What Praising The UnitedHealthcare Shooter Says About America
What A Day
Deep Dive
Why did the murder of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson spark widespread online support for the alleged shooter?
The murder of Brian Thompson sparked widespread online support for the alleged shooter, Luigi Mangione, because many people sympathized with his perceived stand against the injustices of the American healthcare system. Comments and posts highlighted frustrations with insurance companies, with some expressing that those who have suffered due to denied claims or financial devastation from medical bills could understand the shooter's actions. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez also noted that while violence is not justified, the behavior of some healthcare companies can feel like acts of violence to patients.
What does the acquittal of Daniel Penny reveal about public perceptions of vigilantism?
The acquittal of Daniel Penny, who killed Jordan Neely using a chokehold on a New York City subway, revealed a divided public perception of vigilantism. While some condemned Penny as a murderer, others, particularly in conservative circles, praised him as a hero. The Wall Street Journal called the verdict hopeful, and an Arizona Republican congressman even proposed awarding Penny the Congressional Gold Medal for bravery. This case, along with the support for Luigi Mangione, highlights how different political sides in America can rally behind their own vigilantes.
How does the history of political violence in the 1970s compare to current events in the United States?
The history of political violence in the 1970s, marked by over 2,500 bombings in an 18-month period, reflects a time of significant instability and extremism in the U.S. Similarly, current events show a rise in political violence, with acts like the UnitedHealthcare shooting and the Daniel Penny case gaining public support. Author Peter Turchin's model suggests that elite overproduction and economic instability can lead to such violence, indicating that the U.S. may be entering a period where political violence becomes normalized, much like the 1970s.
What are the potential consequences of normalizing political violence in the United States?
Normalizing political violence in the United States could lead to increased instability and a rise in extremist actions. Historical examples, such as the years of lead in Italy and the 1970s in America, show that periods of political violence often result from economic instability and elite overproduction. If violence becomes an accepted means of addressing grievances, it could lead to a cycle of retaliation and further polarization, undermining democratic processes and societal cohesion.
How is California preparing to resist potential actions by a second Trump administration?
California is preparing to resist potential actions by a second Trump administration by building legal defenses and strategies to protect progressive policies. Attorney General Rob Bonta mentioned that the state has been preparing for months, if not years, with briefs on nearly every issue signaled by the Trump administration. California plans to hold Trump accountable if he breaks the law, particularly in areas like environmental protections, gun safety laws, reproductive freedom, and immigrant rights. The state is also ready to challenge any unlawful withholding of federal funds or attempts to condition funding on policy changes.
Shownotes Transcript