We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode Should Mindfulness Teachers Show Vulnerability?

Should Mindfulness Teachers Show Vulnerability?

2024/10/25
logo of podcast Mindfulness Exercises

Mindfulness Exercises

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
S
Sean Fargo
Topics
Sean Fargo:在教授正念的过程中,展现脆弱性以建立与学员之间的信任是一个复杂的问题。过度的脆弱性可能会降低老师的权威性,而完全的封闭又会阻碍与学员的深入连接。 理想的状态是找到一个平衡点,既能展现真实的自我,分享个人经验和挑战,又能保持专业性和权威性。这需要根据具体情况和学员的需求来调整,避免过度分享个人隐私或负面情绪,同时也要避免过度塑造完美的形象。 Sean Fargo分享了他自己以及其他正念老师在处理这个问题上的不同方式,有的老师非常封闭,扮演着“大师”的角色;有的老师则过于随意,分享过多个人弱点。他认为,大多数优秀的正念老师能够在真实和分享之间找到平衡,分享过去的经验教训,但不会过度坦露。 Sean Fargo还强调了信任的复杂性,它不仅仅是理性的分析,更是一种发自内心的感受。建立信任需要通过自我反思和修复来完成,包括自我原谅、寻求原谅以及对自身和他人进行反思。在教学过程中,正念老师可以反思自己希望从老师那里获得什么,这有助于理解脆弱性的作用。 最后,Sean Fargo认为,最好的正念老师能够自嘲,并能够在严肃和轻松之间切换,展现出真实的自我,从而建立与学员之间的信任。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why is showing vulnerability important for mindfulness teachers?

Showing vulnerability helps mindfulness teachers build trust and rapport with their students. It allows them to be authentic and relatable, which can deepen connections and make their teachings more impactful. However, it requires a delicate balance to avoid oversharing or undermining credibility.

What are the risks of mindfulness teachers being too vulnerable?

If mindfulness teachers share too much about their insecurities or shortcomings, it can lead students to question their credibility. Oversharing might make students wonder why they are learning from someone who appears to struggle with the very practices they are teaching.

How do different mindfulness teachers approach vulnerability?

Some teachers remain closed off, adopting a guru-like persona, while others are overly open, sharing too much about their personal challenges. Most teachers strike a balance, being authentic and sharing enough to connect with students without undermining their authority.

What role does trust play in mindfulness teaching?

Trust is crucial in mindfulness teaching as it fosters a safe and open learning environment. Trust is often felt more in the heart than the head, and it can be strengthened through authenticity, humor, and a willingness to be real without being overly self-deprecating.

How can mindfulness teachers balance vulnerability and professionalism?

Mindfulness teachers can balance vulnerability and professionalism by sharing personal experiences of overcoming challenges without oversharing. They should aim to be authentic, relatable, and approachable while maintaining credibility and authority in their teachings.

What qualities make a mindfulness teacher trustworthy?

A trustworthy mindfulness teacher is authentic, able to laugh at themselves, and not overly serious or profound all the time. They avoid pretending to be someone they're not and create a sense of trust by being real and relatable.

Shownotes Transcript

Translations:
中文

This episode is brought to you by Amazon. Sometimes the most painful part of getting sick is the getting better part. Waiting on hold for an appointment, sitting in crowded waiting rooms, standing in line at the pharmacy, that's painful. Amazon One Medical and Amazon Pharmacy remove those painful parts of getting better with things like 24-7 virtual visits and prescriptions delivered to your door. Thanks to Amazon Pharmacy and Amazon One Medical, healthcare just got less painful.

Should I show my vulnerability teaching mindfulness as a way to instill trust from others? Should I be forthcoming about my weaknesses, my challenges as a way to build rapport with people who I'm helping to teach mindfulness to? How do we navigate this territory? How much do we share? How much do we show that we know things?

It's a tricky dance. And so I'd love to help you in navigating that territory to help you identify how vulnerable you should be when you're helping others to be present and self-compassionate and resilient. How much should you divulge? What's appropriate in certain circumstances?

I've certainly made that mistake and learned the hard way many times in my years of teaching mindfulness. I've taught for the mindfulness program born at Google. I was a monk for a couple years in the Buddhist Thai tradition. I was at Spirit Rock Meditation Center for five years full-time supporting Jack Kornfield and a lot of the senior teachers there. And

I've seen other teachers kind of navigate this territory very differently. Some teachers are very closed off and they don't really show much persona or personality or, you know, authenticity. Quite frankly, they kind of play a role as a guru, if you will.

Other teachers are the opposite, where they're very loosey-goosey. Maybe they might go into the deep end on divulging everything and sharing maybe too much about their insecurities, their shortcomings, their

bad habits where it's like, wait, why am I learning mindfulness from you? What's going on here? Should I be teaching you how to be mindful?

Most mindfulness teachers are a little bit in the middle where they're themselves, they're authentic. They divulge a little bit about what they've learned from the past, how they've overcome challenges, but they're also real and not too forthcoming. So

There's definitely a delicate balance here, but I want to share a clip with you of an interaction that I had with someone who's in our mindfulness teacher certification program and who had this question, like, how vulnerable should I be in order to instill trust?

from others? Do we need to be vulnerable to get trust? You know, it's a tricky terrain here. So I'd love to share this clip with you of a raw, impromptu interaction with someone who had this question. I want to share my thoughts on this and get your feedback. You know, does this resonate with you? How vulnerable are you when you teach mindfulness?

How vulnerable do you want your teachers, your mindfulness and meditation teachers to be in sharing their own life story? Some of us crave more stories and vulnerability, and some of us are repelled by it. But I'd love to get your take on how you relate to this. And if you're teaching mindfulness, how vulnerable are you? How scary is it to be vulnerable? Have you found that balance for yourself?

And then if you want to teach mindfulness meditation with this balance of vulnerability and instilling trust, then we'd be honored to support you and our mindfulness teacher certification program. The link is below. But regardless, I hope that you enjoy the following clip.

And I hope that it provides a lot of value for you. Thank you. Yeah, there's so much to unpack with trust and what trust is or what it means, you know, and then there's parallels with confidence, faith. For me, reading the book Loving Kindness was really helpful for sensing into the layers of trust.

which for me over the years is less and less in the head and more and more in the heart. I think it's really easy to think of trust as sort of a logical analysis. For me, trust exponentially increases if it's felt in the heart. You know, if it's hard to trust, you know, often there's, you know,

repair work that can be done, forgiveness work, forgiving others, asking for forgiveness, and forgiving self, journaling. What are the conditions for trust for certain people, for ourselves? What are the things that we ultimately have unshakable trust in, if anything? And we're

And why? Some people include mindfulness in that category or presence or whatever, what words we want to use. But some people put mindfulness in that category. What do we trust about ourselves? That could be really rich exploration. But when we're teaching mindfulness or sharing it with others,

Yeah, we can reflect on, you know, like, what would I want in a teacher to trust them? It's going to connect with the vulnerability piece that you're talking about. And, you know, are they pretending to be a certain way? You know, like,

You know, can I be vulnerable in certain ways to invite a sense of trust? You know, not to be overly self-deprecating, but to be real. And, you know, some mindfulness teachers will kind of fake it till they make it in the sense that, like, they feel like they need to be a certain way. They need to be like a famous mindfulness teacher they like, or they need to, I don't know, be like a monk or

They need to kind of be perfect in how they move. They need to be calm all the time and smooth and all that stuff. You know, and people can usually tell that they're faking it. You know, my favorite mindfulness teachers are the ones that can laugh at themselves or just laugh at life, you know, not in a sarcastic way.

demeaning way but just find the humor in life so you know maybe not being overly serious or overly profound thousand percent of the time yeah there's these cycles of depth and lightness thank you yeah it's very helpful