We're sunsetting PodQuest on 2025-07-28. Thank you for your support!
Export Podcast Subscriptions
cover of episode What's A Weather Forecast Worth?

What's A Weather Forecast Worth?

2024/12/14
logo of podcast Short Wave

Short Wave

AI Deep Dive AI Insights AI Chapters Transcript
People
K
Keith Sider
M
Mary Glackin
美国气象学会前总统,曾任NOAA运营副部长和The Weather Company高级副总裁,多次获得美国总统级别奖励和其他荣誉。
R
Renato Molina
Topics
Adrienne Ma & Waylon Wong: 近年来,天气预报的准确性显著提高,成为一个数十亿美元的产业。但同时也引发了政府和私营公司之间关于天气数据控制权和价格的争议,涉及数据获取、价格、以及政府和私营部门在天气预报中的角色。 Keith Sider: 过去几十年里,私营部门参与天气预报的规模急剧扩大,从小型公司到大型科技公司,都参与其中。这导致政府和私营公司之间出现摩擦,主要体现在数据获取和价格方面。美国国家气象局致力于免费向公众提供高质量数据,但这与一些依靠销售专业天气预报服务的私营公司利益相冲突。私营公司开始发射自己的气象卫星并销售数据,使得政府部门也成为其客户,这使得政府在天气数据供应和需求方面角色模糊,引发新的争议。 Mary Glackin: 航空业是政府和私营部门在天气预报方面合作的成功案例,双方可以共享信息,共同提高预报准确性,例如在航班延误或取消的决策中。 Renato Molina: 准确的天气预报是公共产品,因为它具有非竞争性和非排他性,对所有人都有益,并且能够产生巨大的社会价值,例如减少飓风造成的损失。准确的飓风预报能够促使人们采取有效的防护措施,从而减少损失,例如及时的疏散能够避免更大的灾难。 政府的角色:政府部门,如美国国家气象局,是天气数据的主要来源,其职责是保护生命和财产,并向所有人免费提供天气数据。然而,随着私营部门的扩张,政府的角色变得更加复杂,既是数据的提供者,也是消费者。 私营部门的角色:私营公司利用政府提供的数据,结合自身技术,提供更专业、更细致的天气预报服务,并向特定客户收费。这引发了关于数据获取、价格以及政府与私营部门合作方式的争议。 合作的可能性:政府和私营部门可以在天气预报领域开展合作,例如航空业的成功案例表明,双方共享信息可以提高预报准确性,并更好地服务于公众。 公共产品的属性:准确的天气预报具有公共产品的属性,因为它对所有人都有益,并且一个人的使用不会影响其他人的使用。因此,政府应该确保所有人能够平等地获得准确的天气预报信息。

Deep Dive

Key Insights

Why has weather forecasting become a crowded industry?

The rise of the Internet and big tech has led to increased competition in weather forecasting, with companies like Microsoft and Google entering the market to produce more sophisticated and precise forecasts.

What is the role of the National Weather Service in the U.S.?

The National Weather Service, part of NOAA, collects data and makes forecasts to protect life and property, providing weather data universally as a public service.

How do private companies use government weather data?

Private companies take data from NOAA and the National Weather Service, apply proprietary computer models, and sell specialized data and hyper-local forecasts to customers dependent on weather, such as utility companies or airlines.

What are the tensions between the government and private weather companies?

Tensions arise from the National Weather Service's ethos of providing data for free, which competes with private companies selling specialized forecasts, and the flow of weather data, as private companies now launch satellites and sell data to NOAA.

How has the government's role in weather data changed?

The government now acts as both a supplier and a customer of weather data, buying data from private companies, which complicates the traditional model of providing data for free.

What is an example of government and private sector collaboration in weather forecasting?

The aviation industry serves as a model, with private and federal forecasters collaborating to advise airlines on flight cancellations and delays during weather events.

What is the economic concept of a public good, and how does it apply to weather forecasts?

A public good is something that can be used by multiple people without diminishing and is available to everyone. Accurate weather forecasts, such as hurricane predictions, meet this criteria as they benefit society collectively.

What is the estimated value of improved hurricane forecasts?

Improved hurricane forecasts have led to $7 billion in avoided damages and costs since 2009, as they enable timely evacuations and protective measures.

Shownotes Transcript

The federal government has been tracking the weather for more than 150 years. Yet over the last few decades, the rise of the Internet and big tech have made weather forecasting a more crowded space. Today, our colleagues at NPR's daily economics podcast The Indicator)* report on the value of an accurate forecast and the debate over who should control weather data. Follow The Indicator on Apple Podcasts) or Spotify). Listen to every episode of Short Wave sponsor-free and support our work at NPR by signing up for Short Wave+ at* plus.npr.org/shortwave*).*Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices)NPR Privacy Policy)