济区域或集群,持续提升L1性能,并推动基于以太坊的Rollup发展,以吸引开发者和流动性。当前Rollup的异构性导致难以解决互操作性问题,需要构建具有相同风险特征的Rollup,并改进跨Rollup通信标准。长期目标是实现同步组合性,但可以从同步读取开始。以太坊目前主要提供低价值的数据可用性服务,应该专注于提供高价值的执行服务,并提升L1容量以吸引开发者和流动性。原生Rollup,即由以太坊本身开发和维护的标准化Rollup,是解决这个问题的关键。

Deep Dive

Shownotes Transcript

Ethereum has been left behind in this bull market. As rivals like Solana gain ground in metrics such as speed, cost, and developer mindshare, questions are being raised about whether Ethereum’s reliance on Layer 2 solutions is the right path forward—or if it needs a more fundamental redesign.

In this episode, Martin Köppelmann, co-founder of Gnosis, and Justin Drake, researcher at the Ethereum Foundation, discuss the trade-offs of native and based rollups, execution capacity, and Ethereum’s ability to maintain its dominance. They debate how Ethereum should address fragmentation across rollups, whether ETH has strayed from its ultrasound money narrative, and whether its deliberate pace of innovation could make it vulnerable in an increasingly competitive landscape.

Whose ideas will lead Ethereum out of this dark forest? 

Show highlights:

  • 03:10 Why Justin is so optimistic about pre confirmations and Ethereum scaling its throughput

  • 06:15 Whether Ethereum could reach “maintenance mode” within 5 years

  • 08:20 Whether Ethereum can solve the problem of fragmentation

  • 20:21 The difference between based rollups and native rollups

  • 25:29 Why Martin believes that Ethereum is not building for developers

  • 34:21 What real-time proving is and why it is relevant

  • 37:46 How programmable native rollups could have different business models from Ethereum but the same security

  • 44:51 Why most assets on L2s might not actually be secured by Ethereum

  • 50:24 Whether Ethereum’s consensus layer might see a “clean slate” redesign with the Beam Chain

  • 58:59 Whether Ethereum’s slow pace of change could leave it vulnerable to competition

  • 01:06:55 How Ethereum's shift to rollups and blob data has reshaped its ultrasound money narrative by transforming the primary sources of fee burn

Visit our website for breaking news, analysis, op-eds, articles to learn about crypto, and much more: unchainedcrypto.com

Thank you to our sponsors!

Guests:

- Martin Köppelmann), Co-founder and CEO of Gnosis

  • Previous appearances on Unchained:

Are Layer 2s Failing Ethereum? A New Proposal Advocates for Native L2s)

Given the Sanctions on Tornado Cash, Is Ethereum Censorship Resistant?)

- Justin Drake), Researcher at the Ethereum Foundation

Previous appearances on Unchained:

Why MEV Will Always Be Controversial)

Did the Merge Make Ethereum ‘the Most Secure Blockchain in the World’?)

Can Bitcoin Be Secured Only by Transaction Fees? Two Researchers Sound Off)

Is ETH on Its Way to Becoming Ultra-Sound Money? Yes, Says Justin Drake)

Links

  • Previous coverage of Unchained on Ethereum layer 2s:

ETH Is Down Bad, While Layer 2s Are Ripping. Are L2s Parasitic to Ethereum?)

Are L2s ‘Parasitic’? Analysis Shows Ethereum Only Gets a Tiny Percentage of Fees)

Are Solana’s ‘Network Extensions’ Just Like Ethereum’s Layer 2s But by a Different Name?)

Ethereum Has Had a Banner Year in Most Areas. Except Price.)

Should Ethereum Layer 2s Urgently Decentralize Their Sequencers?)

Ethereum Scaling With L2s Has Damaged Its Tokenomics. Is It Possible to Fix It)

Beam Chain:

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices)