Talking Dateline: Return to the Lake
26:50 Share

Brought to you by the Capital One Venture X-Card. If you love to travel, the Capital One Venture X-Card is perfect for you. Earn unlimited double miles on your purchases and turn them into extraordinary travel. Enjoy premium benefits at a collection of luxury hotels when you book through Capital One Travel and get access to over 1,000 airport lounges worldwide. Capital One, what's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com for details.

If you're a facilities manager at a university, you know students rely on the cafeteria for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and the occasional late night snack. So when a dishwasher breaks down and dirty plates pile up, the mess hall can turn messy in the blink of an eye. Enter Grainger. With over a million industrial grade products and fast delivery, the product you need now is never far away. So you can turn that dishwasher back into a lean, clean washing machine. Call, click Grainger.com or just stop by.

Ranger, for the ones who get it done. Hi, everybody. It's Josh Mankiewicz, and we're talking Dateline today with Craig Melvin. Hi, Craig. Josh, how are you, Mank? Good, and congratulations on that new non-Dateline job that you have. I see you trying to fit in around your Dateline responsibilities. Well, you know, my primary obligation remains...

To Dateline. This Dateline thing. Forever. This is correct. So this episode is called Return to the Lake, and it is about a horrifying case that everybody of a certain age, that being me, will remember. It's from 1994. It's the story of Susan Smith, who murdered her two young children.

Now, for this episode, Craig spoke with her ex-husband, David, in a very rare, very revealing interview about how this case, this loss, how it impacted him and how he is fighting to keep the woman that he once loved behind bars. Now, if you've not listened to this episode yet, it is the episode right below this one on the list of podcasts that you just chose from. So you can go there and you can listen to it and come back here, or you can go to Peacock and stream it.

Now, when you come back, Craig and I will talk about the episode. Craig also has an extra clip that he wants to play for us from the chief of SLED, the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, Mark Keel. And then later, we're going to be joined by a special guest. And that is Dateline producer Carol Gable, who exchanged letters with Susan Smith for 20 years.

And she's going to talk about that and also answer some of your questions about the broadcast from social media. So stick around for that. And now let's talk Dateline. You were a small child when this happened. I know that. It's not a small child. No, you were like, you saw this, I'm thinking, through the bars of your crib. No, I was 15. I was 15. Okay. All right. Because I was, I think, 65 then. Shut up. Shut up.

I remember this story. I was actually not only was I a TV reporter at this stage, I was not working. I had not come to Dateline yet, and I was working for a show that had stopped producing episodes, and we were all just kind of getting paid, waiting for them to figure out what they were going to do next, which turned out to be nothing. So I had a lot of time to watch coverage of this, and I did. I remember watching a lot of it. Well, it was all-consuming, man. It was all-consuming work.

In Columbia, South Carolina, where I'm from, WIS Television was the big station there still is.

and it was one of those stories for two weeks. Multiple stories, every newscast. And this little town, Union, South Carolina, where it happened, it was about an hour from where I grew up. Things like this didn't happen to Union. I mean, Union was like Mayberry. Everyone knew everybody. Half the town's related to the other half. I mean, that's just kind of—there's just small town South Carolina.

You know, I grew up a good Baptist boy. Even I remember on church on Sunday, you know, we were praying for these boys. We were praying for their safe return. Like it was just that there were ribbons that had gone up. I can't remember the color, but I remember they had these ribbons all over cities and towns just remembering Michael and Alex. So yeah, it was top of mind for a long time.

And I'm presuming that even when the TV wasn't on, everybody was talking about it. It's all anybody could talk about. You know, the detail of her story, I remembered this when I saw it in your broadcast. The guy jumps in the car, supposedly, and says, you know, he's got a gun. He's like, just drive. And she said, and the boys were crying.

And I remember thinking like, man, they must have been terrified. Like they could tell something was wrong. They knew how frightened she was. That was the moment where I thought, oh my God, how awful that must be. And of course, all made up. None of that happened. You got the benefit of the doubt back then, certainly more often than not. You had this young white woman, and I hate even saying this now 30 years later,

She didn't look like someone who might kill their children. She just didn't look the part. And so from jump, she immediately starts to garner justifiable sympathy, you know? And so it triggers this manhunt, this...

And you've got... Well, I mean, she sold this really well. It wasn't like she was refusing to talk to anybody or wouldn't speak afterwards. Correct. She absolutely played her part. And that obviously helped tremendously. And then when they put out the pictures first and then the video of these little boys, it was really sort of the perfect storm.

She would see the searches. She would see the helicopters in the air, the bloodhounds on the ground, all of these investigators, these volunteers, right?

And she still kept it up. And it wasn't just the telling of the lie. The telling of the lie, the initial lie. And then there were other lies, obviously, because when you lie once, you got to keep lying to cover up the lie. She did it for nine days. A good friend of mine is from Union. And we've talked about it many times since then. People didn't carjack in Union back in the 90s.

First of all, there were only two intersections and you only had like, you know, 30 cars. So much of it didn't make sense. And granted, we're looking at it now through the lens of today. And we talked to two of the journalists who covered the story closely at the time. And they both brought it up separately. I asked them about regrets. And they did say, looking back on it, they wish now that there had been more journalists asking tougher questions about cars.

the, the story itself and not immediately giving, giving her a pass. Yeah. I mean, I don't want to say it was a simpler or more innocent time, but it may have been a less suspicious time because without, without social media and the internet, the impulse was to believe her story. She's telling the truth. Yep. And people did believe it. And then clearly, I mean, uh,

at some point law enforcement starts doing what I think was a pretty good job, like figuring out like her story, but the stoplight couldn't have been true. That's a,

That's pretty good police work in a time when there weren't cameras at every intersection. That's one of my favorite parts of the episode is the police start working together and they give her the polygraph. We know how it turns out. And then you've got Pete Logan, who, by the way, fun fact, worked on the Kennedy assassination back in the day.

But Pete Logan is this renowned polygraph expert. They bring him in and he decides to work with Sheriff Wells to extract this confession. And it works. It works beautifully. It really is. Your point, though, man, you're right. I mean, this this was before.

We lived in a time of ubiquitous surveillance. There's no social media, no phone record. There's no cell phone towers that we can check. Can't track her. Nothing. No, no. Old school. Right. I mean, today that story wouldn't stand up because of technology. Back then?

You know, you told it and you sold it. And she did. You guys got some conversations, some audio from those conversations. Now, those have not been played before. And they're chilling, I thought. Hey, how you doing? You doing okay? Well, that's good. I'm concerned about you and just wonder how you were doing. I appreciate you telling that. Thanks a lot. Yeah, I would agree with you. And it was interesting to me just hearing that.

Just hearing her voice on those tapes. Yeah. So, you know, Susan Smith initially said, I mean, after she eventually told the truth, she first said that she sort of tried to drown herself along with her sons. Anybody believe that? Funny you should bring that up. I put that question to Tommy Pope, who was the chief prosecutor in the case at the time. And Tommy said that of

Of all the lies she told, that was one that stood out the most because when she showed up at the front door of that woman's house, she was knocking on the door. She was bone dry. If she had been in the water...

There would be some, even at that point, there would be some evidence that she was in the water. And for him, that made it even more appalling. You know, over the years, Carol Gable, our producer, sort of kept in touch with Susan Smith and wrote her all these letters, I think knowing that this story was going to come back one day. Yeah. And you included some of those. Is Susan Smith still selling the story, you think?

Oh, no question. No question. These letters have never been shared. And you get a unique insight into what she was thinking then, what she thinks now. And I know you find this to be true with a lot of killers. There is this clear detachment from reality that still very much exists in the letters. And I found that strange. Right.

When we come back, we will have an extra clip from the interview with the chief of SLED, Mark Keel, who remembers where he was when Susan Smith confessed to killing her two sons.

Hey everybody, I'm Al Roker from the Today Show. Let's kickstart your wellness journey with the all-new Start Today app. Everything you need for a healthier you, all in one place. Fitness challenges for all levels. Meal plans that are easy and delicious. And so much more. It's built to fit your lifestyle and our experts will guide you every step of the way. Come on, let's do this. To subscribe, download Start Today from the App Store on your Apple device now. Terms apply. Cancel anytime through Apple under profile settings.

Every morning, we choose how to begin our day. I think about the people at home. They tune in because they are curious. They care about their world and they care about each other. There's always something new to learn, whether a news event or a new recipe. And when we step through the morning together, it makes the rest of the day better.

We come here to make the most of today. We are family. We are today. Watch the Today Show with Savannah Guthrie and Craig Melvin, weekdays at 7 a.m. on NBC. A true crime story never really ends.

Even when a case is closed, the journey for those left behind is just beginning. Since our Dateline story aired, Tracy has harnessed her outrage into a mission. I had no other option. I had to do something. Catch up with families, friends, and investigators on our bonus series, After the Verdict.

Ordinary people facing extraordinary circumstances with strength and courage. It does just change your life, but speaking up for these issues helps me keep going. To listen to After the Verdict, subscribe to Dateline Premium on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or at datelinepremium.com.

You know, when I saw Mark Keel in your episode, I realized that I had interviewed him before. I immediately recognized him and his name. And I have been racking my brain unsuccessfully, as it turns out, to try to remember what story it was that I interviewed him for. I can't remember. Now, he has not really talked about this case. No, in part because of not wanting to give air to Susan Smith.

No, in fact, this was the first time he talked about it on national television. I mean, he runs SLED now, South Carolina Law Enforcement Division. We actually talked to him during the Murdoch trial, which he had also not talked about before. But during this particular case, Chief Keel, he was in law school at the time.

but he was also an amateur pilot and he was part of the search team. So he would go to class. In fact, he talked about at one point, he skipped some class to go search for these two little boys or that black guy from the sketch. And this is for him as well. This is one of those stories that really has always stayed with him. And he was there at the parole hearing in November and,

Which he never does. This is full circle for him. I mean, he went from being like part-time on a pilot and now he's running SLED and he's still on this story. Yep. Yep. We have a little bit more of Craig's interview with the chief of SLED, Mark Keel. And he remembers very well what was going on back then and in the days after. Let's listen to that. What do you remember about the emotions of members of law enforcement back then after SLED?

we found out that she had an effect. It was very emotional. And I can remember seeing our agents and other law enforcement personnel as well, but specifically some of our agents that were standing in the back hallway at a courthouse and were just sobbing. And they were agents that had been to the scene when the car was pulled out of the water. And I know that there were some that said, you know, I wish I had not been there. I mean...

I saw emotions from agents that had been working homicide cases for years and years that you never saw emotion out of. Tough, tough guys, but you saw a lot of emotion that day.

I think to the chief's point, like even these guys who had, you know, I mean, you've been at SLED for a while. You've seen a murder. You know, you've seen probably a double murder, car accidents. You've seen some stuff. But to see two little boys who were still, when they hoisted that car from John D. Long Lake, they were still strapped in. And they'd been strapped in for nine days. So you can only imagine what these officers saw.

And by the way, and this is, I think, one of the other reasons that this case has resonated with so many for so long now, it wasn't just the killing of the children. It was the way that she did it. I completely agree. As odd as that may sound. No, I completely agree. Because there's no way that that was quick or painless. Correct. And anyone who's had small children,

You know, I remember kids are 10 and 8 now, and I remember the car seat phase. And, I mean, the car seat is sacrosanct. You just got to make sure they're buckled in the car seat. You got to have the car seat. You got to make sure the car—you become obsessed with the car seat. And to think that these two little boys, they get strapped in their car seats by their mother, and they die this slow death.

submerged in this lake that they'd... And I think that's for a lot of people. It's not...

It's not what she did. It's not why she did it. It's the way that she did it. Even now, 30 years later, that's the part that I think pisses me off the most. But, you know, David Smith, Mank, he is, and this is of the takeaways for me of the episode, I'd never met David before. Obviously, I knew who he was, and he doesn't do...

A lot of interviews at all. No. And he decided to sit down with us exclusively because he wanted to make sure that even though times have changed and the way we view abuse and depression, even though a lot of that has changed for us as a society, he did not want anyone using that lens to view abuse.

what happened to his two boys in a sympathetic light back in 1994. So begrudgingly, he decided to make sure that we remembered what she did and what his boys were like. That had to be tough. It was. And it's one of those things where, you know, you and I, you know, we've had some interviews that are hard and we've seen a lot. We've heard a lot. Quite frankly, we've probably become a little desensitized to a lot of

I did not fully appreciate the depth of his despair 30 years later. He talked about the two times that he nearly killed himself. He talked about not being able to get out of bed for months and just going to work. And you don't really think about this part of it, but for a very long time,

I mean, he was on TV every day for a long time. Everyone knew how the guy looked. And so he would have these strangers, well-meaning strangers, who would come up to him at the grocery store, the bank. I've been praying for you. I prayed for those boys. I prayed for Susan. I just...

And he had to leave town. He moved for a long time down to Florida just to get away from it. This is one of the things we've talked about before on previous episodes of Talking Dateline and elsewhere, which is there's this ripple effect to murder. It's not just the person. It's not just the immediate family. It doesn't go away because the person gets killed.

convicted or locked up. And those people that approach you in the supermarket, like they're well-meaning. Yes. But they're not letting you move on from this. Right? It also defines your life. Right. And you probably don't wish that, I mean, when you don't want it to, but it will anyway. And he said to me, I think it was off camera. It's not in the episode, but he said to me, he's like, when I die,

In my obit.

This will be included. It'll be the husband of, the ex-husband of. And that's, I mean, and think about it. I mean, that's just a, you know, and his new wife, God bless her. You know, Tiffany has been there. They got married in 2003, but she was there with him during all of this, during the search, during the trial. They went on, they had a child together, Savannah. She's 24 now. But she spent a fair amount of time talking about it.

For a very long time, she could not pull him out of what had to be the darkest of days. She talks about this period where he didn't really trust her, you know, because if this woman that he had known for all these years and had gotten married to, if she would do something so unspeakable. Someone he completely trusted. Correct. I really, there are a couple of times, he gets choked up, I get choked up.

What moved me the most, Mank, was he said to me, and it was one of those things where I don't know if he meant to say it, but after he said it, it stayed with me. He said one of the biggest problems now is 30 years later, he has a hard time remembering things.

And when he talked about it with his therapist early on, the therapist explained it away. The mind, in an attempt to protect itself, will guard you from certain memories because that'll just prolong the trauma. And the therapist was basically like, you'll get the memories back. You'll get the memories back. And he said, Craig, you're going to get them back.

The memories haven't come back. That saddened him to his soul. And you could tell that of all of the things that he wishes he could change, I think he just wishes that he had more memories of the boys. This is not something you get over. Nope. It's why I hate the word closure so much. I mean, she's locked up and she didn't get parole, but there's no closure here. No. Pretty clearly. And that's the thing. He points out every two years this could happen. Every two years. Yep.

She comes up for parole and she'll make her case every two years. And in at the next one, I mean, increasingly jurisdictions around the country are releasing older prisoners so they can stop paying for the cost of their health care. Assuming that Susan does not cause more problems behind bars, the odds go up just for that, that she's going to be released or that a parole board will want to release her.

And he knows that. And that's why he told me and his new wife, they'll be there every two years. You know, the parole board, by the way,

parole board in South Carolina, you'd be hard pressed to find a more conservative parole board. Like you don't, you commit a crime like this in South Carolina. Good luck ever getting out. We sat down with her lawyer, David Brock. And he's never talked about this. No, no, no, he never has. And by the way, David Brock also, you know, represents the Charleston church shooter. I mean, he's spent a lot of his time representing the,

Extremely unpopular defendants. Yes, that was a very diplomatic way of saying what I was thinking, but yes. And he sees it as a duty. And I said, David, should she be paroled? He said, well, yeah. I said, well, has she been rehabilitated? And he maintains that she has, but his larger point was she's not going to get out of prison at 60 years old and go find two more kids to kill.

He maintains that she's paid her debt for the murders, and she doesn't pose a threat to society. And the parole board sort of didn't buy it 30 years later. No. Did that surprise anybody? Was there anybody who thought that was going through? No. You know what? It didn't surprise anyone that I talked to, any of the legal experts, anybody.

You know, the vote was unanimous. No, it did not. It didn't surprise. After the break, we will be back with Dateline producer Carol Gable, and we will answer some of your questions from social media. Now they had the final answer. Or did they?

Nothing has more suspense than a Dateline mystery. And no one wants to wait to find out what happens next. That's why everyone needs Dateline Premium, where listening is always ad-free. You get the whole story and nothing but the story. Or do you? Yes, actually, you do. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or DatelinePremium.com.

It was late, past midnight, when they broke into the farmhouse. Never in a million years would you think that you'd see your parents' house taped off by that yellow tape. Wrong. And they said, you know, I'm dead of being killed. They left behind a wall of blood and the key to a secret. She looked at me and she said, I'm screwed. Murder in the Moonlight.

a new podcast from Dateline. To listen to the latest episodes each week completely free, you can find and follow Murder in the Moonlight on Pandora.

We are now joined by producer Carol Gable. Hi, nice to see you. Good to see you, Josh. You started working on this episode for Dateline back in 1994, which was actually even before I joined Dateline, which is what you and many other people refer to as the good old days. Tell me a little bit about your journey with this case. What sort of kept you working on it for so long? It was obvious that once she was arrested, Susan Smith said,

did not have an opportunity to talk about what had happened. As time went on, I really wanted to interview her. I thought that she was the center of one of the biggest stories in America, but we didn't know a lot about her. So when you write her, did you expect to hear back?

No, I mean, I didn't have any expectations at all. But I wrote her and explained that I had actually been in union the entire week the boys were missing and I had covered the trial. And I was surprised she wrote back. The thing that everybody asks about is remorse.

What do you detect from Susan Smith under that category? Total remorse. Consistent remorse. People ask me this question a lot, and it's almost like once you say and you show you're remorseful, why...

You know, what else can you say? Let me ask you a question that is not among the social media questions that we're going to be answering today, but it is one that I know is out there. Why are you, Dateline and Carol Gable and Craig Melvin,

giving this woman a platform to whine about her problems. She's a terrible person. She committed a horrible crime. She's right where she belongs. Why are you giving her any airtime? I think what we're giving is understanding, context, depth, and a bit more meaning. Not an excuse. It's not an excuse, but it's more information. Now we're going to listen to some audio questions, which were sent to us.

On social media. Okay. This is from Marion Marshall Hardy on Facebook. Hello. My name is Marion Marshall. My husband and I just finished watching Return to the Lake. And my question is, we were wondering where the 911 call was placed from. Was it in Union or was it in Carlisle? Because if she wouldn't have had a car...

Wouldn't it make a difference to know where the call was placed from? The Carlisle story was a made-up story that Susan told investigators before she confessed.

after Sheriff Wells said, you couldn't have been in Monarch, which is a part of Union, because the traffic light situation you report can't happen. That's when they realized, okay, this person's lying. There was no question about where the call was placed from at the time the call was placed, because it was from that woman's house that she ran to. Yes, it was. Yes, it was. And her son...

is the one who actually called 911. But everything happened near that lake. Here's another audio question. This one from Gail Pannis on Facebook. Hi, my name is Gail. I've got a question about tonight's episode. Beverly Russell was Susan Smith's stepfather. Did the mother stay married to Beverly Russell after all this came out?

In court, they did get divorced. I don't know the time frame, but fairly soon after, they did get divorced. That's it for the audio questions today. Now we're going to go to other questions from social media. Southern Beach Girl says, I'm sure David or other family members would have been happy to take those babies in, and she could still have run off with the other guy. Of course, anyone in that town would have taken those boys.

In her mind, and she has said this to me, in her mind at that moment, she could not leave her boys like her dad left her when he committed suicide. Eight Lawana says, I can't believe it's been 30 years. Those little boys would have went to college and had lives of their own, if not for Susan's selfishness. And that is something I always think about when kids are involved, which is,

the life that went unlived. Well, you can't help but think about that, you know, what might have been.

And it's really hard. And that's why this is a very searing, searing story. Carol, thank you very much. And thanks, everybody, for listening. Now, remember, if you have any questions for us about our stories or any case that you think we should be covering, you can reach out to us on social at at Dateline NBC, or you can send us an audio message for a chance to be featured in our next Talking Dateline episode. Also,

Do not forget about Keith's all-new podcast called Murder in the Moonlight. It's very, very good, and I know that because Keith told me that personally. So you can listen to the first two episodes of Murder in the Moonlight right now for free. For early access to future episodes and to listen to all Dateline podcasts ad-free, which I know you want to do, subscribe to Dateline Premium on Apple, Spotify, or at datelinepremium.com.

See you next Friday for an all-new Dateline on NBC.